news-record.com

NEWS

School groups back 1-cent tax

Sunday, May 8, 2011
(Updated 3:02 am)

RALEIGH — Call it the one-cent solution.

Faced with the prospect of a state budget that would cut thousands of teaching jobs across the state — the exact number is a matter of some debate — public schools boosters are calling for lawmakers to keep a one-cent temporary sales tax that is set to expire July 1.

The extension would put roughly $1 billion into the state treasury next year — without which school officials say they’ll be forced to lay off teachers and teaching assistants.

“This is a self-inflicted wound and has more to do with political promises than with common good,” said Bill McNeil, executive director of the N.C. Association of School Administrators.

McNeil and his organization are part of an alliance of 40 school and business groups called the Quality Schools Coalition. Included are the Guilford Education Alliance and the Piedmont Triad Education Consortium.

They argue extending the temporary one-penny tax would cost the average taxpayer less than 25 cents per day, or about $90 per year.

But Republicans who control the state House and Senate this year ran on promises not to raise taxes. Keeping a temporary tax would be tantamount to a tax increase, they say.

“We believe if we can leave more money in the pockets of individual citizens and small businesses, that in and of itself will have a positive effect on job numbers,” Senate President Pro Tempore Phil Berger, an Eden Republican, said last week.

Not only are Republicans looking to let the one-cent temporary sales tax expire, they also plan roughly $230 million worth of additional tax cuts next year.

When the House finished its work on the $19.3 billion budget last week, lawmakers proposed reducing state spending on public schools by 9 percent and spending on the state universities by 15 percent.

Although those percentages may be tweaked by the Senate as it takes up the budget this week, Berger’s chamber is unlikely to make public education boosters feel any better. He said last week the House budget ticked over spending limits agreed to by House and Senate budget negotiators early on in the process.

“The Senate budget will come closer to the original targets,” he said.

Sen. Jerry Tillman, an Archdale Republican and a chairman of two education committees, said cuts will definitely affect schools and may not be obvious before local school officials put their final budgets in place.

“It will squeeze them; it will put some pressure on them,” Tillman said.

For example, while the House budget pays for all state-funded teaching positions, it requires schools to hand back millions of dollars in unspecified cuts to the state.

“To make those cuts and not affect the classroom is going to be very, very hard,” Tillman said.

But even with schools facing hard decisions, he said, Republicans are right to focus on letting the temporary tax expire.

“Yes, there’s going to be unmet needs. Yes, it would be nice to have that $800 million or $1 billion. But it would also be nice to keep our word ... We believe that billion-plus-dollars we’re going to let the taxpayers keep is going to spur the economy,” he said.

That leaves groups such as the Quality School Coalition girding for an all-out lobbying campaign on behalf of schools, pledging to bring teachers, parents and others to Raleigh every week to try to change lawmakers’ minds.

They point to polls, including a recent Elon University Poll, that show support for keeping the sales tax ranging from 70 to 80 percent of those surveyed.

Gov. Bev Perdue, a Democrat, called for keeping most of the temporary tax in her budget and has argued throughout the spring that lawmakers would cut too deeply without more revenue. Last week, Perdue penned an editorial slamming the House budget for its “staggering cuts” to classrooms.

If the education fight comes to a veto, Perdue can afford to lose only three House Democrats or Republicans can override her rejection. Those numbers were front of mind last week when five House Democrats voted for the Republican budget.

However, at least three of those Democrats have said they would back Perdue’s veto if she rejected budget with the current level of education cuts.

When asked if that necessarily meant keeping the temporary sales tax or raising another tax, Rep. Bill Owens, an Elizabeth City Democrat, said “No.

“No. There are some other options,” Owens said.

He did not specify what those options might be. But he said it would be a good idea for Republicans to keep talking with Perdue and avoid a showdown.

 

Contact Mark Binker at (919) 832-5549 or mark.binker@news-record.com

 

Accompanying Photos

File photo (News & Record)

Photo Caption: North Carolina legislative building in Raleigh.

Comments

This article has been closed to new comments. Comments are generally closed after 14 days. However, comments may be closed earlier at the discretion of the News & Record.

Inappropriate content? Please report abuse.

RonaldusMagnus

May 8, 2011 - 7:48 am EDT

I am so glad that we voted the Republicans in last election. If democrats had total control as they have in recent years they would definitely let the "temporary" tax expire and be looking to add more taxes. We just need to replace the gov next election and maybe this state will began to head in the right direction. A few more years of the liberal democrats in control and we would be as bad off as California. They just do not get it. We have been nickel and dimed to death.

polly1964

May 8, 2011 - 9:58 am EDT

The state should use the nc education lottery for any additional education needs. As of now the nc lottery is not being used for education. This makes the nc education lottery a fraud.

destinys mother in law

May 8, 2011 - 10:42 am EDT

Oh my goodness! Raising taxes for education? Sounds like socialism to me

jackhartjj

May 8, 2011 - 10:42 am EDT

I for one am sick and tired of raising taxes while at the same time more and more folks are sucking off the public teat! Whether it is more folks getting hired for 'guvmit' jobs...or more sorry, lazy folks letting the two or so years of unemployment run out and apply for and get disability because they are 'bipolar'!
And I am quite frankly tired of hearing folks in the 'education industry' scream every time folks talk about not giving every last cent to 'the children'! When less than half of folks that work in the schools are teachers...there is a MAJOR problem! When I went to school from 1963 to 1975 or so there was a teacher per class, a couple of custodians, several in the cafeteria, several in the office and the coaches. No we did not have teacher assistants, the one teacher did just fine!
Let the one cent tax end. Period!

Panacea

May 8, 2011 - 3:48 pm EDT

OK, let's correct a few misconceptions.

First of all, government does required people to run services. Most government employees are involved in teaching in the classrooms, dealing with waste disposal, fixing the roads, collecting taxes, providing law enforcement, and many other services that people need and want. They're doing real work. That is not living off the public teat. That is doing a regular job like folks who work in the private sector.

Second: many people who are on unemployment are there through no fault of their own. The economy has been bad; they can't find work.

Third: disability is a federal, not state program. And it is very hard to get. Most people who apply are rejected the first time. It takes on average about a year to get disability, and not everyone who applies gets it.

Fourth: Bipolar disorder is no joke. Be glad you don't have it.

Fifth: Many teachers would agree with you that the system is top heavy with administrators who won't let them do their jobs. Vilifying education is the last thing they need however. The job requirements of a teacher have greatly changed since 1975. There is a long trail of documentation they have to complete. Until we make changes to empower teachers in the classrooms, they are stuck doing what they have to do.

Bottom line is, we need to extend the 1 cent tax. We can't afford not let it expire.

RonaldusMagnus

May 8, 2011 - 9:13 pm EDT

You admit the system is broken yet we can't afford to let the temporary tax expire! Is there a limit to the amount of money that you think the government should be allowed to confiscate from us(the productive part of society). Your argument is not logical.

snapandwhistle

May 8, 2011 - 11:02 pm EDT

What is not logical is saying that letting people keep $90 per year will help bring back jobs while at the same time laying off THOUSANDS of State employees who (drum roll please) will be competing with everyone for those supposed jobs that will be created. The Governor's proposal would let part of the temporary tax expire this coming year and the rest expire the next year, thereby allowing the Republicans to keep their promise to "lower taxes." That is called compromise and it is the reason our form of government was created nearly 222 years ago with its different branches. Republicans seem to forget that now as the Democrats did when they were in charge.

ravencottage

May 9, 2011 - 7:22 am EDT

snapandwhistle it is not the responsibility of the local, state and federal government to provide you, me or anyone else with a job. Those who accept positions as public servants do so willingly and are foolish to expect lifetime career positions with benefits and full retirement from entities whose only source of income is the forced confiscation of wealth.

snapandwhistle

May 9, 2011 - 8:31 am EDT

I did not say that it was the government's responsibility to provide jobs. It is the government's responsibility to provide quality services for the money it takes. If you think that those services can be provided by poorly paid, mistreated workers who constantly fear losing their jobs, I'd sure hate to work for you in the private sector or be your customer. What I am saying is that for $90 each, North Carolina citizens can avoid crippling the education system of our state and avoid dropping thousands of unemployed workers into an already bleak job market. Oh, and those workers will be on unemployment, just like the ones from the private sector. Why is it that you and people of your mindset think that I don't pay taxes, buy goods, and do other things that stimulate the economy just because I am a State employee?

I'm sorry that my country and its form of government are such a burden to you and such an object of your ire. A quick search on the Internet will provide you with a long list of countries that do not require foreign nationals to pay taxes and do not do a very good job of collecting taxes from its citizens. Three of the articles I read have Iraq at the top of the list. If you get Rosetta Stone, you can learn Arabic and be gone before next April 15.

ravencottage

May 9, 2011 - 5:55 pm EDT

snapandwhistle to hear the government employee unions tell it, all bureaucrats are poorly paid, mistreated and in constant fear of losing their jobs. If you are so worried about your future why don't you wean yourself from the government teat? I'm betting the agency that employs you will not even notice you're gone.

snapandwhistle

May 10, 2011 - 10:15 am EDT

Well, it usually only takes a few interactions in this forum before people like you show your absolute ignorance. North Carolina is an at will state. There are no government employee unions because we do not have collective bargaining. I believe that unions have outlived their usefullness and have contributed to many of the economic problems in our country.

As far as my job, I only have five years left before retirement, which I earned. I am the head of a State agency with nearly 80 employees. My goal is to develop my employees so that I am not missed when I leave. That is what good leaders do.

I will get my chance in the private sector once I retire. I'll either be a highly paid consultant because I used my off time to get post graduate degrees and become an expert in my field, or I'll go bag groceries at Harris Teeter. Either way, I will retire knowing I made a difference in my community and in my state. How about you?

snapandwhistle

May 9, 2011 - 8:33 am EDT

Sorry, I almost forgot. Have you looked up Chapter 135 of the North Carolina General Statutes? I would be foolish to think that the State would comply with its own laws.

HotRodLincoln

May 8, 2011 - 1:23 pm EDT

One cent....

copper1

May 8, 2011 - 3:21 pm EDT

Speaking of one cent, has anyone checked the state jobs page? There's NO freeze on hiring or spending the taxpayers money. The DOC is hiring truck drivers, construction supervisors, and other non-critical positions. Others are following suite, they can't hire enough dead weight. To have the newly infected officials say they want "smaller" government is foolish. They will continue to seek only one cent until we the taxpayer is broke.

Panacea

May 8, 2011 - 3:58 pm EDT

Organizations with open positions can still hire . . . otherwise the state would not be able to counter normal turnover due to firings, retirements, or resignations.

There are limits on promotion and advancement. State workers have not gotten a raise in 3 years. I earned merit pay in 2008, but it was rescinded due to the economy and it has not been offered since.

To say state agencies are hiring "dead weight" just shows you know very little about what state workers really do.

ravencottage

May 8, 2011 - 7:53 pm EDT

We all know what state and federal employees do who work in the bowels of the bureaucracies. We also know we don't miss them one bit when they all take one of those many 3 day weekends. I wish you could have been listening in last week when I tried to report fraud involving Section 8 housing.

snapandwhistle

May 8, 2011 - 11:04 pm EDT

Really? Tell me the last time you were in the "bowels" of some State agency.

ravencottage

May 9, 2011 - 7:28 am EDT

DMV, ESC

snapandwhistle

May 9, 2011 - 8:43 am EDT

All I see when I go there is people working hard to get things done with far fewer people than they had 5 years ago. I don't consider front line workers the "bowels" of bureaucracy. You are the same person who stands in line for 20 minutes to get your driver's license, spends the rest of the day complaining about how long it took, and then writes a letter to the editor demanding more cuts in State employment. When is the last time you were at the ESC? Surely you would never accept any money from the "public teet." Because you are wealthy, you would never go there to look for a job! So, how do you know what happens at the ESC, unless you are a business owner who routinely fires employees?

ravencottage

May 9, 2011 - 5:58 pm EDT

I'm thinking you must be one of those ever smiling, friendly faces behind the counter at DMV!

rc378

May 9, 2011 - 9:54 am EDT

freeze on hiring or not - teacher's salaries have been frozen for the past three years. of course, since we're living off the public teat, we don't really deserve to be paid in exchange for our labor.

ravencottage

May 9, 2011 - 6:02 pm EDT

Actually rc378, considering some of the products of our schools, you may well be right.

snapandwhistle

May 10, 2011 - 10:09 am EDT

Any poor "products of our schools" are more the result of the lack of discipline and involvement at home than the result of a lack of effort from teachers. In an effort to be politically correct, schools and legislators have stripped the teachers of their ability to maintain discipline in the classroom. Not only should the teachers be paid, they should get combat pay for doing their jobs.

coasterguy65

May 8, 2011 - 10:53 pm EDT

So what exactly is the North Carolina Educational Lotttery contributing to help our schools again? Our state educational system seems to be way worse off now than before the Lootery.

Speaking of looting...if this extra one cent tax stays in effect will it actually make it to any of the school systems or will it be pulled to fund other projects as the legislature sees fit?

eMail Updates

Advertisement | Advertise with Us

Featured Ads

Search

Advertisement | Advertise with Us
Advertisement | Advertise with Us
Advertisement | Advertise with Us

News & Record Network Sites

User Tools

  • Social Networking
  • RSS
  • Share
  • Sign in to MyNR

Search