news-record.com

OPINION

Kathleen Parker: Cartoonist touches nerve across America

Wednesday, April 28, 2010
(Updated 3:00 am)

WASHINGTON -- Once you've gone viral, there's no turning back.

That's the hard lesson for a Seattle cartoonist who sketched some doodles and unwittingly launched a movement.

Molly Norris, a reluctant phenomenon, wants to return to her quiet artist's life, the one she lived largely unnoticed until she drew the Prophet Muhammad -- as a spool of thread, a box of pasta, a cup of coffee, a domino, a cherry and a doggie purse.

Take your pick. Since depictions of Muhammad aren't allowed under some (but not all) interpretations of Islam, no one knows what he looks like. And, bummer alert, anyone who tries to capture his likeness is subject to punishment by death.

The text on Norris' cartoon, a poster calling for a national "Everybody Draw Muhammed Day" on May 20, reads: "Will the REAL likeness of the prophet Mohammed please stand up?!"

Clever girl, but perhaps too clever?

Her idea, which Norris insists was intended only to serve as a stand-alone cartoon -- not a movement! -- has spawned a Facebook page that boasted almost 8,500 members by Tuesday morning. Apparently, lots and lots of people want to see this thing through.

Not Norris, who was merely trying to express solidarity with Trey Parker and Matt Stone, the "South Park" creators threatened by a radical Muslim group (or 12 guys and a website) offended by a recent episode not depicting Muhammad. Actually, the cartoon Muhammad was wearing a bear costume.

Horrors. (One can't even muster the requisite outrage to install exclamation points.) But seriously?

Seriously!!!

One Abu Talhah Al-Amrikee (aka Zachary Chesser of Virginia) posted a warning on the Revolution Muslim website suggesting that Parker and Stone might wind up the way murdered filmmaker Theo van Gogh did. Van Gogh's offense was making a film about Islam's abuse of women.

In response to the threat, the bosses at Comedy Central knelt before the altar of -- no joke -- political correctness and censored a subsequent episode, bleeping all mentions of Muhammad, as well as a short segment about fear and censorship.

Who could have guessed that the clash of civilizations would be fought by cartoon characters?

Enter Norris, who had the simple idea that this was silliness and deserved further poking. And then things really got out of control. Norris wants out and has begun to distance herself from the fray, which has taken on a life of its own.

Until recently, her website featured a banner: "I am NOT involved in 'Everybody Draw Muhammd [sic] Day!'" A new cartoon shows Norris wearing a peace-sign T-shirt seated at her drawing board in a swirl of balloon thoughts: "I am a cartoonist. I never 'launched' a day to draw Mohammed." "Good thing I am married to a SUMO WRESTLER!" "This was always about the freedom to draw what we want in the U.S.A." And perhaps most to the point:

"I have hit some kind of gigantic nerve."

Indeed you have, Ms. Molly. But there's a reason you hit a nerve, and it bears further discussion. Gigantic nerves are repositories of truth. Once you've tapped one, exploding electric currents ricochet across the landscape of the human psyche. A light goes on in a Seattle studio, and suddenly the nation is illuminated by a bright idea.

The truth is that Americans love their free speech and have had enough of those who think they can dictate the limits of that fundamental right. Americans also love humor and the irreverence that underpins the joke.

You might say irreverence is our national religion. It keeps us from taking ourselves too seriously and from killing each other over differences of opinion. Cartoons get under our skin in special ways, driving past our defenses and aiming right for the heart of our self-importance. That's why we respond so emotionally.

Barring the occasional offensive punch line, humor is a mostly pleasant test of our allegiance to founding principles. Think of it this way: The degree to which one can tolerate ribbing about one's most deeply held convictions is the degree to which a society can remain free. We honor that notion through our laws and our sense of humor. We may not all laugh at the same things, but most understand that it ain't personal.

Norris' cartoon was a fine idea, but she should be relieved of further duty or responsibility. As for the rest of you characters: Draw to any heart's discontent. It's a free country.

For now.

Kathleen Parker's e-mail address is kathleenparker@washpost.com

Comments

This article has been closed to new comments. Comments are generally closed after 14 days. However, comments may be closed earlier at the discretion of the News & Record.

Inappropriate content? Please report abuse.

Get A Clue

April 28, 2010 - 5:29 am EDT

I'm not Catholic, so should I practice birth control using a condom (something the Pope doesn't like), I don't really care if it bothers a Catholic.
I'm not Jewish, so when I enjoy another pulled pork sandwich, I don't really care about not keeping Kosher.
And I'm not a Muslim, so whatever I draw or depict or even poke fun or direct political commentary at--including Mohammed--is a right I'll happily continue to practice.
Look, if your magikal skye being is so persnickety that he can't handle condoms, bacon or pictures of him, then it's time you invented a new thing to pray to.
Or, better still, get off your knees (since it doesn't matter which way you bow, anyway) and just get busy. To paraphrase a post from another thread:
We don't need a "National Day of Prayer." We could use one day, for a change, devoted to solving problems with thought, reason and action instead.
I'm with you on this one Kathleen. Draw whatever you want to draw. This is still the United States of America.

danagain

April 28, 2010 - 9:31 am EDT

Wow, for once I agree with Mr. Clue. There is however a PC double standard. Christians and Jews are fair game for ridicule yet try it on Muslims and all hell breaks out as witnessed by the South Park episode and with the Danish cartoonist.

Here are the...ahem...offensive cartoons:

http://media.bonnint.net/seattle/3/373/37326.jpg

BTW I am a Catholic and could care less if you practice contraception and/or how you do it.

Panacea

April 28, 2010 - 10:00 pm EDT

There is a double standard: mock Christians in a cartoon, and there is outrage and calls for more "sensitivity." Mock Muhammad, and "it's just freedom of speech, get a grip."

I'm fine with political cartoons poking fun at what ever they want. I do find some offensive, but I would never call for restrictions on free speech.

"I may not agree with what you have to say, but I will defend with my life your right to say it."

Kit9

April 28, 2010 - 7:23 am EDT

Radical Muslims. That is Muslims who harbor feelings of possible terrorism using violence or threats and state it, should be immediately imprisoned and then deported.
IMMEDIATELY! This is America not the Middle East. Look at the Muslimazation of Europe and see what trouble they are in. They are scrambling to protect their own citizen from this scourge. I see nothing wrong with the peaceful practice of Islam. Radicals must BE DEPORTED IMMEDIATELY!

Panacea

April 28, 2010 - 10:05 pm EDT

I agree. Let's round up Pat Robertson, James Dobson, Robert Grant, Billy and Frank Graham, and ship them to the Holey Land.

worker ant

April 28, 2010 - 11:59 am EDT

I'll bet Kathleen Parker wouldn't approve of a cartoon depicting a gay teen at Riverdale High.

danagain

April 28, 2010 - 12:19 pm EDT

Gymnaseum

April 28, 2010 - 8:47 pm EDT

Great link, danagain. Terrific column by Parker.

As the poster of the aforementioned paraphrased comment, let me clarify: I think a National Day of Prayer is fine and harmless. I'd love if equal time was given to humanists and those who champion Enlightenment practices...and maybe we could apply those principles year-round for a change.

Finally, I teach a class in art and humor, and have practiced some political cartooning my self. I am afraid Parker is being overly rosy about the country's factions enjoying a good laugh at their chosen allegiances or ethnic/cultural backgrounds. In the current polarized climate (getting less polar all the time, according to Al Gore), I think there isn't as much room for the most biting artists to maneuver anymore.

eMail Updates

Advertisement | Advertise with Us

Featured Ads

Search

Advertisement | Advertise with Us
Advertisement | Advertise with Us
Advertisement | Advertise with Us

News & Record Network Sites

User Tools

  • Mobile
  • Social
  • RSS
  • Share
  • Sign in to MyNR

Search