news-record.com

OPINION

Counterpoint: Health care reform bill lacks support

Thursday, December 10, 2009
(Updated 3:00 am)

By Nancy Mays

In response to the Nov. 29 opinion piece by state Reps. Alma Adams and Pricey Harrison ("N.C. needs passage of health care reform"), I offer the opposing view that the state most certainly does not need passage of this bill.

This legislation is nothing more than a power grab to take over another segment of our economy.

We are losing our God-given freedoms each and every day as an over-reaching Washington cabal sucks the life-breath out of America.

I take exception to the points in the opinions of these Guilford County representatives. In the first sentence, they define this debate as a partisan political battle.

May I remind that Republican representation is in the minority in both the House and Senate and, as such, is totally powerless to stop passage of this legislation?

Another claim that the cost of health insurance has risen by 80 percent since 2001 is misleading. The implication is that greedy health insurers are taking advantage of their subscribers.

However, health insurers posted a modest 2.2 percent profit margin last year which ranks them 35th in the Fortune 500.
The rate increases are due to many factors, including advances in new technology and screening methods that are far more costly than those previously employed.

And let us not forget that our medical bills are necessarily inflated to cover the outrageous cost of professional liability insurance medical providers are forced to carry to protect themselves from frivolous lawsuits. Meaningful tort reform legislation would do more to reduce the cost of health care.

Another point of contention is the article’s assumption that when the government takes over, everyone will get everything they need. In reality, a recent American Medical Association study found that Medicare’s claim denial rate is higher than that of any private insurer, and almost 70 percent higher overall than private insurers’ average denial rate.

The Nov. 25 Rasmussen Poll shows the lowest number ever in support of this health care reform. Only 35 percent are in favor while 56 percent are opposed.

Where are the representatives who listen to the voice of the people?

The writer lives in Trinity.

Comments

This letter has been closed to new comments. Comments are accepted on select letters to the editor between the hours of 7 AM and 5 PM, EDT, Monday through Friday.

Inappropriate content? Please report abuse.

xeno10

December 10, 2009 - 5:07 am EST

Ms. Mays, please get thee back to your "booby hatch" -- in Trinity! ( And your LTTE rant reminds me of Republican Sen. Orrin Hatch!) I suspect that you are layered on top of a typical right-wing, paranoia-style of Republican politics, and serve as icing on one of the "doody-cakes!" Very seriously!

Sawdust

December 10, 2009 - 9:11 am EST

The fact is that neither of the plans hatched by the Democrats will do anything to reduce costs, they will simply shift those costs around a bit more, so that the producers of the country pay more, and the leeches of the country suck more blood. This argument isn't about health care, any more than the gathering in Copenhagen is about climate change. Both are about money and political power, nothing more.

If the Copenhagen gang was worried about carbon footprints, they would have flown there on commercial airlines instead of private jets, and would be making their way around the city in economy cars, not limousines. They don't give a tinker's dam about the climate, and the Democrats don't give a tinker's dam about health care costs. If they did, they would include tort reform, and other money-saving ideas proposed by Republivans. "Won't save enough to bother with", as one commenter on this site said of tort reform a few days ago. It would save some, it wouldn't cost anything to implement, why not include it? Because it's not about medicine, it is about money and political power.

I fail to see how anyone, even xero, could possibly be so stupid as to be unable to see that.

neocon

December 10, 2009 - 6:32 am EST

Good LTE, Ms. Mays. Alma Adams and Pricey Harrison represent and give voice to a small group of insecure people who for various reasons, feel they are entitled to the fruits of other peoples' labor.

Alma Adams and Pricey Harrison are simply spokespersons for a loud group of people who have been conditioned by liberal politicians seeking power that they are owed something by this country and their desire to be nurtured by government throughout their lives is perfectly normal and should be respected.

This is what 60 years of unchecked liberalism has wrought. Pitiful.

Sawdust

December 10, 2009 - 4:13 pm EST

Latest poll: 34% favor health care reform, a new low. The Dems better hurry and pass this turkey before even they, as dim-witted as they and their supporters are, figure out that this is not setting well with the voters.

firerescuechick

December 10, 2009 - 7:44 am EST

Great letter! A few facts for everyone....... In Missouri, malpractice payout amounts have increased more than 350% from 1990 to 2004. That is from the US Dept. of Justice Bureau of Justice Statistics. Defensive medicine practices account for 200 to 300 billion dollars of waste in the US ( Reuters). 83% of Massachusetts physicians cited the fear of being sued as the number 1 reason they practice defensive medicine, and that 18-28% of all tests and procedures that were ordered were unnecessary. This added an additional 1.4 billion to health care costs in Massachusetts (Metropolitan Corporate Counsel).

Slaan

December 10, 2009 - 8:18 am EST

"The Nov. 25 Rasmussen Poll shows the lowest number ever in support of this health care reform. Only 35 percent are in favor while 56 percent are opposed."

The same Rasmussen poll that showed 120% of Americans think Global Warming is a hoax?

http://thinkprogress.org/2009/12/08/fox-poll-120/

rightwingnemesis

December 10, 2009 - 8:42 am EST

The question being asked in some of these polls is "Do you approve of the way the Health Care debate is being waged" and not surprisingly, Democrats and Independents both answer "NO". With that type poll question, I find it hard to leap to a conclusion such as this letter writer did. As Mr.Slaan pointed out, the Rasmussen poll has not had a good run as of late--but FoxNews stands by their 120% results.

Sawdust

December 10, 2009 - 9:20 am EST

Is that the best you can do? Obviously a slip-up, given the data in the article, a clear majority still think hanky-panky is the case.

neocon

December 10, 2009 - 12:40 pm EST

They need something to cling to. The wheels are coming off algore's cart:

http://www.infowars.com/photos-of-protest-against-al-gore-in-florida/

Edit: algore's private jet...

ghost from white oak

December 10, 2009 - 9:51 am EST

Great letter, and as for all the flak about the polls, I expect nothing less.
It is normal for the left to scream "stupid poll" when they disagree with it and "point to it beaming" if it should agree with " their vast minority.
As far as the 120% not buying into gobal warming BS, sounds good to me.

Rufus_T.Firefly

December 10, 2009 - 11:56 am EST

"We are losing our God-given freedoms each and every day as an over-reaching Washington cabal sucks the life-breath out of America."

No, we got rid of them last November. Keep up with current events Nancy!!

dcolin

December 10, 2009 - 3:31 pm EST

"2.2 percent profit margin"

Please explain what this means.

They have little investment

danagain

December 10, 2009 - 7:53 pm EST

"They have little investment"

Yep, those surgeries and hospital stays are cheap.

Sawdust

December 11, 2009 - 12:04 am EST

The fact that you leftists don't know the difference between profit and profit margin is one of the main reasons that your hysterics don't make any sense to anyone with a brain. It's impossible to take you seriously when you ask questions like that. I suggest a course in basic economics, or better yet read Thomas Sowell's book of the same name. You might also read his column,which is on these pages today.

eMail Updates

Advertisement | Advertise with Us

Featured Ads

Search

Advertisement | Advertise with Us
Advertisement | Advertise with Us
Advertisement | Advertise with Us

News & Record Network Sites

User Tools

  • Social Networking
  • RSS
  • Share
  • Sign in to MyNR

Search