news-record.com

OPINION

Gene Owens: Football is the great racial leveler

Friday, December 4, 2009
(Updated 3:00 am)

Mort Persky, en eminent Southern journalist whose path crossed mine in Augusta, Ga., during the springtime of our careers, now lives in retirement in New York City. He occasionally shares with me his insight into what's happening in Gotham City and its environs.

His latest missive was a story lifted from the New York Times Web site in which the Good Gray Lady took a nosy peek into the football goings-on in Valdosta, Ga.

Mort marveled that the Times had devoted so much ink to the Valdosta High School Wildcats, the Crimson Tide of Georgia high school football.

The Times painted a portrait of a school and town where high school football had grown to outsize proportions but now is ebbing as the winning tradition is shifting from Valdosta High School, now 75 percent black, to predominantly white Lowndes High School, just outside city limits.

It's not surprising that the school just out of town is mostly white. Since World War II, the trend has been for the affluent to move out of the inner cities and into the ever-expanding suburbs, and in Valdosta, as in most places, whites have outnumbered blacks in the ranks of the affluent.

It also isn't surprising that community loyalty has been flowing away from Valdosta High and toward Lowndes High as the demographics have shifted. We're just 55 years removed from Brown v. Board of Education, and deeply embedded cultural attitudes take time to dissipate.

But they have dissipated somewhat. Whites in Southern college stadiums have learned to cheer enthusiastically for black athletes. Coaches throughout the Southeastern Conference and the Atlantic Coast Conference enthusiastically recruit black athletes. Those who don't recruit them don't win.

Up through the 1960s, if you had asked a University of Georgia football fan to pick the Bulldogs' greatest player, you would have heard names like Charley Trippi, Frank Sinkwich and Fran Tarkenton -- all certifiably white.

If you were to ask that question in Athens, Ga., today, you would probably hear one name: Herschel Walker, the big running back who, as a freshman in 1980, carried the Bulldogs to their last national championship. Herschel is certifiably black. The quarterback for the national-championship team was Buck Belue, a Valdosta High School alumnus who became a fine college quarterback but is remembered mainly as the guy who handed the ball to Herschel.

My memory of Georgia high school football goes back to 1955, my freshman year at the University of Georgia, when the state's two top teams were the Athens High School Trojans and the Valdosta High School Wildcats. The Athens team, led by a quarterback named Fran Tarkenton, won 41-20.

But Valdosta remains the winningest high school team in the nation. It has won 23 state championships and six national championships of one stripe or another.

Still, Valdosta's 11,000-seat Wildcat stadium no longer is filled every Friday night and the school's enrollment has dwindled below the minimum required to meet the standards for Division 5A schools. Lowndes is now the larger school.

Furthermore, as Belue, now an Atlanta sports radio host, has observed, politics has entered the picture -- politics with a racial dimension. Should the coach of a 75 percent black school be white or black?

The logical answer should be the one Chinese leader Deng Xiaoping used to defend his market-oriented heresy against the communist doctrines of Mao Xedong: "It doesn't matter whether a cat is black or white as long as it catches mice." It shouldn't matter whether a coach is black or white as long as his teams win championships.

I have a feeling that Valdosta will work through the racial question. Football seems to have a great leveling effect.

Even as far back as my college days, the kids seem to have been ahead of the politicians. The only panty raid I observed during my stay at the University of Georgia came in 1955, when Gov. Marvin Griffin tried to prevent Georgia Tech from playing against the University of Pittsburgh in the Sugar Bowl. His reason: Pitt had a black player, Bobby Grier, on its squad.

Students at the University of Georgia chose the panty raid as a vehicle for protesting this attempt to keep their arch-rival from collecting its post-season reward.

In North Carolina, football nostalgia still conjures the image of Charlie "Choo-Choo" Justice, my football hero of the '40s. But basketball has eclipsed football at Chapel Hill, and the hero is a guy named Michael Jordan. The tall, dark and handsome athlete starred in Hanes underwear commercials in which cute white chicks ogled him and wondered whether he was wearing boxers or briefs. In another era that would have gotten him lynched.

Yeah, I think Valdosta will advance the ball beyond the color line. That's the way to remain a football city.

Of course, Valdosta High may switch its attention to basketball and regularly clobber its out-of-town rival.

Readers may write Gene Owens at 315 Lakeforest Circle, Anderson SC 29625, or e-mail him at WadesDixieco@AOL.com.

Comments

This article has been closed to new comments. Comments are generally closed after 14 days. However, comments may be closed earlier at the discretion of the News & Record.

Inappropriate content? Please report abuse.

Lakeshia

December 4, 2009 - 3:29 am EST

Gene,
Your mention of ACC football causes me to note that ACC football is an embarrasment -
Tomorrow, in Tampa, Clemson will play Georgia Tech for the ACC championship - but what does it say about the ACC when both contenders for the ACC championship title were soundly beaten by SEC teams this past Saturday??? Last Saturday, unranked South Carolina whipped then #16 Clemson 34 - 17 and then #7 Georgia Tech was beaten on its home field by unranked Georgia 30 - 25.
I repeat - ACC football is an embarrassment -

igliigli

December 4, 2009 - 4:50 am EST

"Football is the great racial leveler" is not a true statement. Football and basketball players have done nothing but reinforce society's stereotypes, if you are black, you must be either an athlete, a criminal, or an entertainer. For example, many NR readers can name dozens of black ACC athletes. How many know the name of a black mathematician who has taught at UNC-CH for almost 20 years?

DaveW

December 4, 2009 - 1:54 pm EST

The readers of the News-Record that actually went to UNC-CH probably could name the UNC math professor.It is unreasonable to expect those that did not attend UNC to know this.

jbcarper

December 4, 2009 - 7:03 am EST

According to a July 2009 report, using data from the 2005-06 school year, Georgia had 4 year graduation rates that were significantly different from racial group to racial group: Asians - 80%, White - 65%, African-American - 46%, and Hispanic - 41%. Doesn't look like sports has helped level graduation rates. Since educational achievement is one of the primary indicators for lifetime income, starting out with a disparate achievement level in education will end up with a disparate income level over the student lifetime.
Let's recognize sports as a great way to motivate some individuals and a provider of opportunity for a small, select group of people. Let's not make it into some great social movement that will solve the issues of our day.
http://www.all4ed.org/files/Georgia_wc.pdf

Get A Clue

December 4, 2009 - 7:10 am EST

I agree with igliigli. I worry the author of this piece has no clue as to how incredibly racially stereotypical his comments are. His tone is but a smidgen away from "a credit to his race." He might as well have just stated, "Some of my best friends are black," and ended it there.

Sawdust

December 4, 2009 - 8:06 am EST

Can't help but wonder when the racial quota folks will tackle the NBA and the NFL. Gross disparities in both. What's that you say? Black athletes have proven their abilities and deserve a spot on the roster regardless of the racial make-up of the team? What a great idea! How about applying that idea to the rest of the real world?

Get A Clue

December 4, 2009 - 8:22 am EST

If you insist on quoting canards from right-wing talk shows, the KKK and the Protocols of the Elders of Zion, at least have the decency to cite your sources.
You know, like us pointy-headed pencil-necked Librul elites do.
Seriously, old man, are you off your meds or did your wife finally stop caring how much time you spend online? You need a hobby besides talk radio and the internet. Go out and get some sunshine.

jbcarper

December 4, 2009 - 10:01 am EST

It isn't just a portion of African-Americans who favor affirmative action programs. In parts of the country many white parents have been insisting on affirmative action/quotas to make sure their own under performing children don't get excluded from the best schools:

"According to parents and students of both races, what white parents fear most is their children being marginalized in the college admission process by the academic achievements of their Asian—American peers. This fear is perhaps best summarized by the patron saint of white liberals, Bill Clinton. In a 1995 interview with the Sacramento Bee, then—President Clinton stated that excessive reliance on academic qualifications in higher education could have dire consequences. His warning that "there are universities in California that could fill their entire freshman classes with nothing but Asians' echoes their concerns.

As a last resort, liberal school boards, courts and administrators will typically take it unto themselves to implement policies to introduce more 'diversity' into their student bodies. In the San Francisco public schools, this took form through the recently terminated 1983 Consent Decree which set a school enrollment limit of 45 percent for any single racial or ethnic group. Chinese—American parents charged that the racial caps were aimed primarily at limiting their children's access to the city's most prestigious schools. Throughout the 1980s and 1990s, the University of California imposed an affirmative—qction—based quota system, which temporarily maintained the white plurality at its most prestigious campuses."
http://www.americanthinker.com/2005/12/the_new_separate_but_equal.html

The truth is most of us fear real competition, especially when it impacts our financial future. Those who have want their accumulated assets to be protected from the hordes of humanity. Individuals who lack want to gain what they perceive to be their fair share regardless of effort they put forth relative to the more successful.
There is no such thing as a level playing field. We each start life with differing talents and abilities. It is not nature or nuture that determines success. The combination of Nature + Nuture + Random Events is what determines life outcome.

JGALT

December 4, 2009 - 12:00 pm EST

Don't discount those with modest natural gifts and zero nurture but an abundance of individual initiative.

jbcarper

December 4, 2009 - 12:54 pm EST

Is not personal initiative a natural talent? My wife and I have eight children; and, within them we have self starters and the more laid back. I firmly believe we are born with unique personalities that can either be developed and enhanced or allowed to wither. I've also worked with a variety of sales people, over the years, in a management role. I have come to believe that you can only motivate short-term changes in behavior. The core drive to excel, as found in the highly motivated, comes from within. You can force individuals to practice and work, but I don't think you can force them to internalize greatness.

JGALT

December 4, 2009 - 4:28 pm EST

It can be a personality trait. It can be discovered later in life through experience when other non- productive paths have been exhausted.

Sawdust

December 4, 2009 - 8:49 pm EST

clue; I'm not quoting anybody. I'm merely asking why those who insist on quotas when it comes to minorities don't see the glaring racial inequality in the NBA. I think it's a fair question. Why is it fair to have a basketball team that is 90% black, but police and fire departments must hire according to the quota system? Seems a bit hypocritical to me.

Sawdust

December 4, 2009 - 9:04 pm EST

And besides that, it's not my fault that you're a pointy-headed pencil-necked geek. Sounds like a personal problem to me. Probably Bush's fault.

eMail Updates

Advertisement | Advertise with Us

Featured Ads

Search

Advertisement | Advertise with Us
Advertisement | Advertise with Us
Advertisement | Advertise with Us

News & Record Network Sites

User Tools

  • Mobile
  • Social
  • RSS
  • Share
  • Sign in to MyNR

Search