news-record.com

NEWS

Advertisement | Advertise with Us

Veteran wants VA to pay for medical bills

Sunday, September 6, 2009
(Updated 3:00 am)

GREENSBORO — William Izzard  says he never made it past the admissions clerk at the VA Medical Center in Salisbury. She told him he’d been “kicked out” of the system.

So, in February 2008 , the veteran of two tours in Vietnam went to Moses Cone Hospital to find out why he was feeling so sick.

It turns out he’d had a heart attack. He spent four days in the ICU and ended up with a $25,000 bill. He has been paying about $25 a month, but Moses Cone won a lawsuit against him in March for the remainder. He owes thousands more to specialists.

Now Izzard, 63 , wants to know why he was turned away from the VA Medical Center at all. He believes the VA should pay for his medical costs.

Greensboro attorney Craig Kabatchnick  agrees.

“No doubt, they blew the call,” said Kabatchnick, who heads the Veterans Law Program at N.C. Central University . “They should have at least done a triage of him. ... Instead, they just said, 'You’re not in our system,’ which is impossible if he’d been previously treated there.”

Izzard wasn’t eligible for benefits at the time even though he had been treated there before, said Lexia Frasher, chief over health administration service, during a review Thursday  of Izzard’s records.

Over the years, the laws regarding VA benefits have changed, she said. Izzard was eligible for services when first honorably discharged from the Army in 1973. But in 1996 , Congress required veterans to enroll for services and has put income caps on eligibility except in cases of service-connected disabilities.

When Izzard went to the VA hospital in February 2008, he did not qualify for benefits because he made too much money and did not have a service-connected disability. He had applied for disability benefits for a back and shoulder injury and post-traumatic stress disorder but was denied, records show.

“It is complex anytime you deal with the government,” Frasher said.

Kabatchnick said the VA still shouldn’t have turned Izzard away because it was an emergency situation. Izzard complained of symptoms of a heart attack. The VA should have examined him to make sure he wasn’t in a life-threatening situation as any other hospital would have done, Kabatchnick said.

“I don’t know too many folks that go to a hospital and get turned away,” said Izzard, who is confused and frustrated by the VA health care process.

He served two tours in Vietnam as an Army mechanic and a truck driver. One of those tours was in Da Nang, a southern port city that housed a U.S. air base.

“We used to run convoys,” he said. “It was real interesting.”

In the 1980s , he went to the Salisbury VA for an alcohol-addiction treatment program. Back then, just being a veteran qualified him for services, he said.

He has gone back a few times over the years but mostly has made use of his work-related health-care plans, Izzard said.

But in February last year, Izzard had just been reemployed as a truck driver so his medical insurance hadn’t kicked in yet.

“That’s why I went to he VA,” he said, “to keep from having a big bill.”

Doctors didn’t tell him when he had his heart attack. Izzard had complained of chest pains at least twice that week to his wife.

By the time he got to Moses Cone, doctors told him his main artery was 95 percent blocked and he had high levels of cholesterol, blood pressure and sugar. He also learned that he was diabetic.

“I didn’t know what was wrong with me,” he said. “I just knew I was ill.”

Kabatchnick, who defended the department against disability claims in the early 1990s, plans to file complaints with the VA on Izzard’s behalf. He believes that Izzard should have been seen that day because he had symptoms of a heart attack, which Izzard said he reported to the admissions clerk.

“The VA failed to exercise a reasonable degree of care,” Kabatchnick said. “That’s what’s happened here.”

Frasher said Izzard’s case likely wasn’t considered an emergency because he wasn’t in obvious distress from symptoms of a heart attack at the time. He drove to the VA, back home and then to the hospital in Greensboro, she said.

“I’m outraged by that response,” said Kabatchnick, who has accepted Izzard’s case pro bono as part of his work with the veterans program at N.C. Central.

Izzard now goes to the VA in Salisbury to be treated for his diabetes. The diagnosis for that illness automatically qualified him for benefits, Frasher said.

“It’s unfortunate and heart-breaking that you weren’t able to get your eligibility before the incident,” Frasher said.

Izzard met with VA officials hoping to find some relief from his medical bills. They said they had no programs that could help him.

“You have to look at me,” Izzard told them. “I’m a simple man (living) paycheck to paycheck.”

 

Contact Jennifer Fernandez at 373-7064 or jennifer.fernandez@news-record.com

 

Accompanying Photos

H. Scott Hoffmann (News & Record)

Photo Caption: William Izzard at his home in Greensboro.

MORE INFORMATION

For information on veterans benefits:
Online:

Phone:
(800) 827-1000: Service-related benefits
(704) 638-3470: Health benefits
 

Comments

This article has been closed to new comments. Comments are generally closed after 14 days. However, comments may be closed earlier at the discretion of the News & Record.

Inappropriate content? Please notify us.

onbe1kanoby

September 6, 2009 - 4:21 am EDT

That is why there should be a national health plan! PERIOD..
It is dump... not to have one.. and a waste of money...
It has to be plan for.. either with insurance or taxes..

ghost from white oak

September 7, 2009 - 8:47 am EDT

Why do you expect a national health plan run by the guvmint to be better than a VA health plan run by the guvmint?

TerryT

September 6, 2009 - 6:48 am EDT

I am a vet. I served 7 years during the Vietnam war. I decided to leave the military and worked for private industry. I do not expect nor should anyone else expect the VA to care for them UNLESS IT IS A SERVICE RELATED ILLNESS. Private industry does not cover you after you leave their employment unless it is workers comp. Before everyone jumps on me I am a champion for taking care of our Vets but this man left the military 40 years ago.

justified

September 6, 2009 - 9:10 am EDT

In today's America you don't have to work or pay your bills.
The gov. will supply you with free health care, food, housing,and believe it or not free gas for your auto.
Now if I could just get them to pay my cable bill.
" God Bless America"

speakup2

September 6, 2009 - 9:20 am EDT

You know 25K doesn't sound all that bad for fixing a bad heart. I saw on the news where a woman owed 192K for a pacemaker. Outrageous. He needs to just keep paying what he can. That is all that he can do. As long as they cannot kick him out of his home. What I am surprised about is that they turned him away from the VA hospital. Are they not bound by the same laws as the rest of the hospitals in this country? I mean this does/did appear to be an emergency. There does need to be some type of Insurance for people inbetween jobs. I am NOT talking about people that Won't work, but people that DO Work and have been laidoff. Cobra is a joke. Someone with a full time job can't afford that.

Panacea

September 6, 2009 - 1:11 pm EDT

speakup2: you raise a good point. The VA hospital in Salisbury has an ER. That makes me think the EMTALA law should apply. He should have had a medical screening exam before leaving.

Of course, he would still be responsible for the bill at the VA, since he wasn't eligible for benefits. The complication is, since he was having a heart attack, who is then responsible for treating him? The VA can't get into the habit of treating civilians or veterans who aren't eligible for benefits.

Still, the administrator at the VA is full of crap. "Frasher said Izzard’s case likely wasn’t considered an emergency because he wasn’t in obvious distress from symptoms of a heart attack at the time. He drove to the VA, back home and then to the hospital in Greensboro, she said." How the HELL would she know that since this man never saw a nurse?!?!?!? Some clerk isn't going to be able to tell if this gentleman was having a heart attack or not. You don't have to be grey in the face and clutching your chest to have a heart attack. A registered nurse could have evaluated his symptoms, and determined if a medical emergency existed or not. Most likely, a nurse would have recommended he be seen by a doctor before leaving.

I hate it for the VA: I'm sure they don't want to be in the position of having to treat the community at large, but to avoid that all they need to do is not have an ER, or to train their nurses to do medical screening exams (EMTALA allows this).

$25,000 for this problem actually sounds expensive. My dad had bypass surgery that didn't cost that much. This guy is probably being overcharged because he doesn't have insurance. I'm not surprised if Cone went after him in court if he's only paying $25/month, but I am surprised that a judge ruled against him. Usually people who make good faith payments don't get sued, or if they do, the judge throws it out without prejudice. The judge must have thought he could afford more than $25/mo, and frankly I'm inclined to agree. If he'd been paying $100 a month, he probably could have avoided court. Now with a judgment against him, he risks having his wages or Social Security garnished, and if he owns his own home, he could lose it.

This is why we need health care reform. speakup2 is right COBRA is a joke.

Dogwood

September 6, 2009 - 2:50 pm EDT

Half the county is split up. One half goes to Durham the other half goes to Salisbury. Depending on current residence of the veteran only he can decide which way to travel east or west 85. I would not drive to Salisbury VA due to they have had a very troubled administrative past if I could get to Durham.

Panacea

September 6, 2009 - 5:46 pm EDT

Don't forget Winston Salem. My best friend (a disabled vet) now has to get her primary care at Winston Salem because it is closer than Salisbury.

ClayLawsonJr

September 6, 2009 - 9:26 pm EDT

I can not see why he was not seen either. I was working in a furniture factory late 1998 or early 1999; sometime before 9/11 though. A fellow veteran told about going to sign up for health benifits,since I am a veteran myself, I served in the Navy from 8/68 to 02/24/70, recieved a Honarable Discharge (DD-214 proves it and it proudly hangs on the wall in the house). anyway I have been enrolled for about 61/2 years and the treatment might be slow but I think it is fair.. To give you a picture of what I am talking about; I had severe arthritis to the point that I could not walk no more thanmaybe 100 feet without pain, they exrayed my knees and agreed that it needed to have work done on them the first one (left) was replaced in Thomasville (payed by the VA plus therpy at home); the second one was done in Asheville. Recieved travel pay for going there which I payed for gas to the people that I hadf to get to transport me there and back, but I know if the problem should pop up that if I needed to go that I would be seen by the ER at the Triadge Unit and they would then know what to do for me to get the proper treatment.

MCLady

September 7, 2009 - 9:32 am EDT

In 2004 my husband was having chest pains, I took him to the VA hospital in Salisbury, we walked in, he told the nurse he was having chest pains, they took him straight back, by the time I had finished his paper work, they had determined he had a Heart Attack. He was sent to Asheville for Surgery, they determined he had Diabetes, we did have to have a private Dr. say his Diabetes caused his heart problems, but almost any veteran who was in Viet Nam who has diabetes has Military related injuries because they were probably exposed to Agent Orange. We have been very happy with the care he gets at Salisbury. I am thinking the ER is now being out sourced and this could be where the problem is, they need better training and if this is the case, then I hope the VA gets enough grief that they do away with Out Sourcing and put those VA employees back to work, if, this is the case I think it is a good example of what happens when you Out Source. Plus if this gentleman was once
treated for PTSD, he will always have PTSD and needs continual treatment. Since all this I have become a Veterans Advocate, I support these veterans all I can, by spending endless hours writing and making calls to the VA and political offices. I would like to thank the group of Attorneys who are helping them as well. We need more family members getting involved, let your Congressmen and Senators know what is going on with your loved ones health care, whether it is good or bad, and most important, Hug a Veteran Today and say, Thank You.

eMail Updates

Advertisement | Advertise with Us

Featured Ads

Search

Advertisement | Advertise with Us
Advertisement | Advertise with Us
Advertisement | Advertise with Us

News & Record Network Sites

Triad Weather

  • Current Condition: CLOUDY
  • Current Temperature: 38°
  • UV Idx: 0
  • Forecast High/Low: H: 37° L: 24°

User Tools

  • Social Networking
  • RSS
  • Share
  • Sign in to MyNR

Search