news-record.com

NEWS

Advertisement | Advertise with Us

Police chief: Bear in Winston-Salem posed a threat

Wednesday, July 15, 2009
(Updated 9:14 am)

WINSTON-SALEM (MCT) — A bear that likely wandered down from the mountains to the northwestern part of the city was shot to death because it was in a populated area and posed a threat, Police Chief Scott Cunningham said Tuesday.

"We didn't think it was worth it to wait for the bear to become hostile," Cunningham said.

But a state wildlife biologist said that the bear would have passed through quickly once it realized that it wouldn't find enough food to sustain its diet.

"Bears won't stay there," said Colleen Olfenbuttel, a biologist with the N.C. Wildlife Resources Commission. "It just doesn't offer the habitat they need. They may show up for a few days or week, and as long as people aren't feeding them incidentally, they'll keep moving on.

"I've never heard of a situation where a bear walks through the neighborhood, and it escalates into aggression," Olfenbuttel said.

Officers used rifles to shoot the bear after it ransacked a bird feeder in the backyard of a house on Kramer Court, near the intersection of Robinhood and Shattalon roads, just after 8 p.m. Monday.

The bear was between 100 and 150 pounds and about 5 feet 6 inches tall. Olfenbuttel guessed that it was probably 1 or 2 years old.

Rudy Kane said he and his wife, Valia, noticed a bear in their backyard on Kramer Court about 1 p.m. They called 911 and were transferred to an animal-control dispatcher, who told them to stay away from the bear.

About 8 o'clock, Kane saw another bear trying to get food from one of his bird feeders. Kane said he stayed inside while officers with guns and flashlights entered his yard to get the bear. Officers later told him that they shot the bear. The wounded animal tried to escape by climbing about 50 feet up a nearby tree. But it fell to the ground.

Kane said that the wounded bear wandered next door, where Hope Pirtle lives. Pirtle said that the bear died next to a chain-link fence in her backyard.

She said that the bear's death was unfortunate, but she believes that the police did the right thing.

"It's really very sad," she said.

Carey Bostic, a law-enforcement supervisor with the wildlife commission, said that his officers are told to kill a bear only if a person is in imminent danger.

"Very seldom do we see imminent danger," Bostic said. "But what you perceive and I perceive as imminent danger are two different things."

Bostic's agency is investigating the shooting, which is standard procedure when a game animal is killed out of season. Although there is a bear-hunting season in some parts of the state, bears are protected in the Piedmont.

From what he has learned so far, Bostic said, the bear was not threatening anyone or acting aggressively. However, he did not second-guess the Winston-Salem Police Department's decision to shoot it.

Cunningham said that the police department would investigate the shooting, which is standard procedure whenever an officer fires a weapon on duty.

The encounter in Winston-Salem comes amid other bear sightings in Guilford and Yadkin counties.

Olfenbuttel said that bears are on the move this time of year for several reasons:

* Young bears have left their mothers and are trying to establish new territories. Forsyth County is on the edge of prime bear habitat, so it's no surprise to Olfenbuttel that a few bears are passing through.

* Food is not as abundant in late spring and summer, and that forces bears to venture south and east in search of soft berries, such as cherries and blackberries.

* When such food isn't readily available, bears rely on their keen sense of smell, which could lead them to garbage cans or grills.

* Male bears are more active this time of year because it is the breeding season.

Bears usually travel along a forested corridor or along a river or stream, Olfenbuttel said. As those areas are being developed, more people are encountering bears.

People who encounter a bear should back away quietly and go inside their houses. Pets should be taken inside, too.

Some neighborhoods in western North Carolina where bears are much more abundant have adapted. Residents in these areas don't fill bird feeders, keep trash cans in their garage, and they clean their grills.

"Bears are like all wildlife," Olfenbuttel said. "They think with their stomachs."

Comments

This article has been closed to new comments. Comments are generally closed after 14 days. However, comments may be closed earlier at the discretion of the News & Record.

Inappropriate content? Please notify us.

rw11777

July 15, 2009 - 10:03 am EDT

THESE OFFICERS ACTED VERY WRONG. THEY SHOULD HAVE LET THE BEAR BE. I FEEL OUTRAGED BY THIS AS I GREW UP IN THE MOUNTAINS AND BEARS ARE COMMON ON YOUR BACK PORCH. THEY ARE HARMLESS IF YOU DONT MESS WITH THEM THEY WILL GO ON. THE BEAR WAS FORAGING DUE TO THE DRY WEATHER WE HAVE HAD FOR THE LAST MONTH. THESE OFFICERS NEED TO LEARN ABOUT WILDLIFE OR BACK OFF. AS FAR AS THE CHIEF HE'S AN IDIOT TO SAY ITS JUSTIFIED, THE WINSTON SALEM PD NEEDS TO SETUP BETTER CONTINUING ED CLASSES TO ADDRESS WHAT TO DO IN A WILDLIFE SITUATION, THEY ARE OBVIOUSLY NOT TRAINED FOR IT NOW.

J Peterman Reality Tour

July 19, 2009 - 9:43 am EDT

I think that if the bear had not been black . . . we wouldn't be reading about this every Sunday.

CopOnTheBeat

July 15, 2009 - 1:10 pm EDT

It was last October that the NC Highway Patrol and one of the mountain police departments shut down the Interstate so a mother bear could retrieve her dead cub that was killed by a car. Traffic was blocked for an hour while officers watched and waited for her to get her dead cub, which she did, and she took it into the woods. She was no threat, police just didn't want her killed or for her to cause an accident. She went about her way and that was the end of it.

While I try not to second guess and officer, I honestly feel that the WSPD made an error in killing the bear. I've never heard of anyone in the Piedmont being harmed by a bear, most of the time when they see people, they take off. A good friend who is a game warden told me years ago that bears are just as afraid of you as you are of them..and the best thing to do is leave them alone and they'll leave.

Methinks it may be time for the WSPD and other departments to have a training course in dealing with wildlife that wander into human territory.

As a related side note, many wild animals are being spotted in residential areas...that's because those areas once belonged to the animals...but man is slowly encroaching in their territory and taking over. Sad really.

leftnc

July 15, 2009 - 2:33 pm EDT

I agree completely with you. If you are a LEO, you know there's more danger with a rabid raccoon or dog in the Triad area, especially Guilford county. Also, again if you're a LEO, you know how WSPD shoots at qualifications at Calibers, versus other agencies. I exclude the WSPD detectives, those folks were some of the best I've seen.

leftnc

July 15, 2009 - 1:22 pm EDT

Where was animal control? After I left the Triad area I was in Knoxville TN. We had black bears roaming the city including the UT campus area. They usually left on their own if no food was found, one was run off by a little silky terrier. The persistent ones, Wildlife control would come out, and is the nature of these bears, they'd climb a tree to escape from humans. the Wildlife control officers used tranquilizer guns, and if the bear was high in a tree would set a net for it to fall into. In my entire time there, no humans or pets were ever attacked by these bears. If you want to live near nature, please be prepared for these incursions. I agree, a little more training for the police on how to handle black bears seems to be in order. Side note, I don't know what WSPD uses as carry arms whether it's 9MM or .40 cal, any missed shots probably put more people in danger than the bear.

Noyouranidiot

July 15, 2009 - 1:25 pm EDT

"We didn't think it was worth it to wait for the bear to become hostile."

That sentence says it all. The complete lack of understanding of bear behavior by the Mayberry-Salem PD is now apparent for all to see.

blackstream

July 19, 2009 - 10:00 am EDT

Hey, even Andy and Barney would have known better then to shoot the bear. This is some crap a bunch of idiot big city yankees would do. Not a country boy!

thestatelottery

July 15, 2009 - 4:35 pm EDT

Keep developing on a massive, poorly planned way and wildlife will encroach on "your" property since they have nowhere else to go. The problem is not the bear, but people. The same problem is happening in Florida with alligators.

leftnc

July 15, 2009 - 10:19 pm EDT

I lived in FL for 12 years before going to NC.for 12 years. I've been back in FL for one year now, east coast vs. west coast. You can't compare the alligator to a black bear. If you've lived in both areas,you would know a black bear is harmless, a gator is totally different. I've watched gators kill and not bother to eat the prey. Black bears, look for fresh food,berries or scraps. Please do a little more research on the species before talking out of turn. I agree with you in principle, however it's not a good comparison. Alligators are still a protected species in FL, black bears are not in NC.

blackstream

July 19, 2009 - 9:57 am EDT

This story took a number of twists and turns. First, they said it was just acting aggressively. Then the story read that the officers shot the bear, and then the bear climbed a tree in which it fell from. They then had to finish off the wounded animal. First of all, they were the reason the animal was wounded to start with. If the bear did show any sign of aggression, it was because a number of people showed up in a small area and the bear felt threatened or trapped. I got a copy of a letter from the City Mananger of W-S written to the Mayor. There was no mention of the bear climbing a tree. The original story tried to make out like the bear was already wounded before the cops showed up. Oh, and that bent over bird feeder that they are trying to scare everybody with by making this 100# look all powerful.... Could have been bent over by almost anybody. We know this thing is flimsy. They always are. They just wanted to shoot something!

Don Stowe

July 19, 2009 - 7:32 pm EDT

I suggest that you bleeding hearts do some research into how many people have been hurt or killed by nice, friendly, cute little bears. Please stop second guessing and criticizing everything our law enforcement officers do.

eMail Updates

Advertisement | Advertise with Us

Featured Ads

Search

Advertisement | Advertise with Us
Advertisement | Advertise with Us
Advertisement | Advertise with Us

News & Record Network Sites

Triad Weather

  • Current Condition: FAIR
  • Current Temperature: 72°
  • UV Idx: 0
  • Forecast High/Low: H: 73° L: 44°

User Tools

  • Social Networking
  • RSS
  • Share
  • Sign in to MyNR

Search