news-record.com

NEWS

Advertisement | Advertise with Us

Greensboro College fending off creditors

Sunday, June 28, 2009
(Updated Thursday, July 2 - 8:01 am)

Editor's Note: Because of incorrect information provided to the News & Record, this article misreported who pays the bill for a personal trainer for the wife of Greensboro College President Craven Williams. Williams personally reimburses Greensboro College for that expense.

A week ago, a lineman from Duke Energy handed an $8,000 disconnect notice to the undergrad working the front desk at Reynolds student union, saying Greensboro College had two hours to pay before the power would be turned off.

Monday, a sheriff’s deputy served the college’s vice president for business a summons to appear in small-claims court on a $1,245 office supply bill.

How bleak is the financial outlook at Greensboro College, where salaries were cut 20 percent this spring in an emergency move to avoid layoffs?

Bleak enough that a restructuring consultant last week sent a letter asking creditors to be patient in collecting past due bills of $974,508 — most of them owed to local businesses.

Having met its June payroll Friday, according to Chief Restructuring Officer Edward Sanz, the college must now raise enough money to keep operating through the summer until students return in full force this fall.

“It’s a tough patch, period, but we’re going to get through it,” said Sanz, whose Charlotte-based Naviscent Group was brought in by the college’s board of trustees two months ago to reorganize the school’s debt. “All the colleges are getting slammed right now.”

True, the recession has hit campuses private and public, decimating endowments while drying up gifts from well-heeled benefactors.

But for a small liberal arts college that has rarely made headlines in its 161-year history, the depth of Greensboro College’s financial woes is drawing notice.

So much so, that a national professional journal, the Chronicle of Higher Education, last week used the 1,300-student Greensboro College as a textbook example of, basically, how not to react to a crisis.

Under the front-page headline, “Broad Pay Cuts Make Deep Dents in Morale,” the story quoted, at length, anonymous faculty members highly critical of Craven Williams, the school’s president since 1993.

Williams, infuriated by the article and by recent discussion in the media of his $403,000 annual salary, said this week he has no intention of stepping down in response to the problems, as anonymous messages circulated on campus and on message boards have suggested.

“I don’t have anything to say to that,” Williams said. “Anybody can just say anything when they’re anonymous. Of course, it bothers me.”

Williams, who took the 20 percent cut along with his staff, has for years worn the hat of campus ambassador and fundraiser-in-chief.

As such, says Sanz, the president’s use of a Sunset Drive home the college owns in Irving Park, complete with maid service and BMW, are the cost of doing business. They are, Sanz argues, the necessary accoutrements for entertaining would-be major donors.

But the college, in contrast, can barely meet its own basic needs, according to the school’s own list of outstanding bills obtained by the News & Record.

For example:

ARAMARK, the cafeteria  service, was owed $136,889. Of that, $93,564 was more than two months in arrears.

Waste Management’s bill was $13,388 past due; Royal Tours, the buses the college hires to transport athletes, was owed $50,276; a water bill for the city of Greensboro was over 90 days late at $6,500. Duke Energy was posting a $1,862 balance, of which $758 was two months late.

Karen Riffanacht, the student who was working at Reynolds Center when the Duke Energy truck arrived, said she thought the cutoff notice was a mistake.

“It was a very big surprise,” she said. “They said 'You have two hours to pay it.’ They didn’t want to shut it off and then have to come all the way back to turn it back on.”

Sanz called the incident a misunderstanding on Duke Energy’s part, over deposits being negotiated on several college accounts.

The college’s bills show tabs being run up at competing businesses — $4,122 at Office Depot, $5,847 at OfficeMax. Insurance bills, medical bills and legal bills are unpaid, as is money owed to nonprofit concerns such as $6,000 to the Berkshire Theatre Festival.

In addition, a membership at Greensboro Country Club has fallen from 60 to 90 days behind, according to the billing records.

Robert Stout, chairman of the school’s Board of Trustees  was out of state this week and could not be reached for comment. Other board members reached this week referred all questions to Stout.

Sanz said the fact that faculty members had not “bolted for the door” after the 20 percent pay cut was announced indicated the strong loyalty professors feel to Greensboro College. He conceded, however, that the tight job market in academia, as in other sectors, could also be a factor in retaining faculty.

Several professors contacted by the newspaper this week declined to comment, mindful of the school’s strict policy to direct reporters to school spokeswoman Cyndie Basinger.

Basinger said the college president would select faculty to be interviewed. She then sent questions to Dean of Faculty Paul Leslie.

Leslie said that since the pay cut, just two of 75 full-time faculty members had resigned to take other academic posts,  but that both had likely been courted over time by other institutions.

Shortly after the pay cut was announced, an anonymous letter, supposedly written by faculty members, made the rounds on campus, blaming Williams for the college’s crisis and criticizing his salary and benefits.

Asked whether that view, repeated in last week’s Chronicle, represents a consensus, Dean Leslie said his faculty “has not been polled as to their concerns.”

But as for the trouble the campus is having paying its bills to local businesses, Leslie said the struggle the school is having is obvious to faculty.

“We are aware that there are open invoices,” he said. “We’re working as diligently as possible so that this will have no effect on what happens in the classroom.”

Trustee chairman Stout is quoted in the Chronicle  as estimating that the school needs to raise “$5 million” in order to operate through the lean summer months, but Sanz said Friday he felt that figure was too high. Currently, the school is in the process of renegotiating its line of credit with Bank of America.

The good news for the school is that freshman enrollments are nearly in line with last year. But that won’t erase the cause of the school’s financial tumble.

The school’s endowment, against which the college had already been borrowing, lost its value on the market, plummeting from a starting point of $19 million down to its current  $12 million.

With many wealthy investors and private foundations in the same boat, the large gifts of previous years have not been forthcoming at Greensboro College, nor at other institutions in the area.

“The college lives on contributions and endowments,” observed Sanz, “but retiring a debt is a bit of a challenge. It’s not like raising money for a building that you can put someone’s name on. You can’t name a debt after someone.”

Contact Lorraine Ahearn at 373-7334 or lorraine.ahearn@news-record.com

 

Accompanying Photos

Staff photo (News & Record)

Photo Caption: The campus of Greensboro College.

Comments

This article has been closed to new comments. Comments are generally closed after 14 days. However, comments may be closed earlier at the discretion of the News & Record.

Inappropriate content? Please notify us.

logicfairy

July 2, 2009 - 2:53 pm EDT

Why comment when you can't face the facts and denial is so much easier?

NVDave

June 30, 2009 - 5:47 pm EDT

I am a GC alum and the parent of a recent graduate of GC, I fully understand the challenges facing the college. The time has come to cut the losses and remove Craven Williams and his huge expenditures. One of the primary concepts taught in any professional leadership and business program is to examine the current practices and make changes when they are not working. Are the expenditures balancing the income produced? Obviously not! The time has come to remove Craven Williams and the BOT. GC… cut your losses, if you must pay his severance package and get leadership into the position that cares more for GC than for his own well being. Until he is removed I will cease donations to the college (but will resume once he resigns or is removed /and his cost of business is eliminated. I encourage other alums to do the same. The faculty and support staff is excellent, caring and committed…Thank you for your leadership and professionalism in the face of this mess. Hopefully GC will be saved from this situation and the next generation of our family will proudly wear the GC robes at their graduation!

goingforward

July 1, 2009 - 5:11 pm EDT

NO YOU SHOULD THANK DR WILLIAMS FOR REMAINING AT THE HELM. THERE IS NO MESS AS YOU PUT IT.

qwerty

July 1, 2009 - 12:51 am EDT

what's needed is a new direction, some sort of theme that unites the campus. elon has international business, guilford has it's earthy-activist feel, greensboro college fills no real niche. yes, it has excellent fac and staff, but it needs a theme to its curriculum or it's done for.

why would someone want to go to greensboro college? yes, individual attention and good folks, etc., but other schools have this and so much more.

pres. williams cannot be the innovator that this school needs. why doesn't he realize that and do a great service to GC and pass the torch to someone who can transform the school?

gcwas4me

July 1, 2009 - 10:14 am EDT

Two words, Qwerty, summarize why Craven doesn't realize that he isn't he innovator Greensboro College needs - EGO and GREED.

Chemelle

July 1, 2009 - 2:21 pm EDT

It all comes down to Greed.
If the operating expense is 1 mill a year and their paying the president in excess of 400,000, he could save the college if he would quit being so greedy. Also if they were making decisions for the best interest of the college, they should have cut everyone's pay in teirs. Instead of 20% across the board and hurting the lower paid faculty, it should have been the more you make the more you got cut!!!!
What does a man do with 400,000 a year with no bills?
Greedy, greedy people!

They should fire the president and throw out the whole board and refresh the college from it's leeches.

drobertson

July 3, 2009 - 5:35 pm EDT

Those who remember John Wesley's injunction, "I love plain dealing. Do not you?" might be interested in taking a look at the public records maintained by the NC Secretary of State's website on the Judith & Craven Williams Corporation, a private, for-profit organization incorporated in 2005 and recently reporting sales of $62,000. The Williams' disclosure of this family, for-profit corporation has been in my opinion less than plain.

The US Department of Commerce's classification of this corporation is SIC Code 7389, which is defined, interestlingly, as "business services not elsewhere classified." In practical terms, such corporations often sell interior decorating services and book travel for speakers and authors. Now, to speak plainly, consider the following hypothetical business situations: (1) should a trustee have desired to renovate his residence, could not the J & CW Inc done so at give-away rates, in tacit return for future favorable consideration? (2) could not the J & CW Inc bought expensive furnishings, deducted them from taxes as unsold, and yet had these items at hand indefinitely to personally enjoy? (3) should Dr. Williams travel, and assuming the College has no audited travel office, could not the J & CW Inc book him (and his wife) at very luxurous settings, and also bill an additional 15 to 20 percent as the standard commission for such corporations handling bookings? and (4) since the business address given for the J & CW Inc is the same as the residence of the Greensboro College president, would not this private, family corporation have the use of the college-funded electricity, internet services, faxes, and insurance provided to the residence for college, non-profit business?

Dr. Williams and his friends/retainers have made much of the anonymous nature of those who criticize him. My real name is found at the top of this comment. Actually, I owe Craven Williams a debt, this time a literary one. I'll repay it, unlike his administration, which has not paid its Duke Power bill, for either the college or his for-private corporation. Having once known Craven Williams fairly well, I found his character invaluable while writing one of my biographies, of the once-famous Bishop James A. Pike, who was one-fourth sheer fun, one-fourth interesting religious thinker, one-fourth financial disaster, and one-fourth a self-serving con man.

deaconrock

July 6, 2009 - 7:40 am EDT

A quick check of the North Carolina Secretary of State website shows that this is actually a non-profit corporation, which is also registered as a charitable private foundation. The short answer is that the form 990pf is available online and all funds are used to support qualified public charities. It can not be used for any of the purposes which you suggest.

drobertson

July 6, 2009 - 11:06 pm EDT

There is documentation for two corporations created by Judith and Craven Williams, one a for-profit and the other a non-profit. The source of the information above for the Judith & Craven Williams, the for-profit corporation, is accessible at www.manta.com, by entering their names. Manta is a research tool primarily for investors and journalists, and gathers information from equally legitimate sources such as Moody's, Dun & Bradstreet, and Hoover's. It's description is of the NC incorporation of "Judith & Craven Williams, located in Greensboro, NC. Judith & Craven Williams' line of business is business services at non-commercial site."
The "Judith and Craven Williams Family Foundation," their non-profit corporation, is, as you state, accessible from their filing of the 990-PF form with the US Department of Treasury. Futher information is also available from the Urban Institute National Center for Charitable Statistics. According to the 990-PF, the Family Foundation had assets with a market value of $213, 614.38 in June 2008. That year $4,304.67 was paid to A. G. Edwards and Sons, Inc., for managing the Family's assets, and $11,600.00 was contributed to charities. This is a ratio of greater than one dollar spent in administrative costs for every three dollars contributed to charities, that is to say, one third for administration. Greensboro College received $3,000, of which $1,000 was given to the President's Discretionary Fund.
The Family Foundation lists no gifts directly to the United Methodist Church; however, $5000 was given to three communions of the Epsicopal/Anglican Church, one of which worships at Greensboro. These gifts total $2000 more than the Family Foundation gave to Greensboro College. Of the $3000 given to the College, deducing the $1000 to the President's Discretionary Fund, $1000 was given to the Annual Fund campaign; $1000 was given to the Circle of Pride fundraising campaign. A gift of $100 was given to Dr. Williams' former seminary, at Richmond, Virginia; his wife's gift to her undergraduate alma mater, in the state of Alabama, was slightly higher, at $150.00.
Although I have misgivings about communicating with one who will not sign an actual name (surely the Williams would not censure you personally for speaking in what you think is a clarification of their non-profit incorporation), our exchange has been quite civil. In the continuance of that civility, please at least try not to rephrase my statements. A hypothetical statement is an assertion of possibility, based upon some known facts; a "suggestion," as you state I make, implies a preference or a belief. All that we really know about the Williams' incorporations and their activities are from the above facts, and all of the these facts are taken from credible documents in the public domain.

philprice@triad.rr.com

July 7, 2009 - 8:19 am EDT

This the time to give thought to the facts and reality of our situation; formulate a plan of action; consult and revise that plan; present for approval; and move forward. I pray that we all focus on what is good for Greensboro College. We exisit to serve and educate. We lead by example. May we seek truth to overcome ignorance and have understanding, may we have coruage to act on our understanding, and God help us all to act in a way that will enhance Greensboro College. Phil Price

eMail Updates

Advertisement | Advertise with Us

Featured Ads

Search

Advertisement | Advertise with Us
Advertisement | Advertise with Us
Advertisement | Advertise with Us

News & Record Network Sites

Triad Weather

  • Current Condition: LIGHT RAIN
  • Current Temperature: 50°
  • UV Idx: 0
  • Forecast High/Low: H: 0° L: 45°

User Tools

  • Social Networking
  • RSS
  • Share
  • Sign in to MyNR

Search