news-record.com

NEWS

Advertisement | Advertise with Us

Greensboro College fending off creditors

Sunday, June 28, 2009
(Updated Thursday, July 2 - 8:01 am)

Editor's Note: Because of incorrect information provided to the News & Record, this article misreported who pays the bill for a personal trainer for the wife of Greensboro College President Craven Williams. Williams personally reimburses Greensboro College for that expense.

A week ago, a lineman from Duke Energy handed an $8,000 disconnect notice to the undergrad working the front desk at Reynolds student union, saying Greensboro College had two hours to pay before the power would be turned off.

Monday, a sheriff’s deputy served the college’s vice president for business a summons to appear in small-claims court on a $1,245 office supply bill.

How bleak is the financial outlook at Greensboro College, where salaries were cut 20 percent this spring in an emergency move to avoid layoffs?

Bleak enough that a restructuring consultant last week sent a letter asking creditors to be patient in collecting past due bills of $974,508 — most of them owed to local businesses.

Having met its June payroll Friday, according to Chief Restructuring Officer Edward Sanz, the college must now raise enough money to keep operating through the summer until students return in full force this fall.

“It’s a tough patch, period, but we’re going to get through it,” said Sanz, whose Charlotte-based Naviscent Group was brought in by the college’s board of trustees two months ago to reorganize the school’s debt. “All the colleges are getting slammed right now.”

True, the recession has hit campuses private and public, decimating endowments while drying up gifts from well-heeled benefactors.

But for a small liberal arts college that has rarely made headlines in its 161-year history, the depth of Greensboro College’s financial woes is drawing notice.

So much so, that a national professional journal, the Chronicle of Higher Education, last week used the 1,300-student Greensboro College as a textbook example of, basically, how not to react to a crisis.

Under the front-page headline, “Broad Pay Cuts Make Deep Dents in Morale,” the story quoted, at length, anonymous faculty members highly critical of Craven Williams, the school’s president since 1993.

Williams, infuriated by the article and by recent discussion in the media of his $403,000 annual salary, said this week he has no intention of stepping down in response to the problems, as anonymous messages circulated on campus and on message boards have suggested.

“I don’t have anything to say to that,” Williams said. “Anybody can just say anything when they’re anonymous. Of course, it bothers me.”

Williams, who took the 20 percent cut along with his staff, has for years worn the hat of campus ambassador and fundraiser-in-chief.

As such, says Sanz, the president’s use of a Sunset Drive home the college owns in Irving Park, complete with maid service and BMW, are the cost of doing business. They are, Sanz argues, the necessary accoutrements for entertaining would-be major donors.

But the college, in contrast, can barely meet its own basic needs, according to the school’s own list of outstanding bills obtained by the News & Record.

For example:

ARAMARK, the cafeteria  service, was owed $136,889. Of that, $93,564 was more than two months in arrears.

Waste Management’s bill was $13,388 past due; Royal Tours, the buses the college hires to transport athletes, was owed $50,276; a water bill for the city of Greensboro was over 90 days late at $6,500. Duke Energy was posting a $1,862 balance, of which $758 was two months late.

Karen Riffanacht, the student who was working at Reynolds Center when the Duke Energy truck arrived, said she thought the cutoff notice was a mistake.

“It was a very big surprise,” she said. “They said 'You have two hours to pay it.’ They didn’t want to shut it off and then have to come all the way back to turn it back on.”

Sanz called the incident a misunderstanding on Duke Energy’s part, over deposits being negotiated on several college accounts.

The college’s bills show tabs being run up at competing businesses — $4,122 at Office Depot, $5,847 at OfficeMax. Insurance bills, medical bills and legal bills are unpaid, as is money owed to nonprofit concerns such as $6,000 to the Berkshire Theatre Festival.

In addition, a membership at Greensboro Country Club has fallen from 60 to 90 days behind, according to the billing records.

Robert Stout, chairman of the school’s Board of Trustees  was out of state this week and could not be reached for comment. Other board members reached this week referred all questions to Stout.

Sanz said the fact that faculty members had not “bolted for the door” after the 20 percent pay cut was announced indicated the strong loyalty professors feel to Greensboro College. He conceded, however, that the tight job market in academia, as in other sectors, could also be a factor in retaining faculty.

Several professors contacted by the newspaper this week declined to comment, mindful of the school’s strict policy to direct reporters to school spokeswoman Cyndie Basinger.

Basinger said the college president would select faculty to be interviewed. She then sent questions to Dean of Faculty Paul Leslie.

Leslie said that since the pay cut, just two of 75 full-time faculty members had resigned to take other academic posts,  but that both had likely been courted over time by other institutions.

Shortly after the pay cut was announced, an anonymous letter, supposedly written by faculty members, made the rounds on campus, blaming Williams for the college’s crisis and criticizing his salary and benefits.

Asked whether that view, repeated in last week’s Chronicle, represents a consensus, Dean Leslie said his faculty “has not been polled as to their concerns.”

But as for the trouble the campus is having paying its bills to local businesses, Leslie said the struggle the school is having is obvious to faculty.

“We are aware that there are open invoices,” he said. “We’re working as diligently as possible so that this will have no effect on what happens in the classroom.”

Trustee chairman Stout is quoted in the Chronicle  as estimating that the school needs to raise “$5 million” in order to operate through the lean summer months, but Sanz said Friday he felt that figure was too high. Currently, the school is in the process of renegotiating its line of credit with Bank of America.

The good news for the school is that freshman enrollments are nearly in line with last year. But that won’t erase the cause of the school’s financial tumble.

The school’s endowment, against which the college had already been borrowing, lost its value on the market, plummeting from a starting point of $19 million down to its current  $12 million.

With many wealthy investors and private foundations in the same boat, the large gifts of previous years have not been forthcoming at Greensboro College, nor at other institutions in the area.

“The college lives on contributions and endowments,” observed Sanz, “but retiring a debt is a bit of a challenge. It’s not like raising money for a building that you can put someone’s name on. You can’t name a debt after someone.”

Contact Lorraine Ahearn at 373-7334 or lorraine.ahearn@news-record.com

 

Accompanying Photos

Staff photo (News & Record)

Photo Caption: The campus of Greensboro College.

Comments

This article has been closed to new comments. Comments are generally closed after 14 days. However, comments may be closed earlier at the discretion of the News & Record.

Inappropriate content? Please notify us.

Paul J

June 28, 2009 - 6:36 am EDT

Credit,Credit,Credit. Good old American way. $50K to transport athletes, $3.6 million for Coach K there sure seems to be something wrong with this education picture. Here is a school that teaches business admin. Don't think I would want my child going there.

DaveW

June 28, 2009 - 7:28 am EDT

And what does Coach K's salary have to do with Greensboro College?

Paul J

June 28, 2009 - 8:39 am EDT

Over all stupid spending on athletic programs when money is so tight.

clay

June 28, 2009 - 4:15 pm EDT

I am not a fan of Coach K, but I would wager he makes money for Duke University, far beyond the $3 million he gets paid.

blackballed

June 28, 2009 - 7:59 pm EDT

THATS WHAT I'D LIKE TO KNOW... HOW MUCH HE (OH I'M SORRY)WE, SPENT ON HIS PLUSH COUNTRY CLUB MEMBERSHIP AND FRINGE BENEFITS FOR HIS WIFE AND HOW MUCH HE HAS EARNED THE COLLEGE - HOW THAT MATHMATICAL EQUATION SHAPING UP? IT IS DEPLORABLE THAT HE WOULD DO THIS AND THINK IT IS OK

connieohyeah

June 28, 2009 - 2:41 pm EDT

My, what nice, new clothes you have, Craven. His heart's not in the right place, or else he would have sacrificed the Bimmer, the Club membership (I bet he feels silly there right now, because the Club types don't like posers), and the Sunset Drive crib. It seems none of that stuff is working for him anyway because those "would-be donors" haven't exactly coughed up the cash.

The point is, all of his perks - the ones not doing the job they are intended to do - could solve the College's debt problem right now.

Panacea

June 28, 2009 - 9:25 am EDT

I have to seriously question the prioritization skills of a college president who continues to pay for a personal trainer for his wife when his college can't pay the power bill.

goingforward

June 28, 2009 - 5:56 pm EDT

This uncalled for criticism is exactly what is holding back Greensboro College. I just wish this writer and all the anonymous faculty would have the decency to bring their thoughts directly and face to face to the president of the college.

Panacea

June 28, 2009 - 7:51 pm EDT

Just how stupid do you think those faculty are?

blackballed

June 28, 2009 - 8:13 pm EDT

AS WE LOSE OUR JOBS - YEAH RIGHT WHAT A JOKE!!!!

fatboyfanuci

July 1, 2009 - 8:14 pm EDT

Craven, is that you? Get off the computer and get back to work.

LettuceAlone

July 2, 2009 - 8:33 pm EDT

Funny one, fatboy!

fitnessfan

June 29, 2009 - 12:05 pm EDT

I know for a fact that Mrs. Williams pays for her OWN personal training out of her OWN pocket. Get your facts straight and don't bring her into this.

wolfpackgrad

July 7, 2009 - 6:04 pm EDT

Trainer or no trainer.....get with the issue. Just like Madoff's wife knew of his stealing, Wlliams wife knew of her husband's expenses and the last time I went to an Alumni gathering she was not begging to donate any funds or willing to cut luxuries for the sake of the school. Don't bring her into this, heck she is IN THIS right along with her husband.

connieohyeah

June 28, 2009 - 9:59 am EDT

It seems Craven is much like the great Methodist Theologian John Wesley, for Wesley didn't like to ask others for money. However, as Craven points out, "Wesley was known to have given away much of the income that came to him."

Craven on Fundraising: http://greensborocollege.edu/about/presidentscorner/origins-detail.cfm?c...

And on Debt: http://greensborocollege.edu/about/presidentscorner/origins-detail.cfm?c...

On "Plain Clothes:" http://greensborocollege.edu/about/presidentscorner/origins-detail.cfm?c...

bigbaby31

June 28, 2009 - 10:40 am EDT

I just graduated from Greensboro College, my son graduates in December. When I attend graduate school, it will be at Greensboro College. Why? My experience as an undergraduate was wonderful with small class size and caring professors. Last semester, my professors took a 20% paycut and loss of benefits. I was amazed at their professionalism. I never heard their troubles mentioned and teaching went on as if nothing had happened. Thank you for putting your students first. Mr. Williams, it is time to step down and allow Greensboro College to live. We need for the community to rally around Greensboro College and help get it back on track. That will not happen as long as you are president. The article printed in News & Record will only keep perspective students from enrolling at Greensboro College which will cause further losses to the college and our community.

kville native

June 28, 2009 - 4:46 pm EDT

As a fellow alumna of Greensboro College, I completely agree with you. The faculty and staff of GC are amazing and what kept me there for four years. I am horribly disappointed in my College President and feel like the best thing he can do for the College is pay back money, resign, and let the College move on to heal and become an amazing place again.

Paul J

June 28, 2009 - 5:17 pm EDT

So do you two think the financial troubles should be hidden from prospective students? It is the duty of the news and fish wrap to report these stories if if they pull double duty as censors.

blackballed

June 28, 2009 - 8:03 pm EDT

NOT ONLY IS IT BEING HIDDEN FROM THE STUDENTS BUT THE FACULTY. ONLY A SELECT PRIVATE FEW KNOW THE REAL STORY.... I SUSPECT IF YOU REALLY DUG INTO THE DIRT THE CFO 'DISMISSAL' WAS A SCAPEGOAT

collegehill

June 28, 2009 - 4:07 pm EDT

Craven Williams has lost all credibility and with that his effectiveness. How can he justify the defferred maintenance at the school when the college is footing the bill for his wife's personal trainer?

At a time when GC needs a leader they respect they have none.Craven Williams has no credibility and no power left. He did not bring in Sanz, the bank made him choose among three firms that specialize in failing businesses. Williams also spends all day in his office, probably because he knows no one wants to see him anymore.

Staff and faculty don't respect Craven Williams, they just fear for their jobs. He respects no one but himself and apparently has no shame.

goingforward

June 28, 2009 - 5:58 pm EDT

No there is no substance to that. The faculty and staff respect the president and vice versa. End of story.

Panacea

June 28, 2009 - 7:53 pm EDT

Really.

If that anonymous letter really weren't written by the faculty, then why didn't they rise up as a group to protest it?

Because the faculty DID write it, and they DON'T have faith in their president.

Clearly, you are a GC admin shill.

LettuceAlone

June 28, 2009 - 8:39 pm EDT

Honestly, GoingForward....what kool-aid have you been drinking? Yes the stock market played a part on this calamity, but Craven Williams did the most damage in causing this financial meltdown at GC. He has been on a spending spree for years now...intent on making GC a contender in football and lacrosse. What a money-pit that escapade has been! It is a common belief among the College "family" that he is looking for his legacy. I suppose this is his legacy! It is time for him to go. He has lost his focus and his strength. I don't know of many folks on campus who can say they respect him, and we feel like he does not respect us. We are polite to him, but mostly, we do our best to avoid him, which has not been difficult lately since he stays sequestered in his office all day long. This year, he bolted immediately following graduation, which is something that he has never done before. He would always stay around speaking to faculty and students, then eventually make his dignified exit. Not so this year. He took off like a scalded dog. I think he knows that it is time for him to step down, but his pride and vanity prevent him from doing so. Until he decides to resign, I fear that the quagmire at GC will continue unabated.

logicfairy

June 30, 2009 - 1:39 am EDT

goingforward, you are wrong. Williams is seen as an egomaniac.

I'm a former staff member who talked to most of the faculty and staff while I was there. I know. You obviously do not.

HornetMan

June 28, 2009 - 5:31 pm EDT

The Greensboro "Pride" is about to be stung by its old mascot. The theory behind changing the mascot from the "Hornets" to the "Pride" was because there were to many hornets...the Greensbooro Hornets "A" baseball team, the Western Guilford HS Hornets, and at the time...the new Charlotte Hornets NBA team. Two changes were about to happen...adding football and later lacrosse. The reason...male athletes historicly give more to there schools. The years since I have grtaduated, I have enjoyed the football games and the "Souper Bowl" between Guilford College, but I don't think the theory of spending more in athletics has paid off. The historicly womens college is aging out of old money and it's starting to show. And this issue of "cost of doing business"...I don't need to be entertained at the Country Club...just give a tour of the campus and show me the actual needs of the college. Well that's my two cents...Mad as a Hornet

goingforward

June 28, 2009 - 5:47 pm EDT

No you have it all wrong. President Craven Williams is Greensboro Colleges' greatest strength. His talents and dedication are what the school needs to surmount this economic "perfect storm" caused only by the stock market. Our president draws the bare minimum salary he needs to do a great job for Greensboro College and for the whole community. The faculty members who have criticized him should be forced to publicly apologize .

HornetMan

June 28, 2009 - 11:33 pm EDT

It is NOT the stock market's fault and I didn't mention that Craven was not a gifted and talented man. It's a lack of planning... It's the "keeping up with Jones' " feeling. If you don't have the funding, then don't create programs you can't afford to run successfully. Mr. Fred Proctor gave a lot to GC before he passed away, but we can't always rely on the gifts from the likes Mr. Fred Proctor and Mr. and Mrs. Royce Reynolds. GC has or had a great niche, but the early stages of this money problem started when they raised money by selling the land across the railroad tracks to Guilford County for what is now Weaver Education Center.

blackballed

June 28, 2009 - 8:29 pm EDT

HEY GOING FORWARD - FACE IT ... IF THIS WAS HIS GREATEST STRENGTH WE WOULD NOT BE IN THIS MESS. HE WOULD HAVE SEEN THIS COMING OR LISTENED TO THOSE SPEAKING TO HIM AND INSTEAD OF OWNING UP TO HIS MISTAKES OR ADMITING HE MAY NEED HELP WE WOULD NOT HAVE GOTTEN THIS FAR INTO DEBT. SAD PATHETIC TRUTHS THAT WE ARE IN THIS SHAPE. HE HAS NOT ONE OUNCE OF CLUE HOW FAR REACHING THIS 20% HIT HAS TAKEN HIS FACULTY AND STAFF. PEOPLE HAVING TO SELL OFF POSSESSIONS, REFINANCE HOMES, AND TAKE OUT EXTRA LOANS OR WORK SECOND JOBS TO LIVE!!!!! HE SHOULD BE ASHAMED TO STAND IN FRONT OF TIRELESS WORKERS WHO KEEP GOING AND SAY THAT 20% IS EQUAL - WHATS 20% OF 403,000..... AND WHATS 20% OF NOTHING!!!!!!! TRY GOING BACK TO MATH CLASS OR BETTER YET BUSINESS ETHICS 101

histrion

June 29, 2009 - 4:14 pm EDT

Do you realize how difficult it is to read something written in all caps? Honestly, man: Turn off caps-lock!

hasanova

July 2, 2009 - 12:23 am EDT

So, goingforward, if Craven WIlliams draws the "bare minimum salary" required for a man of his stature, why does the President of Guilford College, for example, make around $225,000? Guilford's endowment is at least 7 to 8 times higher, its student body is twice as big, its campus is larger and more complex and its admission standards and student acceptance rate are far superior. I guess being founded a year earlier gave the Quakers a tremendous headstart! lol It's leadership and vision ... not ego. Your comments are the party line. You are truly a shill ... or perhaps Williams himself. Perhaps the Board should investigate his "legacy" at Gardener-Webb ... word is they fired him. G-W's Observatory bears his name, but his contribution to Greensboro College is shaping up to be anything but stellar ... unless, of course, a black hole counts! It's time for him to go so the college can save itself.

eMail Updates

Advertisement | Advertise with Us

Featured Ads

Search

Advertisement | Advertise with Us
Advertisement | Advertise with Us
Advertisement | Advertise with Us

News & Record Network Sites

Triad Weather

  • Current Condition: FAIR
  • Current Temperature: 54°
  • UV Idx: 2
  • Forecast High/Low: H: 67° L: 40°

User Tools

  • Social Networking
  • RSS
  • Share
  • Sign in to MyNR

Search