news-record.com

NEWS

Advertisement | Advertise with Us

Illness at Oak Ridge Elementary worries parents, staff

Thursday, May 21, 2009
(Updated 11:11 am)

OAK RIDGE — School officials told parents and staff of Oak Ridge Elementary School they need help to figure out what is making students and staff sick at the school.

In a meeting Wednesday night with local and state health officials, parents and staff told of students whose noses and eyes bleed and who get migraines and suffer from sinus and respiratory infections. One teacher held up medical records showing that he tested positive for toxic mold exposure.

The complaints began in 2005 after renovations and additions were completed on the school. Mold has been found at the school twice in the past four years.

The school system reports spending nearly $600,000 addressing mold and other issues at the school. The system spent nearly $400,000 installing a dehumidification system four years ago. This month, carpet found to have mold was removed from several classrooms.

Leo Bobadilla, Guilford County Schools’ chief operations officer, said tests have been done and issues have been addressed. At this point, workers can’t find any other issues, he said.

“As far as we know, there is not an issue here,” Bobadilla said.
Schools Superintendent Maurice “Mo” Green said he thinks there is an issue at the school but the school system needs outside help identifying it. He told the parents he has not seen anything to persuade him to close the school early, despite requests from them to do so.

“At this point I am looking for more information myself,” Green said. “At this point I am not recommending to the (school) board that this school be closed.”

School board member Darlene Garrett, whose district includes Oak Ridge Elementary, said she believes there is something at the school making people sick but she will not recommend closing it early to the school board.

Several parents have already pulled their children out of the school. Last year, 27 students were withdrawn from the school. This year, 15 have been withdrawn, though the school system does not keep specific records on students’ reasons for leaving.

Faculty members say they are paying a high price to keep teaching there. Mark Potter, who twice has been named teacher of the year at Oak Ridge in his four years there, says he has tested positive for toxic mold exposure. He is thinking about leaving the school.

“This raises big questions for me, if I’m going to be here next year,” Potter said.

Potter said he went to the doctor after having insomnia, rashes and headaches. Like many at the meeting, he said officials said nothing to instill confidence that the issue would be resolved.

Parent Damita Watkin Amick said she understands other parents’ frustrations. But finding the problem is proving difficult, she said, and the community needs to be patient.

“I just think there are too many variables to expect a quick, five-minute fix tonight,” she said.

The school system has teamed with health officials from county and state health departments to address the issue. Dr. Ward Robinson, medical director with the Guilford County Department of Public Health, told the parents and teachers his office is investigating the problems. But mold, he said, is not the problem.

Parents asked Robinson if he thought it was safe for people to be at the school.

“I don’t know how to answer that because I don’t know what the problem is,” Robinson said.

Robinson said his team will meet this morning to discuss what steps to take next.

Parents also expressed frustration with what they described as a lack of leadership on the issue and asked Green to take ownership. Green said he owns every issue in the school system and once health officials make recommendations the district will act on them.
They also said the issue was made worse when workers failed to properly seal off classrooms when removing the moldy carpet last week. Bobadilla flatly denied this, which enraged some in the audience.

Contact J. Brian Ewing at 373-7351 or brian.ewing@news-record.com

Comments

This article has been closed to new comments. Comments are generally closed after 14 days. However, comments may be closed earlier at the discretion of the News & Record.

Inappropriate content? Please notify us.

NoMoreSchoolMold

May 20, 2009 - 6:20 pm EDT

Parents who are concerned about health problems can visit The Center for School Mold Help (www.schoolmoldhelp.org), for a reliable archive of over 1750 articles on the topic. Our SMH School Health Checklist is available for parents (and school staff) to help recognize potential building problems, a free resource, at http://www.schoolmoldhelp.org/content/view/918/55/.

notagain

May 21, 2009 - 8:17 am EDT

Maybe after school lets out for the summer the administration should go to work there. Lets see if any of them start to feel sick. If they do, then they will take the problem seriously.

Huck9

May 21, 2009 - 8:41 am EDT

Maybe it's the water in Oak Ridge.

debbie180

May 21, 2009 - 10:19 am EDT

I thought the same thing maybe it's something with the water. If the Health Department has done all that they can as well as the School System spending money to try and correct the problem. They need to check other options. What have the doctors said when the children were taken to them ? If parents want to take the kids out and send them where what's the next school of choice ? They may feel better but if the children still get sick something else is wrong.

miche

May 21, 2009 - 2:34 pm EDT

Firstly, the health department has NOT done all it can! There are many things that could be causing the toxicity, yet they have only checked for mold. Additionally, there have been findings which, for whatever reason, are not being disclosed (I have seen one the of official reports). As for the suggestion that it is something in Oak Ridge's water, don't you think there would be Oak Ridge residents of all ages complaining of these issues? The ONE common thread among the students and teachers who are sick is OAK RIDGE ELEMENTARY.

We parents are not looking for something to whine about--in fact, many of us have ignored or rationalized the problem for far too long! We are simply trying to find out what toxic substance is compromising our childrens' health, as any good parent would do. If hearing about classrooms where one-third to one-half of the children complain of headaches on a daily basis (and often ONLY in that particular classroom), or about children getting nose bleeds so badly that blood comes out of their eyes isn't enough to convince skeptics, they should know that in one classroom shortly after a fish tank got moved nearer the ventilation system, all 20 fish died.

Anyone who knows the facts and statistics can not deny there is something toxic in that school. Just because the source has yet to be isolated, doesn't mean it isn't there! If you doubt it, I challenge you to send your children there.

mbowlin001

May 22, 2009 - 2:44 pm EDT

I was talking to a friend that works at Pierce Elementary off Pleasant Ridge Rd. This school and Colfax would be the options. I would take my son to Pierce. There is a gentleman you can contact to ask for a transfer.

mbowlin001

May 22, 2009 - 2:42 pm EDT

I agree maybe then they will understand what we are talking about.

EGParent

May 21, 2009 - 8:43 am EDT

I had to fight a similiar situation with Guilford County Schools a few years back...

My son was sick every week with ever worsening migraine headaches and nausea...from the beginning of school
Other children were complaining of headaches and illnesses but in a school with almost
a 1000 students that can be the norm. He was out for Christmas break for a week and
was fine. The first day back at school I received a phone call...another get in the bed,
turn off the lights, sleep for 6 hours headache. After many visits to the doctor, we tried
to figure out what was triggering it. My son said when I smell that smell at the school is
when it starts...

Turns out the school had a septic odor smell that was worse on Monday's and Tuesdays on two halls....
Some people could smell it others could not. This is caued nasal fatigue...my son must have been the canary in the cave....

The school had to hire an environmental expert to come in and find the problem...
a septic pipe had been left uncovered since the school had been built seven years earlier....
the pipe opened into a maintenance room which contained the air handler for the front hall and the eigth grade hall....methane gas was coming out of the pipe and going into the air handler...

There are a lot of side affects to long term exposure to low levels of methane gas...one of which is short term memory loss, headaches, some chronic intestinal illnesses...etc..

The environmentalist told the school they had 24 hours to cover the pipe or they could close the school....the students and staff had been exposed for years.....

Staff told me that the building had an odor that would come and go for years...
.
All it took was a simple pipe cover to solve the problem....he never had a headache again.....

Moral of this story...as a parent I felt like I was being a trouble maker.....the parents are not the problem...

Mo hire an environmental expert and find the problem!!....
Something is wrong here.....formaldehyde?? other building materials??

Parents stay on top of them....I called them twice a week every week for months before it was finally resolved...

chickenlittle02

May 21, 2009 - 9:29 am EDT

Good for you! Parents need to realize that when all is said and done, the buck stops with them. If my child were in this school I would pull him out. I am utterly amazed that with the overwhelming evidence of illness despite not being able to find a cause, that the school board isn't closing this school until they get it figured out! We can only hope that whatever is causing these problems doesn't turn out to be something that can cause irreparable harm to the children and staff. It just seems prudent that if you don't know, you would err on the side of caution.

shamel

May 21, 2009 - 7:22 pm EDT

Oak Ridge school officials and parents may want to check out the remarkable research on toxic mold removal done by environmental expert Dr Ed Close. Simply diffusing a therapeutic-grade oil regularly in these school buildings would likely result in an environment very hostile to mold. Moreover, numerous studies have shown breathing natural oils improves classroom performance.
http://www.secretofthieves.com/mold.cfm/79544

eMail Updates

Advertisement | Advertise with Us

Featured Ads

Search

Advertisement | Advertise with Us
Advertisement | Advertise with Us
Advertisement | Advertise with Us

News & Record Network Sites

Triad Weather

  • Current Condition: MOSTLY CLOUDY
  • Current Temperature: 53°
  • UV Idx: 2
  • Forecast High/Low: H: 60° L: 39°

User Tools

  • Social Networking
  • RSS
  • Share
  • Sign in to MyNR

Search