news-record.com

EDUCATION

Advertisement | Advertise with Us

Northern basketball team stripped of championship title

Thursday, May 14, 2009
(Updated Friday, May 15 - 3:35 pm)

Editor's Note: This article incorrectly indicated that Guilford County Schools superintendent Maurice “Mo” Green named specific school employees at Northern High officials who should have known that two basketball players were ineligible. Green did not name the employees.

GREENSBORO — Two months after Northern Guilford made history as the first school to win a state basketball title without a senior on its roster, the school earned another, less noble distinction Wednesday when it became the first Guilford County school to be stripped of a state championship.

The N.C. High School Athletic Association saw to that, vacating the Nighthawks of their 3-A title a day after Guilford County Schools determined the Nighthawks used two players who should not have been attending the school.

Hours after the Nighthawks lost their title, they lost their head coach, too. School Superintendent Maurice “Mo” Green told basketball coach Stan Kowalewski his contract would not be renewed.

Kowalewski criticized the investigation, calling it “flawed from start to finish.” He described schools attorney Jill Wilson, the leader of the six-monthlong investigation, as “obviously an amateur.”

He said school system officials will have to face the wrath of Northern parents, particularly those whose boys played on the basketball team.

“This is not about me; this is about the kids,” he said. “I can assure you (the parents) will rise up and stand for their kids. This is not over.”

It’s not. Green said that the Northern investigation remains open and that other teams — including the football program — are being looked into for ineligible players. Green and Wilson said other Guilford County schools are being investigated, based on findings and accusations that have come out of the Northern probe.

School system officials said Wednesday that five Northern students playing on four athletics teams were determined ineligible based on the state athletics association’s domicile rule. Green said those students will be allowed to finish the school year at Northern but will be sent back to their correct school in the fall. Those students will be ineligible to participate in athletics next year, an indication school officials believe they tried to deceive Northern officials on their residency.

Some of the students ruled ineligible played in more than one sport at Northern, Green said. In addition to the two basketball players, investigators found that:

  • The baseball team played with one ineligible player. The team, which was preparing to play in this week’s first round of the state playoffs, forfeited all its game and was removed from the playoffs. Western Alamance, a wild card team, took Northern’s place in the playoffs. Northeast Guilford, which was out of the playoffs Wednesday morning, became a wild card team Wednesday night.
  • The wrestling team used two ineligible wrestlers. Both have forfeited their matches. Officials are still determining if the team must forfeit overall matches in which those players won.
  • The junior varsity softball team played an ineligible student and must forfeit all its games.
  • A JV cheerleader was also found to be ineligible. Cheerleading is not a sanctioned sport.

The high school association also fined Northern $1,250, or $250 for each infraction. The school must also return more than $7,800 in playoff revenue.

Green declined to name the athletes, citing privacy issues. He said the basketball team lost its state title because school system officials believed the ineligible players should have been caught.

Northern principal Joe Yeager and Athletics Director Derrell Force resigned from Northern on April 10 — the same day school system officials announced they were looking into the eligibility issues.

Wilson said she found “red flags” immediately after looking at some students’ records.

“Those flags should have come up just as quickly” with school officials, she said.

Vacating a state championship is rare in North Carolina. The last time it happened was in 1995, when Cary High lost its state basketball title for using an ineligible player. Que Tucker, deputy executive director of the high school athletics association, said Wednesday she looked at “every angle, every possibility” before making the decision.

Northern defeated Gastonia’s Forestview for the state title on March 14. Tucker said no team would be recognized as the 3-A state champion.

Green said coaches and parents need to be better educated on the system’s residency policy. He hopes to have public meetings to address that issue.

“It’s a sad day for Northern and Guilford County,” Green said. “But we’re going to learn from this and we’re going to get things right.”

Flanked by Wilson and Guilford County Athletics Director Leigh Hebbard at Wednesday’s news conference, Green declined to discuss why Kowalewski’s contract would not be renewed. Green said the status of other coaches is being reviewed.

Kowalewski said Green told him Wednesday the school had found no wrongdoing on Kowalewski’s part. He said Green wanted “a fresh start” to the program.

Kowalewski said Wednesday night he would not recommend his players ever play basketball within Guilford County as long as Green was superintendent, but he reserved most of his anger for Wilson. He accused her of trying to find fault where there was none to justify the cost of the investigation. Wilson and Green said they didn’t know the cost.

Wilson, Kowalewski said, “is obviously an amateur and that her underlings wanted to treat rumor as fact throughout the investigation.”

“In recent days the techniques that (Wilson) used were absolutely despicable, trying to frame me to look like I’ve done something wrong,” he said.

School officials stressed that the findings released Wednesday dealt with eligibility issues related to where students said they lived. Green declined to discuss allegations of academic abuse or recruiting — issues sources have said the school system was looking into. He said investigators were still examining those issues.

School system officials also released more than 1,200 pages of e-mails — conveniently packaged in a box — between Northern officials that were requested by the News & Record and WFMY-2 last year in response to a lawsuit filed by Kowalewski against Northwest Athletics Director John Hughes. Sources have said those e-mails could show Northern coaches were involved in recruiting athletes, a violation of local and NCHSAA rules.

Contact Robert Bell at 373-7055 or robert.bell@news-record.com

Accompanying Photos

File photo (News & Record)

Photo Caption: Northern Guilford basketball coach Stan Kowalewski is hugged by his players after the Nighthawks defeated Gastonia Forestview in the 3-A state championship game in March.

Timeline

2007: Guilford County Schools clears Northern Guilford High’s athletics program of allegations of recruiting.

Fall 2008: Superintendent Maurice “Mo” Green opens a new investigation into Northern Guilford’s athletics program.

April 10: Three Northern employees — principal Joe Yeager, Athletics Director Derrell Force and head custodian Louis Lawson — resign. Schools system officials later announce they are investigating Northern’s athletics program over eligibility issues.

April 16: Lawson, whose son plays for the Northern Guilford basketball team, rescinds his resignation, saying he was coerced.

April 23: The N.C. High School Athletic Association announces that Page High used an unnamed, ineligible player during the 2008 football season. Patricia Hughes says the player is her son, Gabe King. Hughes said Page officials knew her son was ineligible all along. Schools system officials are investigating her allegations.

April 24: Guilford County school board members vote unanimously to fire Lawson.

May 6: Green tells Northern Guilford parents, teachers and students he will investigate other schools if credible evidence is presented.

May 6: Sources tell the News & Record that school system officials are investigating whether Northeast Guilford basketball coach Curtis Hunter attempted to recruit Northern Guilford basketball player Michael Neal last month.

May 13: Guilford County Schools rules that five students at Northern are ineligible because of residency issues. The school has been stripped of its 3-A state championship title. Green says the county is investigating other schools.

Comments

This article has been closed to new comments. Comments are generally closed after 14 days. However, comments may be closed earlier at the discretion of the News & Record.

Inappropriate content? Please notify us.

Maku1da

May 14, 2009 - 11:26 am EDT

How would the NON FACULTY coach, know that a child is at the school illegally? He (Coach K) was there to COACH the team, NOT POLICE the team.. It should have been up to the CHILD'S parents or the school admistration to keep up with that..

tammac

May 14, 2009 - 11:34 am EDT

Well I guess the school has decided to go in another direction. Maybe they want someone who is willing to take on more responsibility.

whatcanIsay

May 14, 2009 - 11:44 am EDT

You all can keep playing this NIEVE game. It not the point that did he know. It is how much are you involved with getting it done. Maybe like hiring a janitor or 2 and both just happen to have athletic kids. Maybe Mr. Rich has some rental house he is subleasing we do not know about. You not going to get everything from the article and they are not going to tell everything they found out.

And Academic and Athletic has different rules. You can falsify all you want and go to another school as a student. The worst that can happen is they send you back to your school. But getting into a school with a false address does not allow you to play sports.

whatintheworld

May 14, 2009 - 11:29 am EDT

..and do we fire the English or Math teacher? Why does it only have to be if the team wins...?

whatintheworld

May 14, 2009 - 11:30 am EDT

Why do the kids get to continue at the wrong school academically?

Illiterati

May 15, 2009 - 9:04 am EDT

whatintheworld, it's all about money. You're missing the point that schools have a lot of money at stake with their sports programs. There are many ways they profit from winning basketball and football teams, in the form of ticket and concession sales, sponsorships, parental support, and even a few not-so-kosher under-the-table deals with college recruiters and so on.

Academics, ironically, don't make money for schools. Except in the form of funding for passing those EOGs and other standardized tests, but that's another article. So if a parent transfers their kid "illegally" to another school for academic reasons and gets caught, there's no drama because there's no financial impact. They just get kicked back to their "legal" school.

FactGiver

May 14, 2009 - 11:31 am EDT

The REAL issue here that separate this incident from other incidents such as the one where the Page kid blatantly misled the Page admin, is that in this case, the coach knowingly assisted players/knew of players who were using false addresses as uncovered by the investigation. He has a history of doing this and it started at HPC and has followed him to Northern Guilford. The saddest part of all this is that as an adult, he continues to side-step the issue and absolutely REFUSES to accept responsibility for what he has done. That is the sign of a coward and and an individual who has no business around young people in this country. Any AD or Principal who hires this clown deserves to lose their job. He is the most classless coach in this area and truly believes that he is bigger than any program or county. Believe that! I sincerely hope that all of you Northern Guilford parents who have put your faith in this guy have learned your lesson. It's unfortunate that it's at the expense of your children. You deserve better and need to step up from here on out and demand as much from whoever the next leader of that program is! I wish you well, I really do. The first step in the growth process is admission of guilt so start there and rally yourselves and build a program that is respectable with folks in your district....

whatintheworld

May 14, 2009 - 11:36 am EDT

He must be a good coach if he can rally players together in unity for a common purpose and accomplish that goal. The coach didn't fill out the address form, the parents did. The parent is accountable.

bballcrazy.sarah

May 14, 2009 - 1:05 pm EDT

Sounds like you believe that the end justifies the means!
This isn't a theoretical debate where in general coaches may/may not be responsible for qualifying the team players, this is a situation where the coach lied and repeated the dishonest behavior at three different schools - Bishop MacGuiness, High Point Central and now Northern. He cheated, or aided others to cheat in all three situations. How many times does he have to do it before you get the picture. Don't fall for his "I'm the the victim/they're conspiring to get me/they're incompetent" crap. That's why he was fired in all three situations. Great example for our kids, and now you support this behavior. What don't you Get???
BTW, there's no chance that your son plays on one of his teams, right? Full and honest declarations of conflict of interest would be appreciated. And no, I don't have a conflict of interest, other than detesting all cheats especially where kids are involved.

ilvteaching

May 14, 2009 - 1:35 pm EDT

If you are going to be so indignant, at least get your facts straight. Recruiting isn't illegal at Bishop Mcguiness; it is private. He got in trouble for bringing in African American players. perhaps you think that it a terrible thing to do, but many of us don't. Second he absolutely was NOT fired from Central; he was asked by Force to go with him to Northern. Third, Green said Coach K was not at fault for not knowing that the parents of those two players falsified their addresses. No, my son doesn't play for Coach K but your very statement acknowledges that you know his players and their families love him.

The reason many of us support him is 1) we know enough to know that people like you don't know the facts and 2) there has been no evidence produced that K, Force or Yeager knew these 5 kids were illegal. only that they "should have known". I would be willing to bet 100,000 dollars that if you went into ANY high school in this county with a team of attorneys and investigated all the athletes for 6 weeks, not one school who has althetic teams would come out clean.

dpep

May 14, 2009 - 4:06 pm EDT

Speaking of getting facts straight. The thing coach K got in trouble for at Bishop was not bringing in African American players but rather bringing in players from out of state and beyond that had never attended Catholic School or paid into the system. They were given starting positions while the kids who grew up in the Triad Area Catholic School System either sat on the bench or didn’t play at all. Bishop is a parochial school. The difference is that a private school is 100% funded by the students and family that use it. The Catholic and most church affiliated systems are subsidized by the churches in the area that it serves. Therefore all of the church members support the school weather they use it or not. In the case of Bishop anyone that has a child in any of the feeder schools in the Triad Area Catholic System are accessed a healthy fee that pays for the building of the high school regardless of whether you have children that attend the high school or not. In addition funds that were set aside for need based scholarship’s were used for out of state students that were brought in just to play basketball while others were overlooked.

FactGiver

May 14, 2009 - 11:44 am EDT

And another thing, what respectable adult goes on camera for an interview and says some of the things he said last night. He just got fired for recruiting, allowing ineligible transfers on his team, and then recommends that none of his players play basketball in Guilford County next year when most of them live in the county? Think about that. That is the type of person you are dealing with. The other big issue is the parents who are coming to his defense which is laughable. I'm sure that he has treated your children well, however, he also used/abused the youth of your children by using them as pawns in his attempt to gain credibility as a coach in this area. His mis-use/abuse of your children should be noted by everybody. At the end of the day, he's greatly tarnished the reputation of a school, athletic program, and the names of the players involved. He's also stolen an exciting piece of the lives of many young people who played both for him and against him this year. The kids from NG that lived in district were robbed of a memory for the rest of their lives. The kids from the opponent they played in the state title game were robbed of a memory that they can't get back. This is real life. You live and you learn, but in order to learn, you must see the big picture and admit wrongdoing to prevent it from happening again. Another funny thing about this whole ordeal is that Big Bad Coach Klown has tried to sue everybody from the AD at Northwest Guilford to the towel boy at Dudley, when in all actuality, the civil negligence shown by him in this situation is punishable in civil court. Wouldn't that be funny? If some parents of some of the Northern Guilford basketball players who live in district sued Coach K for damages caused to the lives of their young people.....If I were them, I'd at least look into it.....

dcolin

May 14, 2009 - 1:33 pm EDT

It's all a Red Herring.

Who cares about who wins.
We keep ignoring education and worried about sports

Look at Northerns math report card. Only 40% pass Algebra l
Thats a disgrace.

Some parent said best school in county. Thats scary.

The sport thing is simple to solve.
All coaches must be school full time teachers. Period.
No exceptions, no contracts.

get the facts straight

May 14, 2009 - 1:58 pm EDT

ilv teaching get real. I know several people at Bishop McGuinness. First, the whole thing about being fired at Bishop McGuinness because he brought in black players is something that Mr. Kowalewski (sp?) told people after he was fired. That is bull and I know the school had quite a laugh over that claim. I think having more diversity at the school is something the school cherishes and they have a large minority population for a private school, but the majority of them do not play sports. 2nd, where did you get that recruiting at private schools is allowable? In fact, it is a violation in the NC Private school league as well. Lets put it this way. Mr. K was fired for many different things and bringing in minorities was not one of them. That was his claim and he is a liar. Also, is this not the third time he has been publicly fired? Here is an interesting link: see if any of the quotes sound familiar. http://www.thefreelibrary.com/Is+this+money+manager+hedging+more+than+be...

get the facts straight

May 14, 2009 - 2:19 pm EDT

and one other thing. Just because this coach claimes that Mo Green told him he did not do anything wrong does not mean that Mo Green really said that. I quite doubt that he was told that just as when he claimed the Guilford County School Attorney told him he did nothing wrong back a month or so ago. That clearly never happened either. Just because he says something in the media does not make it fact.

ilvteaching

May 14, 2009 - 2:23 pm EDT

How is it "clear" that never happened? What exactly have they proven Stan did wrong? Not know that parents were lying about an address? Wow, what a terrible person

get the facts straight

May 14, 2009 - 3:44 pm EDT

Yeah, he didn't know. Keep sipping the Kool Aid.

ilvteaching

May 14, 2009 - 6:38 pm EDT

So why is it so obvious that he lied?
Do you think that no one wanted to go to the new 60-million dollar school and Stan had to convince them to?
Or do you think the parents aren't smart enough to lie without Stan's help and instructions?
Or maybe you just dislike Stan so much you assume he is lying when there is no proof of that, or any logical reaon why he would?

As an aside, most people who volunteer in the public school system for hours every day (yes, I know he is paid 75 cents and hour or something . . same thing) are pretty good people - they generally aren't evil even if they are found to have an ineligible player. I am curious, how much time do you spend volunteering in the public school system?

Do you know Stan and Traci? I am taking a wild guess that you don't

ilvteaching

May 14, 2009 - 2:33 pm EDT

Dcolin, Don't judge Northern's academics based on Algebra I scores. Algebra I, even though it is a "high school" course, is now standard in the 8th grade. Therefore, only 9th graders who failed algebra in the 8th grade take the test. So it is not as if 40% of the student body failed the algebra test . .I think if you look at Northwest, Grimsley etc.. .you will find algebra I score low everywhere.

dcolin

May 14, 2009 - 9:05 pm EDT

Algebra ll is not much better. 62% ( below state average )
Supposedly honors is their simplest No college prep offered.
Think about why that is
All smoke and mirrors except for basketball I guess.

Again if they are the best it is scary.

ilvteaching

May 14, 2009 - 6:28 pm EDT

One would hope the student had an ongoing relationship with the teacher. And yes, children transfer and lie about their residence for academic reason too.

teabag

May 14, 2009 - 2:23 pm EDT

This whole situation has been enlightening for me. I wholeheartedly admit I have considered and have come very close to enrolling my child in a school outside our district through the various means mentioned. I must say, I never once thought about sports because my child doesn’t really play sports, my reasons were safety and academics. Has anyone considered that if many of the schools weren’t so HORRIBLE that parents wouldn’t be so desperate to get their children out of their home district?

I have a college degree, work really hard, earn a good living, pay my taxes, go to church, volunteer, I’ve never had a single speeding ticket …but the thought of sending my child to the lousy school we’re districted to makes me sick, sick enough to want to find a way around it.

I’m not saying the end justifies the means, to the contrary, after reading this article and all the posts I now realize how very harmful doing this to my child could have been. I could have taught my child I was a liar. I could have hurt the teachers, the AD, and the fellow students and parents. I will not be changing districts. However, I think Mo needs to look at an even bigger picture when the sports investigation is finished. I know MANY people whose children attend schools outside their district because the schools they are in are full of drugs & gangs, are OLD and falling apart, don’t have the resources they need, don’t have the best teachers, etc. Seeing a new, fancy, suburban state-of-the-art school can make even the most rule-following, law-abiding parent crave that for their child. And why shouldn’t they? Who doesn’t want their child to get the best and safest education possible? Why shouldn't my tax dollar count as much as the priviledge people?

And (before you blast me with posts) it’s not always easy to just MOVE. We live close to our places of employment, near close family and good neighbors, and in a house we love. It’s very difficult to expect parents to give up everything that matters them and their quality of life just to escape 4 or 7 years of middle/high school.

I wish Guilford County would consider an open district similar to Forsythe County. In Forsythe you have a choice of several schools in a given district so the options are greater. I think this arrangement would lower the number of those willing to break the rules for a decent school. Until they do we'll either list our house (assuming we can sell it in this down market) or send our child to the district school full of thugs and thuglets.

ilvteaching

May 14, 2009 - 2:26 pm EDT

Teabag, parents do it EVERY day. To single out Northern and pretend that it doesn't happen everywhere else is absurd.

teabag

May 14, 2009 - 5:17 pm EDT

Err... I am not singling out Northern. I don't even mention them in my post.

ilvteaching

May 14, 2009 - 6:31 pm EDT

I did not mean you were singling them out - the system is. Sorry

tammac

May 14, 2009 - 2:46 pm EDT

Have you looked into the Magnet School options in Guilford county? I went to the magnet fair and there seem to be quite a few options for IB schools for jr and senior high. We moved into an area that is supposed to have great schools, but have explored a magnet school choice for our elementary school child because we feel it would be a better fit for his learning style. Being a parent is hard and you try your best, but you should always model honest and ethical behavior if you want your children to behave in the same way.

ilvteaching

May 14, 2009 - 2:54 pm EDT

We are lucky in Guilford County to have great magnet programs - my children are in them. No one is advocating lying. But to pretend that the 5 athletes caught living outside the district are the only ones in Guilford County doing it is stupid. I think it is terrible that all the children at Northern are suffering and being called cheaters because 4 parents lied (2 of the kids are siblings).

Panacea

May 14, 2009 - 9:55 pm EDT

No one's pretending the problems at Northern are exclusive to Northern. The investigation isn't over, and I think we'll see more heads rolling and more schools in the limelight before long.

Yes, it's a shame some kids at Northern are suffering. But the way you talk, I get the impression you'd rather see the whole thing swept under the rug, and go back to business as usual.

You see, that's the thing about scandals. They bring problems like this into the light of day. Those who benefited from the corruption, including the kids (whether involved or not, they benefited) get raked over the coals. Hopefully, change comes, and decent people can get back to business of living, and having fun.

ilvteaching

May 14, 2009 - 11:01 pm EDT

No, I am not advocating that this be swept under the rug. I just feel very strongly that it has been handled very badly. I’ll stop talking about Stan and take the AD as an example. He taught 3 history class, maintained the field got the buses, supervised all the games, and, yes, was responsible for eligibility. Most ADs work 10-14 hours a day. Force is a sweet older man who had been out of school for months this year with knee surgery.
He was called downtown on a Monday (under false pretenses) and questioned (not nicely at all) from 10 am until 7pm. Then Thursday evening late, he was called and told to resign by Friday or else. He was threatened with his retirement and his teaching licence. It was a holiday, he couldn’t get in touch with his attorney (GCS planned it that way), and he resigned. All because he “should” have known that 5 students had parents who lied about where their kids live. Should he have been questioned? Sure Written up? Maybe Given advice on how to better manage all of this . .ok. but this?? Everyone knows if they spend 6 weeks investigating the schools they are bound to find other ineligible players. Will they fire all the principals and Ads because they “should” have known? I hope not. There is a BIG difference between sweeping it under the rug and what happened here.
As upset as I have been about this, you would think I care about high school athletics. Other than watching my kids and my students play, I really don’t. But I don’t think the way this was handled and the way these employees were treated, or the timing of it all, bodes well at all for the Guilford County Schools under this superintendent.

thestatelottery

May 14, 2009 - 2:50 pm EDT

It's about time something is done about these abuses. It's unfortunate, but this example needs to be set and continue to be enforced. It's been going on for way too long.

eMail Updates

Advertisement | Advertise with Us

Featured Ads

Search

Advertisement | Advertise with Us
Advertisement | Advertise with Us
Advertisement | Advertise with Us

News & Record Network Sites

Triad Weather

  • Current Condition: PARTLY CLOUDY
  • Current Temperature: 58°
  • UV Idx: 3
  • Forecast High/Low: H: 59° L: 45°

User Tools

  • Social Networking
  • RSS
  • Share
  • Sign in to MyNR

Search