news-record.com

EDUCATION

Advertisement | Advertise with Us

Northern basketball team stripped of championship title

Thursday, May 14, 2009
(Updated Friday, May 15 - 3:35 pm)

Editor's Note: This article incorrectly indicated that Guilford County Schools superintendent Maurice “Mo” Green named specific school employees at Northern High officials who should have known that two basketball players were ineligible. Green did not name the employees.

GREENSBORO — Two months after Northern Guilford made history as the first school to win a state basketball title without a senior on its roster, the school earned another, less noble distinction Wednesday when it became the first Guilford County school to be stripped of a state championship.

The N.C. High School Athletic Association saw to that, vacating the Nighthawks of their 3-A title a day after Guilford County Schools determined the Nighthawks used two players who should not have been attending the school.

Hours after the Nighthawks lost their title, they lost their head coach, too. School Superintendent Maurice “Mo” Green told basketball coach Stan Kowalewski his contract would not be renewed.

Kowalewski criticized the investigation, calling it “flawed from start to finish.” He described schools attorney Jill Wilson, the leader of the six-monthlong investigation, as “obviously an amateur.”

He said school system officials will have to face the wrath of Northern parents, particularly those whose boys played on the basketball team.

“This is not about me; this is about the kids,” he said. “I can assure you (the parents) will rise up and stand for their kids. This is not over.”

It’s not. Green said that the Northern investigation remains open and that other teams — including the football program — are being looked into for ineligible players. Green and Wilson said other Guilford County schools are being investigated, based on findings and accusations that have come out of the Northern probe.

School system officials said Wednesday that five Northern students playing on four athletics teams were determined ineligible based on the state athletics association’s domicile rule. Green said those students will be allowed to finish the school year at Northern but will be sent back to their correct school in the fall. Those students will be ineligible to participate in athletics next year, an indication school officials believe they tried to deceive Northern officials on their residency.

Some of the students ruled ineligible played in more than one sport at Northern, Green said. In addition to the two basketball players, investigators found that:

  • The baseball team played with one ineligible player. The team, which was preparing to play in this week’s first round of the state playoffs, forfeited all its game and was removed from the playoffs. Western Alamance, a wild card team, took Northern’s place in the playoffs. Northeast Guilford, which was out of the playoffs Wednesday morning, became a wild card team Wednesday night.
  • The wrestling team used two ineligible wrestlers. Both have forfeited their matches. Officials are still determining if the team must forfeit overall matches in which those players won.
  • The junior varsity softball team played an ineligible student and must forfeit all its games.
  • A JV cheerleader was also found to be ineligible. Cheerleading is not a sanctioned sport.

The high school association also fined Northern $1,250, or $250 for each infraction. The school must also return more than $7,800 in playoff revenue.

Green declined to name the athletes, citing privacy issues. He said the basketball team lost its state title because school system officials believed the ineligible players should have been caught.

Northern principal Joe Yeager and Athletics Director Derrell Force resigned from Northern on April 10 — the same day school system officials announced they were looking into the eligibility issues.

Wilson said she found “red flags” immediately after looking at some students’ records.

“Those flags should have come up just as quickly” with school officials, she said.

Vacating a state championship is rare in North Carolina. The last time it happened was in 1995, when Cary High lost its state basketball title for using an ineligible player. Que Tucker, deputy executive director of the high school athletics association, said Wednesday she looked at “every angle, every possibility” before making the decision.

Northern defeated Gastonia’s Forestview for the state title on March 14. Tucker said no team would be recognized as the 3-A state champion.

Green said coaches and parents need to be better educated on the system’s residency policy. He hopes to have public meetings to address that issue.

“It’s a sad day for Northern and Guilford County,” Green said. “But we’re going to learn from this and we’re going to get things right.”

Flanked by Wilson and Guilford County Athletics Director Leigh Hebbard at Wednesday’s news conference, Green declined to discuss why Kowalewski’s contract would not be renewed. Green said the status of other coaches is being reviewed.

Kowalewski said Green told him Wednesday the school had found no wrongdoing on Kowalewski’s part. He said Green wanted “a fresh start” to the program.

Kowalewski said Wednesday night he would not recommend his players ever play basketball within Guilford County as long as Green was superintendent, but he reserved most of his anger for Wilson. He accused her of trying to find fault where there was none to justify the cost of the investigation. Wilson and Green said they didn’t know the cost.

Wilson, Kowalewski said, “is obviously an amateur and that her underlings wanted to treat rumor as fact throughout the investigation.”

“In recent days the techniques that (Wilson) used were absolutely despicable, trying to frame me to look like I’ve done something wrong,” he said.

School officials stressed that the findings released Wednesday dealt with eligibility issues related to where students said they lived. Green declined to discuss allegations of academic abuse or recruiting — issues sources have said the school system was looking into. He said investigators were still examining those issues.

School system officials also released more than 1,200 pages of e-mails — conveniently packaged in a box — between Northern officials that were requested by the News & Record and WFMY-2 last year in response to a lawsuit filed by Kowalewski against Northwest Athletics Director John Hughes. Sources have said those e-mails could show Northern coaches were involved in recruiting athletes, a violation of local and NCHSAA rules.

Contact Robert Bell at 373-7055 or robert.bell@news-record.com

Accompanying Photos

File photo (News & Record)

Photo Caption: Northern Guilford basketball coach Stan Kowalewski is hugged by his players after the Nighthawks defeated Gastonia Forestview in the 3-A state championship game in March.

Timeline

2007: Guilford County Schools clears Northern Guilford High’s athletics program of allegations of recruiting.

Fall 2008: Superintendent Maurice “Mo” Green opens a new investigation into Northern Guilford’s athletics program.

April 10: Three Northern employees — principal Joe Yeager, Athletics Director Derrell Force and head custodian Louis Lawson — resign. Schools system officials later announce they are investigating Northern’s athletics program over eligibility issues.

April 16: Lawson, whose son plays for the Northern Guilford basketball team, rescinds his resignation, saying he was coerced.

April 23: The N.C. High School Athletic Association announces that Page High used an unnamed, ineligible player during the 2008 football season. Patricia Hughes says the player is her son, Gabe King. Hughes said Page officials knew her son was ineligible all along. Schools system officials are investigating her allegations.

April 24: Guilford County school board members vote unanimously to fire Lawson.

May 6: Green tells Northern Guilford parents, teachers and students he will investigate other schools if credible evidence is presented.

May 6: Sources tell the News & Record that school system officials are investigating whether Northeast Guilford basketball coach Curtis Hunter attempted to recruit Northern Guilford basketball player Michael Neal last month.

May 13: Guilford County Schools rules that five students at Northern are ineligible because of residency issues. The school has been stripped of its 3-A state championship title. Green says the county is investigating other schools.

Comments

This article has been closed to new comments. Comments are generally closed after 14 days. However, comments may be closed earlier at the discretion of the News & Record.

Inappropriate content? Please notify us.

daveasphalt

May 14, 2009 - 6:25 am EDT

Bang, the evidence is out there! Just do your research of the past! Now let's see if this supt. has the courage to stand up to the money and minority groups that represent these schools.

whatcanIsay

May 14, 2009 - 6:52 am EDT

He will. You better believe that. And all the other schools better be ready to be investigated. He will not stop at one.

Bang201

May 14, 2009 - 9:38 pm EDT

Dave I've done my research like you said..........still nothing. What big money are you referring to? Does anyone have a problem with athletes going to NG for Academic reasons and they haven't graduated anyone yet? How many kids off the coaches AAU team ended up at NG?

Panacea

May 14, 2009 - 1:27 pm EDT

Dave, we don't know that those other schools aren't next . . . .

Page at least disclosed an ineligible player BEFORE the crap hit the fan, showing their officials at least have a clue.

daveasphalt

May 14, 2009 - 3:40 pm EDT

I guess Mo can blame all of this mess on Grier. Lets hope that he does have the ethics and morals to correct the entire school system problem.

Former AD

May 13, 2009 - 9:52 pm EDT

This situation is definitely a tragedy. Unfortunately I have seen this too many times. There are only a handful of people who know what really happened here and who was at fault. It is the duty of the Athletic Director to check all eligibility and approve a teams roster before the season begins. But He/She can only use the information which is provided to them from parents and the district. Right or wrong they must trust this information as credible and correct. In a district the size and complexity of Guilford county the amount of information can be staggering. You could pay a team of people to do just eligibility and they would still be foulable. The rules of athletic eligibility are complex and are written by attorneys who try to cover every single angle that could happen at every school in the state. When you factor in the transfer situation and the verification of where the student actually lives you almost need to have a private detective to investigate each case to be sure. The point is, this could happen to any school at any time, even if they were trying to do the right thing. There is no denying these kids worked hard and were involved in a healthy activity and I am sure had fun doing it. This is a teachable moment for all involved and life lessons will be learned from this terrible situation. Unfortunately it will happen again because it is nearly impossible to prevent.

Bang201

May 13, 2009 - 10:14 pm EDT

Former AD you make some very good points. I'd like to challenge everyone to offer suggestions on how this can be avoided in the future. What can a school do to protect itself from parents who are shopping there kids around?

whatcanIsay

May 13, 2009 - 10:50 pm EDT

Actually, If it is found that a student or parent use fraudelent documents to enroll into the school, then the student is punish and the school do not have to forfiet any games. So, for them to have to forfiet the games, it had to be proven that they knew the address given was false or lead them in the right direction to get it done.

It is more to this story that NO ONE will ever KNOW. They will not disclose details in personnel records. Hence, why the AD and Principal resigned. They are free to apply in another county and state and normally your files are not requested.

nanapapa

May 13, 2009 - 10:53 pm EDT

What a shame for all students everywhere that this could happen to. There should be a way to confirm eligibility. What a shame that a parent would even begin to participate in something that could possibly harm the mental well being of their own child and others. I cannot imagine that the student was not aware of their eligibility. If there is one coach, AD, and/or principal that can stand up and say that they have not participated in this type of activity - I would applaud you. I live in this community and have witnessed the excitement that this school has brought to us all. There are no winners in this scenario - even for the ones that started the "whole investigation." Be careful what YOU wish for, you may get it.

whatcanIsay

May 13, 2009 - 11:12 pm EDT

I think Northwest Guilford already has. But this is the problem. Grown people trying to justify the action of the young ones. Yes, I am sure it goes on, but that do not make it right. If you are a parent and you want your kid to go to a particular school, it is real easy, MOVE. Then nobody will have any problems.

This is the problems that are going on with athletics now days. It is going to come to a point, that coaches do not want to deal with parents shopping their kids. I keep saying it and I will say it again.

If your son or daughter is good enough, THE COLLEGES will find you. You do not have to win a state title or have the best STATS to get that done. Case in point, 3 football players today was offered scholarships from Arkansas from the little town of Stanley County (South Stanley High School). I wonder how they found them.

whatintheworld

May 14, 2009 - 7:09 am EDT

Nanapapa...you're right...the students knew they were ineligible. It's a new school and they'll do anything to go the school of their choice.....even if it means claiming the address of grandparents, divorced parents, brothers or sisters to get residency. It's not the coaches fault or responsibility....it's the parent's. When is the parent going to be held responsible for the actions of their children? The coaches have enough to worry about, so penalize the child for a year and send a message to the parent that this type of behaviour is not allowed and it will stop. Instead we disrupt the family of the coach in an attempt to find a scapegoat. The fault is in the parent's mirror.

Nighthawk

May 13, 2009 - 10:35 pm EDT

Thank you former ad. Your comments are insightful. I personally know of a family that lives outside the NW district but owns a rental property in the NW district and their sons attend NW. One plays soccer and I bet the AD hasn't got a clue. That's asking a bit too much of an AD who also has to teach 3 or 4 classes a day, don't you think?

Bang201

May 14, 2009 - 7:08 am EDT

One paragraph in this story speaks volumes. "Kowaleski said Wednesday night he would not recommend his players ever play basketball within Guiflord County Schools as long as Green was superintendent." In an interview on TV last night he said he had several offers from public schools in other counties. Isn't "recommending where his players play" what started all this mess?

whatintheworld

May 14, 2009 - 7:14 am EDT

Bang201...If someone doesn't play fair, or ignores the rules, you can take your ball and go play where they do. The school system penalized the coaches unfairly....they should have penalized the student so the parent is held accountable for misrepresenting the address of the child. Since the coach knows it is beyond the scope of his ability to make sure the parents aren't lying about the address of record he wants to coach in a different county. He wasn't recruiting them with his comment.

Panacea

May 14, 2009 - 1:32 pm EDT

The problem here is active recruiting is going on. To recruit ineligible players, the coaches have to give parents tips on how to circumvent the system.

Parents who do it on their own are harder to catch, I grant you. But there are other records to look at, like medical records, which will have the correct billing address of the parent no matter where the kid says he lives.

And you can always just look at the phone numbers provided and do a reverse address search. If they don't have a land line, call the parent's employer and verify employment information like addresses (require parents to sign a waiver).

There are lots of ways. Easy ways.

Earl

May 14, 2009 - 8:35 am EDT

This is nothing new, I graduated from Dudley HS in 1980, I had a friend that stayed off of Youngs Mill road, well in South East's district but went to Grimsley and was a starter for their basketball team. As well I had some cousins who were in Smith's district and went to Grimsley as well to play basketball, while their older brother attended Smith. Its about time something was done about this

gsOhboy

May 14, 2009 - 8:47 am EDT

It is a shame this school is being "made an example of" when the plain and simple fact is that it happens all over guilford county and not simply for athletics but also for academics and an overall school environment. The super and investigation team have done an extremely poor job in handling this case from the start, there has been far more rhetoric and rumor than factual communication with the general public and as a result has created a hype and environment at a high school making it near impossible for teenage kids to learn and lead normal high school lives. This investigation has been purposefully put in the limelight, negatively effecting every kid at the school. Remember the majority of this schools population are innocent KIDS, what are you teaching them Mo? That public drama and self righteousness are more important than other people's lives?

tammac

May 14, 2009 - 9:06 am EDT

What is Mo teaching the kids? What about the coaches, former AD, and former principal at Northern? I do not think this set of circumstances was created by the new super. If this whole situation was all smoke and mirrors the principal would never have resigned. Just because someone actually confronts the issue instead of sweeping it under the rug does not make them the root cause of the problem. Maybe other schools are at fault and they should receive punishment as well, but it does not mean that this situation did not need to be confronted and that this school did not violate the rules.

gsOhboy

May 14, 2009 - 9:38 am EDT

It could have easily be handled differently, taking care of all necessary issues without (hopefully) completely affecting every child at a school.

whatcanIsay

May 14, 2009 - 11:29 am EDT

People keep saying how this is affecting the others at school. I been in school long enough to know that after a party this weekend, they will be over it. Yeah, they will talk about it. They will read about it, but it not going to afftect the majority. It looks like it is affecting the adults more (pride) and definitely those that are cheating and still cheating.

eduguytoo

May 14, 2009 - 9:12 am EDT

Thank you, gsOhboy. You are dead nuts on, and it is what nobody seems to comprehend. This ISN'T just about athletic eligibility; athletics are such a small part of ANY school, including Northern Guilford. But the "ripple effect" of what has gone down is significant. Academics and other aspects are suffering BECAUSE of the athletic investigation; it's that simple. Teachers are preoccupied, stressed and upset. Think about it...the leadership of their school, what they were led to believe was top-notch, obviously wasn't. Students are preoccupied, stressed and upset. Time that should be spent preparing for all of the things that happen at the end of a school year (projects, course tests, exams) is compromised. My point all along has been that the timing of this investigation was not great. I will admit that one thing revealed yesterday makes me change my mind a bit...that has to do with eligibility in an still-ongoing sport, baseball. I could accept that for the fairness of teams still in pursuit of post-season play, this aspect of Northern's program probably should have been dealt with now. That would still have created ripples, but not the tidal wave that has come from allowing the entire thing to explode. For the sake of the majority of kids in that school who have done absolutely nothing wrong and whose principal reason for being there is academics, the timing is awful. That's not too hard of a concept. The major uproar could have come a few weeks down the road when the impact would have been much less. But for most folks commenting here, the attitude is: "Hey, you cheat, you get caught, you pay the dues." My child is not a cheater. He is what you call "collateral damage."

your.mom258

May 14, 2009 - 9:21 am EDT

First off I wish we could comment on Coach K's interview on Fox 8. This guy is completely out in left feild. I dont know where this guy came from or what types of programs he has been apart of, but to think that the ineligible players on your STATE CHAMPIONSHIP TEAM would only be punished individually and the team would not be stripped is completly irrational. This is totally rediculous! Its a team sport bro! If you have kids on the court who werent supposed to be there in the first place, then the TEAM is invaild and the CHAMPIONSHIP IS INVALID! I also like that he is questioned about his player's addresses and he responds with "im a basketball coach, im here to coach kids and make a difference blah blah blah" WRONG! If you are the coach in any county in the US, you are responsible to make sure who is allowed to be on the team or else find someone else to investigate it for you. On top of that, if you were a good coach, you wouldnt have put any player whos eledgibility was in question out in a game to play.
I am going to call his bluff on the fact that he has had other coaching offers in other counties. Any AD who wants him at their school is foolish. The real reason im writing this is that I really feel bad for Forestview. They lost the Championship game... they are going to be given an award that had no climatic ending to recieve it... You think they are going to brag to their friends, family, or children about how they won the State title in 2009? Do you think they are going to have a huge school pep ralley for the team when they recieve the trophy? Doubt it, and i know that if i was on the team i wouldnt want any of those belated luxuries that every high school state champion should recieve. The Forestview basketball team has been robbed of a priceless moment and memory that cannot be replaced.
last thing Robert, you are still a moron.

whatintheworld

May 14, 2009 - 9:24 am EDT

Question: Why is it the coaches fault that the parents lied about their address of record? When the child shows up in class the coach he says, "get dressed and we'll get started learning the sport." He shouldn't have to quiz him or make him prove he lives at the appropriate address...that's the office administration's job. Next thing you know there will be a Task Force created to police the school directory. What if it had been a math contest or science fair?

tammac

May 14, 2009 - 9:30 am EDT

The reason I think the coach bears responsibility in this case is he had several players follow him to the school. He coached a community team and then several of those players come to play at Northern. He seems to have an ongoing relationship with the kids on the team so it would be difficult for me to believe he did not know where each of the kids on the team lived or was ignorant of any wrong doing by the parents or student. But that is just my opinion.

bballcrazy.sarah

May 14, 2009 - 11:23 am EDT

Normally you would be right. In this case, Coach K (yeh, I can't beleive he encourages his team to call him that - he should apologize to the real Coach K) was fired from the catholic school in Kernersville because he imported players and had them stay at his house, using his address for registration to qualify them. There is a trail to this guy and a pattern of abuse of the system by him in spite of his protests that he is the innocent victim. Has someone approached the catholic school for a comment? I guess that it would also be intersting to see whether this pattern of importing players into the other teams in Northern began after he joined them. The guys bad news and deserves to be banned from participating in sport at any level. If there really is another county interested in hiring him as a coach, hopefully they are made aware of this situation. My heart goes out to all those kids who worked so hard and didn't try to get around the system.

whatintheworld

May 14, 2009 - 9:38 am EDT

So....What about the 'A' the ineligible student made in English class?.....do we fire the English teacher?

tammac

May 14, 2009 - 9:50 am EDT

Did the student have an ongoing relationship with the English teacher? Did the student transfer to that school to specifically have that English teacher and be a part of that English class?

gsOhboy

May 14, 2009 - 10:54 am EDT

A lot of students (or parents of students) transfer based on the desire to be a part of one school's academic program, or just to be in a superior school environment to the one they should attend based on district, it's commonplace and not just related to athletics.

Maku1da

May 14, 2009 - 11:04 am EDT

tammac, you have expressed your opinion on everything else, why is that question so hard for you answer? YOUR opinion DO NOT MATTER!! Talk is cheap.. Sorry your child couldn't keep up with the COMPETITION!!! and its NOT upto a NON FACULTY Coach to police the kids address.. Its BAD enough that the PRINCIPAL and the AD resign from their position.. The only people that is hurting is the kids.. but I guess that don't matter to you.. LOSER!!!

tammac

May 14, 2009 - 11:20 am EDT

If a student is at a school illegally, and represents an academic team and that team wins say a math competition or English competition, yes the same consequences should apply as they do with sports. The entire academic team should lose the award.

eMail Updates

Advertisement | Advertise with Us

Featured Ads

Search

Advertisement | Advertise with Us
Advertisement | Advertise with Us
Advertisement | Advertise with Us

News & Record Network Sites

Triad Weather

  • Current Condition: FAIR
  • Current Temperature: 46°
  • UV Idx: 0
  • Forecast High/Low: H: 0° L: 39°

User Tools

  • Social Networking
  • RSS
  • Share
  • Sign in to MyNR

Search