news-record.com

EDUCATION

Advertisement | Advertise with Us

Northern basketball team stripped of championship title

Thursday, May 14, 2009
(Updated Friday, May 15 - 3:35 pm)

Editor's Note: This article incorrectly indicated that Guilford County Schools superintendent Maurice “Mo” Green named specific school employees at Northern High officials who should have known that two basketball players were ineligible. Green did not name the employees.

GREENSBORO — Two months after Northern Guilford made history as the first school to win a state basketball title without a senior on its roster, the school earned another, less noble distinction Wednesday when it became the first Guilford County school to be stripped of a state championship.

The N.C. High School Athletic Association saw to that, vacating the Nighthawks of their 3-A title a day after Guilford County Schools determined the Nighthawks used two players who should not have been attending the school.

Hours after the Nighthawks lost their title, they lost their head coach, too. School Superintendent Maurice “Mo” Green told basketball coach Stan Kowalewski his contract would not be renewed.

Kowalewski criticized the investigation, calling it “flawed from start to finish.” He described schools attorney Jill Wilson, the leader of the six-monthlong investigation, as “obviously an amateur.”

He said school system officials will have to face the wrath of Northern parents, particularly those whose boys played on the basketball team.

“This is not about me; this is about the kids,” he said. “I can assure you (the parents) will rise up and stand for their kids. This is not over.”

It’s not. Green said that the Northern investigation remains open and that other teams — including the football program — are being looked into for ineligible players. Green and Wilson said other Guilford County schools are being investigated, based on findings and accusations that have come out of the Northern probe.

School system officials said Wednesday that five Northern students playing on four athletics teams were determined ineligible based on the state athletics association’s domicile rule. Green said those students will be allowed to finish the school year at Northern but will be sent back to their correct school in the fall. Those students will be ineligible to participate in athletics next year, an indication school officials believe they tried to deceive Northern officials on their residency.

Some of the students ruled ineligible played in more than one sport at Northern, Green said. In addition to the two basketball players, investigators found that:

  • The baseball team played with one ineligible player. The team, which was preparing to play in this week’s first round of the state playoffs, forfeited all its game and was removed from the playoffs. Western Alamance, a wild card team, took Northern’s place in the playoffs. Northeast Guilford, which was out of the playoffs Wednesday morning, became a wild card team Wednesday night.
  • The wrestling team used two ineligible wrestlers. Both have forfeited their matches. Officials are still determining if the team must forfeit overall matches in which those players won.
  • The junior varsity softball team played an ineligible student and must forfeit all its games.
  • A JV cheerleader was also found to be ineligible. Cheerleading is not a sanctioned sport.

The high school association also fined Northern $1,250, or $250 for each infraction. The school must also return more than $7,800 in playoff revenue.

Green declined to name the athletes, citing privacy issues. He said the basketball team lost its state title because school system officials believed the ineligible players should have been caught.

Northern principal Joe Yeager and Athletics Director Derrell Force resigned from Northern on April 10 — the same day school system officials announced they were looking into the eligibility issues.

Wilson said she found “red flags” immediately after looking at some students’ records.

“Those flags should have come up just as quickly” with school officials, she said.

Vacating a state championship is rare in North Carolina. The last time it happened was in 1995, when Cary High lost its state basketball title for using an ineligible player. Que Tucker, deputy executive director of the high school athletics association, said Wednesday she looked at “every angle, every possibility” before making the decision.

Northern defeated Gastonia’s Forestview for the state title on March 14. Tucker said no team would be recognized as the 3-A state champion.

Green said coaches and parents need to be better educated on the system’s residency policy. He hopes to have public meetings to address that issue.

“It’s a sad day for Northern and Guilford County,” Green said. “But we’re going to learn from this and we’re going to get things right.”

Flanked by Wilson and Guilford County Athletics Director Leigh Hebbard at Wednesday’s news conference, Green declined to discuss why Kowalewski’s contract would not be renewed. Green said the status of other coaches is being reviewed.

Kowalewski said Green told him Wednesday the school had found no wrongdoing on Kowalewski’s part. He said Green wanted “a fresh start” to the program.

Kowalewski said Wednesday night he would not recommend his players ever play basketball within Guilford County as long as Green was superintendent, but he reserved most of his anger for Wilson. He accused her of trying to find fault where there was none to justify the cost of the investigation. Wilson and Green said they didn’t know the cost.

Wilson, Kowalewski said, “is obviously an amateur and that her underlings wanted to treat rumor as fact throughout the investigation.”

“In recent days the techniques that (Wilson) used were absolutely despicable, trying to frame me to look like I’ve done something wrong,” he said.

School officials stressed that the findings released Wednesday dealt with eligibility issues related to where students said they lived. Green declined to discuss allegations of academic abuse or recruiting — issues sources have said the school system was looking into. He said investigators were still examining those issues.

School system officials also released more than 1,200 pages of e-mails — conveniently packaged in a box — between Northern officials that were requested by the News & Record and WFMY-2 last year in response to a lawsuit filed by Kowalewski against Northwest Athletics Director John Hughes. Sources have said those e-mails could show Northern coaches were involved in recruiting athletes, a violation of local and NCHSAA rules.

Contact Robert Bell at 373-7055 or robert.bell@news-record.com

Accompanying Photos

File photo (News & Record)

Photo Caption: Northern Guilford basketball coach Stan Kowalewski is hugged by his players after the Nighthawks defeated Gastonia Forestview in the 3-A state championship game in March.

Timeline

2007: Guilford County Schools clears Northern Guilford High’s athletics program of allegations of recruiting.

Fall 2008: Superintendent Maurice “Mo” Green opens a new investigation into Northern Guilford’s athletics program.

April 10: Three Northern employees — principal Joe Yeager, Athletics Director Derrell Force and head custodian Louis Lawson — resign. Schools system officials later announce they are investigating Northern’s athletics program over eligibility issues.

April 16: Lawson, whose son plays for the Northern Guilford basketball team, rescinds his resignation, saying he was coerced.

April 23: The N.C. High School Athletic Association announces that Page High used an unnamed, ineligible player during the 2008 football season. Patricia Hughes says the player is her son, Gabe King. Hughes said Page officials knew her son was ineligible all along. Schools system officials are investigating her allegations.

April 24: Guilford County school board members vote unanimously to fire Lawson.

May 6: Green tells Northern Guilford parents, teachers and students he will investigate other schools if credible evidence is presented.

May 6: Sources tell the News & Record that school system officials are investigating whether Northeast Guilford basketball coach Curtis Hunter attempted to recruit Northern Guilford basketball player Michael Neal last month.

May 13: Guilford County Schools rules that five students at Northern are ineligible because of residency issues. The school has been stripped of its 3-A state championship title. Green says the county is investigating other schools.

Comments

This article has been closed to new comments. Comments are generally closed after 14 days. However, comments may be closed earlier at the discretion of the News & Record.

Inappropriate content? Please notify us.

jksal2002

May 13, 2009 - 3:56 pm EDT

Cheaters never win and winners never cheat. Undoubtably some kids and their parents knew what they were doing was wrong and did it anyway. I feel bad for the kids that didn't make the team this year due to the recruiting/cheating that went on.

commonsense

May 14, 2009 - 8:40 am EDT

There is plenty of fault to go around here, however, it is certainly not the superintendent nor the lawyer. Northern and Coach K are clearly at fault in this situation. The guy was fired from Bishop McGuinness several years ago for guess what? You guessed it, recruiting. With a history like his, Northern was idiotic to hire him and is now seeing the consequences from hiring a coach with clear ethical issues. Unfortunately this does stink for the kids and here again is another case of youngsters having to pay for coaching and administrative errors. The hope is that other schools with learn from this and that we can get back to having coaches that abide by the rules and are truly in this for the kids.

Panacea

May 14, 2009 - 1:20 pm EDT

Well, it came out of his own mouth. He can't recommend a student "play anywhere in Guilford County." So . . . either that means he doesn't think anyone should play basketball in Guilford County anymore, since you can only play at the school you're eligible for. Or he really does think it's OK to cherry pick where a student athlete will play at, which is certainly what I heard in this statement.

eduguytoo

May 13, 2009 - 4:17 pm EDT

Glad that this train wreck has reached its terminus. Apparently Mo Green got the message that he needs to deal with important issues IN PERSON and DIRECTLY WITH THOSE MOST AFFECTED. Word is that he actually made a trip himself to the Northern campus today. So he did learn something! Congratulations.

But now that decisions have been rendered, I still go back to something that's seemed quite obvious since the "resignations" on April 10. There is nothing that required that this turmoil had to occur now, and it could have easily and logically have been dealt with on or after June 15. The bulk of students, teachers and parents affiliated with the Northern HS community are completely outside the realm of this garbage. While infractions are not to be condoned, judgment must be used about when and where to make a stand. The timing of this one was very ill-conceived. If the leadership of this school system does not think this will affect student performance on class exams, final projects, EOGs, EOCs, AP tests, etc., they're sadly mistaken. It's already taken a toll. Perhaps the referee has made the right call, but he did so at the wrong time. I've said it before and I'll say it again...Guilford County's children deserve much better than what they're getting.

tammac

May 14, 2009 - 8:49 am EDT

I think the timing had to do with the baseball playoffs. Basketball was not the only team that was affected by ineligible players. The baseball team also had to forfeit games and this affected other schools and the state baseball tournament as a whole. But I do agree that it is awful that the sports teams are dominating what goes on at the school to the detriment of academics.

Illiterati

May 14, 2009 - 9:18 am EDT

Timing is irrelevant. If a student is cheating academically and gets caught during the school year, would it be prudent to postpone punishment to a time more convenient and less supposedly traumatic for everyone? No. In this case, school employees, parents, and students were caught cheating, so they're being punished. Unfortunately it's a situation where others are roped into the punishment by association, but that's what being a team is about: all for one and one for all.

I would hope these teenage students aren't so coddled and delicate that they can't function in these situations. If they can't hack it now, how will they hack it in the workplace? They're teenagers, not preschoolers.

Panacea

May 14, 2009 - 1:21 pm EDT

The only students who should be stressed are the ones with something to hide.

mike.tre

May 13, 2009 - 4:19 pm EDT

Did u read it didn't say they got in trouble for recruiting, they got in trouble for using 2 inelgible players. How is the school supposed to kno that the kids were using a fraud address.

Panacea

May 14, 2009 - 1:23 pm EDT

Because the kids are supposed to provide documentation on where they live to show they are eligible. This includes things like medical records (to show they are fit to play sports), and that information will have the billing address of the parents.

Nighthawk2

May 13, 2009 - 4:20 pm EDT

I truly couldn't be happier about this.

mike.tre

May 13, 2009 - 4:25 pm EDT

Why would u be happy about this when it is involving your school.

EGParent

May 13, 2009 - 4:54 pm EDT

It is the athletic director's job at each school to verify student eligibility and to make sure the law is followed...

Anyone that doubts the coaches, students, and parents of these teams had no idea that a player was ineligible
wears a fools hat...everyone knows...

Timing is perfect...it sends out the right message to these students and parents that tried to cheat the system in front of their peers...They should be ashame of the legacy they have left this school...it will be a long time losing this...

Football must have done a better job at hiding it...or they just know how to go around the rules...

eduguytoo

May 13, 2009 - 6:22 pm EDT

Tell me how the timing is "perfect" for my son who is scheduled to take his AP World History exam at Northern tomorrow morning? His final practice session for that exam this afternoon was canceled because of a "called" faculty meeting that took precedence. The faculty meeting, he was told, relates to the athletic investigation. It is very insensitive for anyone to suggest that this shows perfect timing and is justified. Most of us didn't do squat, and to see my child become an academic victim does not sit well with me. By the same token, I guess we could all point to hardships that sometimes confront a school community...say the untimely death of a student or an unfortunate fire. I suppose anything can be a "learning experience." I find it difficult to find a silver lining in any of these, but if it makes you feel better to suggest "you're getting what you deserve," then so be it.

Illiterati

May 14, 2009 - 8:17 am EDT

If your son's emotional health and academic performance is so closely tied to the well-being of his school's sports programs, I pity him (and his future employers) in the adult workplace.

Illiterati

May 14, 2009 - 8:26 am EDT

Wait a second, are you really equating a bunch of adults and kids sneaking around sports eligibility requirements and getting caught cheating to "untimely death or an unfortunate fire"?!? Are you kidding? Seriously, the priorities of the parents in this situation is appalling.

If this were a ring of adults helping their kids cheat on tests, there would be none of the melodramatic nonsense. This complete lack of common sense and maturity is exactly why I will never vote in favor of bonds for anything school-related.

eduguytoo

May 14, 2009 - 8:49 am EDT

It may come as a shock to you, but high schools are NOT an adult workplace. And the fragility or well-being of my son's emotional stability is none of your business. If my son's academic opportunities are compromised by ANYTHING, then I will be upset. I would submit to you that if some catastrophic event had occurred in your life, immediately having to perform at some high level would likely not occur. The point is, a scheduled review session for an important exam he faced today was CANCELED on Wednesday because a faculty meeting was required at the last minute. Ostensibly (which means it is what he was told), the meeting was called because teachers needed to be briefed about the athletic investigation. This may be over your head, but when it comes to academics, there are no "Mulligans." There are no "do-overs." And I'm not the least bit worried about how my children will fare in the workplace. I'm more concerned about whether there will BE a workplace.

ilvteaching

May 14, 2009 - 6:22 pm EDT

Ignore the idiots, eduguytoo. I am sure that none of the people arguing with you had children taking that AP world exam this morning. A lot of the parents of those kids are upset - as they should be.

ilvteaching

May 14, 2009 - 6:23 pm EDT

Ignore the idiots, eduguytoo. I am sure that none of the people arguing with you had children taking that AP world exam this morning. A lot of the parents of those kids are upset - as they should be.

Illiterati

May 15, 2009 - 8:32 am EDT

This is an issue of sports, not academics. Why would your son be negatively affected in his academics by a sports scandal? So they canceled the review, big deal. At this point, your son should be ready for the exam. A last-minute review isn't going to change his results. Yeah, I know there are no Mulligans in life, but as a retired academic, I am also acutely aware that a last-minute review of a test has minimal impact on students' test scores. I also know that sports programs in general, whether it's a scandal of this nature or a team winning a championship, detract a great deal from students' performance.

The issue of timing is irrelevant to the situation. I still maintain that if it were academic cheating, parents would be up in arms if the school didn't address it right away. Sports always gets a pass, which is the real shame.

basehitter

May 14, 2009 - 9:28 am EDT

Its actually the guidance counslers and SIMS person to get the correct paperwork from the parents who are enrolling their children. The AD relys on them for verification when doing eligibility. I highly doubt that there are many other ADs in the county who will actually drive out to a residence to see if the student actually lives there... as Mr. Force was told he shoudl have done!

jksal2002

May 13, 2009 - 4:55 pm EDT

The cheaters and their kids should have to issue a public apology to the teammates that they effected. The kids on the team who worked very hard. Then send them back to the schools they belong in.

Panacea

May 14, 2009 - 1:24 pm EDT

Maybe because Nighthawk wants his kids to grow up with good moral values, and doesn't want them to grow up feeling entitled or believing anything you can get away with is OK.

SAG1986

May 13, 2009 - 5:33 pm EDT

I agree if something was done wrong people need to be punished but to say you are happy about this is sick. My child is a NGHS student athlete and very upset. For you say such is offensive.

Panacea

May 14, 2009 - 1:26 pm EDT

Too bad so sad.

Take this as a cue as a parent of a student athlete: get on the coaches and the schools and make sure the eligibility rules are being followed.

Too bad your kid is upset. I won't condone hiding the truth to keep kids from getting upset. It's a valuable life lesson to them: don't cheat. Reinforce that, and it will build moral character.

SAG1986

May 14, 2009 - 1:38 pm EDT

I'm didn't hide the truth from my child. He found out about all this before me. Again I think those who did wrong should be punished. Unfortunately all those who did right will be paying the price. In some cases, they will pay more because some of these ineligible players will probably transfer to private schools and play next year without consequences.

Panacea

May 14, 2009 - 5:57 pm EDT

Sorry, I meant the school system not you hiding things.

Yeah, it does suck that kids who did nothing wrong will suffer some consequences along with the guilty. Again: a life lesson. Sleep with dogs, you get fleas. The lesson is, be vigilant to cheaters. This is not the first time, people who did nothing wrong will suffer a consequence for the actions of others. Like the folks who worked at Enron, who lost their jobs.

The innocent student athletes can still play this year. As much as I'd like to see sports get shut down due to this, realistically it is unlikely. Yes, a handful lose a championship. But how can they ethically expect to keep it in light of this scandal?

Beachwalk

May 13, 2009 - 5:14 pm EDT

Good for Mo. Although I do not agree with everything you have done since being in Greensboro, this is something I commend you on.

thestatelottery

May 14, 2009 - 2:50 pm EDT

True that!

daveasphalt

May 13, 2009 - 8:29 pm EDT

Will someone please explain to me how this is any different than what Dudley, Smith, Page and Grimsley have been doing. Is Mo going to strip them and fire coaches and educators.
I challenge our new superintendent to appoint a independent commission to investigate all of our schools and deal with violators in the same manner.
I bet this will not happen.

Bang201

May 13, 2009 - 9:09 pm EDT

Dave I don't think there has been any evidence the Dudley, Smith or Grimsley have done anything wrong. The player at Page lost a year of elgibility according to his mother, which if you are familiar with NCHSAA rules indicates there was proof that he or his parents defrauded the school. I do agree with SAG1986, it is sad, especially for the kids at NG that were legit. I don't claim to know which NG players were ineligble but the truth is they wouldn't have a title to be taken away if it weren't for some of the "new" players.

eMail Updates

Advertisement | Advertise with Us

Featured Ads

Search

Advertisement | Advertise with Us
Advertisement | Advertise with Us
Advertisement | Advertise with Us

News & Record Network Sites

Triad Weather

  • Current Condition: FAIR
  • Current Temperature: 43°
  • UV Idx: 0
  • Forecast High/Low: H: 62° L: 43°

User Tools

  • Social Networking
  • RSS
  • Share
  • Sign in to MyNR

Search