news-record.com

NEWS

Mentally ill man held in ER for 5 days

Friday, May 8, 2009
(Updated 2:00 pm)

GREENSBORO — A mentally ill Greensboro man spent five days at Moses Cone’s emergency room handcuffed to a bed, waiting for transfer to the state’s new, but at-capacity, psychiatric hospital, police said Thursday.

The man, whose name was withheld because of federal privacy rules, grew combative and was served with involuntary commitment papers when he arrived Sunday at the ER, said Capt. Brian James, the patrol operations commander at the Greensboro Police Department.

The patient was ordered for treatment at Central Regional Hospital in Butner, the state hospital intended to replace John Umstead and Dorothea Dix.

But because the hospital that opened last July already has a waiting list, police were left with nowhere to take him. So for five days, officers had to stand guard in pairs, as procedure requires, round the clock at Cone’s ER.

“Once we serve those papers, he’s in our custody at that point,” James said. “And if we’re waiting for a bed, we’re at the mercy of the state. We’re stuck.”

A Cone spokesman, although prohibited from discussing individual patients, agreed. 

“We’re stuck right along with them,” said Doug Allred, noting that not every mental health patient can be treated in Cone’s psychiatric wing or at the short-stay Moses Cone Behavioral Health (formerly Charter), particularly if patients are violent.

Allred said that 24- to 48-hour waits to get into state mental hospitals have become routine, but that a five-day wait in Cone’s ER was, up to now, unheard of.

After inquiries from the News & Record, the newly-hired administrator for state-operated hospitals, Luckey Welsh, said late Thursday that the patient was about to be taken to Butner.

Welsh, hired five weeks ago by the state’s incoming Health and Human Services secretary, said the admissions delays were necessary to insure the safety of current patients and the staff at Central Regional.

The hospital was beset by controversy and threats to its federal funding before it even opened last summer. Since then, treating the most difficult cases and continually understaffed and at capacity, the picture at the hospital has only grown worse.

“We have to serve everyone, and we treat the very sickest individuals,” Welsh said. “Certainly, these delays (in admissions) do trouble us, but they are necessary.”

Welsh said that as stressful as five days and nights in the emergency department must have been for the patient, it was “better than a jail cell” — the de facto holding facility in many counties.

Had the Cone ER patient been a client at Guilford Center, the county mental health agency, he likely could have been held at a padded emergency holding unit at Bellemeade to wait for transfer, said nursing director Paula Snipes.

But once police served the papers at Cone, Capt. James noted, the law dictated that the patient be held at a treatment center and not a jail. There were no hospitals nearby able to accommodate him because he posed a danger.

Greensboro police Chief Tim Bellamy, in a speech earlier this spring to a group of city merchants, wondered aloud what the effect would be on the city of the state psychiatric hospitals having reached capacity.

Wednesday night, watch commander Lt. Karen Walters got a glimpse. Working the 5 p.m. to 5 a.m. shift, she took two cars off street patrol so that two officers could stand guard at the ER, where the mental patient was getting his third meal of the day.

Cone spokesman Allred said there would likely be no bill  — the hospital would just absorb the cost of the five-day stay, as will the police department.

“Did anyone know that it would get to this level? People spending days in an emergency department?” he said. “Clearly, the system isn’t working, and it’s a shame.”

Staff writer Sonja Elmquist contributed to this report.

Contact Lorraine Ahearn at 373-7334 or lorraine.ahearn@news-record.com
 

Comments

This article has been closed to new comments. Comments are generally closed after 14 days. However, comments may be closed earlier at the discretion of the News & Record.

Inappropriate content? Please report abuse.

robbinj2

May 8, 2009 - 9:10 am EDT

Unless this city/state is experiencing some catastrophic event.....no human being should be forced to spend five days waiting in the emergency room because there's no available bed (especially throughout one of the largest healthcare systems in this state). That is absolutely ridiculous and is one more prime example of how our current healthcare systems DO NOT work and are NOT up to par.

Katbyrd

May 8, 2009 - 9:43 am EDT

Quit blaming the healthcare system and place the blame where it belongs --- legislature. It's all about state law.

robbinj2

May 8, 2009 - 2:24 pm EDT

Katbyrd -

For the record....Legislature had no part in seeing that this patient stayed in the ER for 5 days. Legislature had NO control on making a bed/room available for this patient. So...before you start blaming the government...think of the local employees who run this private healthsystem, not state owned.

wildlaurel

May 8, 2009 - 4:11 pm EDT

The local health system - which is a non-profit organization by the way, is not at fault here. They are in pretty much the same position as the police - waiting for a bed in the state hospital - which the legislature controls only by means of increasing funding and therefore available beds.

robbinj2

May 8, 2009 - 6:31 pm EDT

Hmm - and in good conscience, you can honestly say that out of a 5 day period, NOT ONE person was discharged from the entire MCHS, therefore not allowing for ONE available bed/room. Amazing.

John333

May 8, 2009 - 8:03 pm EDT

Ok, for the people that have no idea how the health care system works. Of course there were people that were discharged from the health system. But, who is going to admit this combative man that required two polic officers to hold down. We do not even have psychiatric care there. Who is going to admit him, write his transfere orders and more importantly take responsibility for this man's care, safety and treatment. The answer is no one is available. You want to be angry and you want to fix the health system, well, here is the answer. Put money in to hire more people to take care of an increasingly "failing" population and increasing overstretched health system. Give us money to hire more doctors, staff, expand facilities etc. You can not increase demand and keep supply the same. It is simple economics. If you want the same quality then demand and supply have to increase at the same rate. That is really the root of the problem. Not the "failing" health system. Stop spending money on insurance because every tom, dick and harry can sue for anything where even no wrong doing was done. Get rid of that and you will cut health costs by 25%. I can give you more ideas on how to save more money but this is not the place for it. Thanks for the opportunity for everybody to voice their opinion. Freedom of expression is what makes us great.

Panacea

May 8, 2009 - 8:28 pm EDT

This patient could not go to a general bed in the Cone system. Behavioral Health is the only unit that could take him, but they don't handle violent cases. Such a patient cannot be treated on a general hospital ward: he needs group and individual therapy, as well as a secure environment, and pyschotropic drugs.

Hate to tell ya this folks, but this scenario is not unheard of nationally, just here. I've been an ER nurse for over 10 years, and I've seen many a patient sit, and sit, and sit no treatment, no nothing, until a bed becomes available.

The ER can give drugs to keep him calm, but ER docs don't have the training to adjust pysch meds for the long term. And the behavioral therapy is not available in the ER.

And to think North Carolina wanted to close mental hospitals.

wtnolansr

May 12, 2009 - 4:01 pm EDT

Amen! Emergincy rooms provide necessary and extraordinary crisis psychiatic care. Our system, within and across hospitals need to be better prepared for these patients. We do not thank our ER nurses and doctors and the supporting staff and law enforcement for their crisis stabilization care. .... This is a challenge nationally. Many communities do this better than NC; we have lots of opportunity to improve.

wtnolansr

May 12, 2009 - 3:56 pm EDT

Our state psychiatric hospitals are the ultimate safety net for our treating people like the one who came to our local ER. More people working in those hospitals is probably not the answer to situations like this. Better systems, better collaboration, and better qualilified people should be our focus.

wildlaurel

May 9, 2009 - 10:31 am EDT

They weren't waiting for a bed at Moses Cone Hospital - they were waiting for a bed in a psychiatric hospital. Cone isn't a psych hospital and it doesn't sound like this guy's problem was medical. When someone is committed involuntarily they must be medically cleared to go to a psych unit - which often happens in an ER setting. In this case the unit the patient was headed to was in a state hospital that didn't have an available bed. If anything, MCHS is the one who lost here - the article said they're going to "absorb" the cost of the guy's 5 day stay in the ER - which means they're just going to eat that cost and/or pass it along to people who actually pay their bills.

wtnolansr

May 12, 2009 - 3:53 pm EDT

Excellent question - and goes to the heart of one barrier to statewide success. It is possible that a bed did not open for this Greensboro patient in five days. Why and what we will do about it are next questions.

wtnolansr

May 12, 2009 - 3:50 pm EDT

The legislature, representing you and me and the local ERs throughout the state who routinely experience such events, have an essential role in our overcoming these challenges.

wtnolansr

May 12, 2009 - 3:48 pm EDT

Blame does not help us ensure satisfactory service. Each stakeholder is responsible from the consumer to the Governor. It will take leadership and collaboration by all to achieve a satisfactory solution.

ncb

May 8, 2009 - 9:51 am EDT

Shall I post the stories about the Canadian heath system that typically holds incapacitated seniors in hospital wings because there are not enough beds in old folks homes?

Yeah, didnt think so.Not every situation is about how Bush destroyed the health system and your need to have a nanny state system

robbinj2

May 8, 2009 - 6:32 pm EDT

AMEN.

Panacea

May 9, 2009 - 5:57 pm EDT

Again, gotta burst your bubble. Happens here too, and has for decades.

Nursing homes send patients to the hospital at the drop of a hat, especially if they aren't making money on the patient. Once the patient is in the hospital, they can give the bed to a paying patient, and they don't have to take the old patient back.

There are patients in the hospital who've been there MONTHS because a long term facility cannot be found to take them.

Bush didn't destroy our health care system. Richard Nixon did when he turned HMO's loose on us. Hmm. He was a Republican too.

jac126

May 8, 2009 - 9:40 am EDT

Thank you for making this injustice known to the community. This has happened numerous times in Winston-Salem but it seems to get brushed under the rug. One patient was in the ER for SIX days before being transported!! This is inexcusable. I thought the LMEs were responsible for seeing that patients could be served in their communities. The LME in Winston Salem even got grant money for a pilot crisis program and has contracted for 10 beds at Old Vineyard; however, if the patient is an adult and has Medicaid they cannot be admitted to these beds because as a free standing hospital Old Vineyard cannot bill Medicaid. Please continue your investigative reporting of the injustices in our supposedly "reformed" mental health system. We need to go back to area programs that actually treat patients. This system wasn't perfect but it was much better than what we have now.

wtnolansr

May 12, 2009 - 4:05 pm EDT

Excellent point. The LMEs are a lynchpin in the failed paradigm of "mental health reform". The questions of transparency,r esponsiblity accountability, and consequences for failure are at the crux of any solution we will discover.

sunshine

May 10, 2009 - 11:15 am EDT

This isn't really a shock for those of us familiar with the way the NC Mental Health system works (or doesn't work). But I would certainly rather spend 5 days in Moses Cone ER than spend 5 days at John Umstead Hospital...such an awful place!!

wtnolansr

May 12, 2009 - 4:07 pm EDT

That it may be better to be five days in our ER, gobbling up extraordinary medical and law enforcement resources, than be five days in our state psychiatric hospital shines a light on opportunities we have to improve our mental health care services, institutions, and systems in NC.

eMail Updates

Advertisement | Advertise with Us

Featured Ads

Search

Advertisement | Advertise with Us
Advertisement | Advertise with Us
Advertisement | Advertise with Us

News & Record Network Sites

User Tools

  • Social Networking
  • RSS
  • Share
  • Sign in to MyNR

Search