news-record.com

OPINION

Allen Johnson: Why Alston and Arnold are getting away with closed-door government

Sunday, March 29, 2009
(Updated 3:00 am)

Hold on to your hard hat.

Steve Arnold and Skip Alston's extreme makeover of county government continues unchecked.

Alston, the chairman of the county commissioners, and Arnold, the vice chairman, are not only rearranging the furniture, they are blowing stuff up (in a figurative sense, at least), firing top leaders, laying off people, and re-engineering critical functions.

And they say they are doing it in the "best interests" of the citizens -- even though they haven't seen fit to ask the citizens' opinions -- or in most cases, even their fellow county commissioners'.

Presumably we are supposed to shut up and let them do their thing. After all, they know best.

Input? They don't need no stinkin' input.

Specifically, on the issue of the layoffs, Alston has said, "I don't feel that we have any obligation to let the public know."

The calculated chaos in county government even prompted local business leaders to demand better behavior on the part of both city and county elected leaders in a March 22 op-ed. They have a right to be concerned. Consider the damage (so far):

Alston and Arnold led the ouster in December of County Manager David McNeill, for reasons that remain unclear, and without the benefit of an evaluation.

They eliminated the job of Deputy County Manager Ben Brown.

They forced the resignation of County Attorney Sharron Kurtz.

Since then no fewer than three interim county attorneys have come and gone in the span of only three months.

They have flouted the state's open meetings laws.

They have planned and executed one round of layoffs, cutting 35 positions, with another round on the way.

They essentially have taken the model of county government, in which a manager runs the day-to-day operations, and turned it inside-out. Now they manage the county.

And no one seems to care.

Ten reasons for the collective yawn that has greeted the Alston-Arnold coup:

1. They have the votes. Alston and Arnold swept into power on the winds of an unusual alliance between Democrats and Republicans. As long as those votes hold, they'll be in charge.

2. They are saving us money. The first wave of layoffs alone could amount to $2 million in savings. But what happens if it winds up costing us in critical services and key priorities over the longer term?

3. They are elected from districts. The district system has its advantages. This is not one of them.

Alston has represented District 8 on the board since 1992; Arnold, District 2 since 1990.

They would find it much harder to rule with such impunity if they had to answer to all county voters.

4. One is a Republican and the other, a Democrat. Their alliance blunts the partisan attacks that would usually ensue if both were of one persuasion.

5. They are smart politicians. The idea of an Arnold-Alston team is brilliant in its odd-coupling of two men who are polar opposites on most issues.

6. They have been overshadowed by the upheaval in Greensboro city government -- though arguably not as complete and as potentially devastating as what they're up to.

7. One is black and the other is white. Sadly, too many local problems boil down to race. That's one reason the David Wray/Mitchell Johnson saga may enjoy a longer run than "Cats."

There are more grays than blacks and whites to that imbroglio. But we, as a community, have insisted on shoehorning it into two distinct camps, with each side charging the other with racism.

And by getting rid of both McNeill, who is white, and his deputy, Brown, who is black, within a heartbeat of one another, Arnold and Alston effectively removed race as an issue.

8. We've become so accustomed to low expectations. The commissioners are so typically combative and dysfunctional that we simply see that as the way things are.

9. A clear majority of commissioners gave Alston and Arnold the keys to the county. Bruce Davis, John Parks, Kirk Perkins, Carolyn Coleman and Linda Shaw placed Alston and Arnold in charge. They should share the credit or take the blame for whatever comes of that.

10. They only can get away with whatever we let them get away with. Public officials ultimately answer to the public, even Skip and Steve.

If we say nothing, they'll forge merrily ahead, two bulls left free to roam in a nitroglycerin factory. Remember, there's a still a manager to hire and a budget to pass.

Whatever lasting damage they do we'll inevitably attribute to "those wacky commissioners."

But we're accountable, too. We hired them.

Comments

This article has been closed to new comments. Comments are generally closed after 14 days. However, comments may be closed earlier at the discretion of the News & Record.

Inappropriate content? Please report abuse.

hpulliamjr@triad.rr.com

March 29, 2009 - 8:03 am EDT

All county and municipal elections should be at large.
Abolish all county and municipal,ward/district elections,this is one result of life long tenures of ward/district elections.
In at large elections.2 year terms (frequent elections)NC Constitution,at large elections.where in, all elected officials are accountable to all the voters all the time,is long overdue.
I agree with the politicians in this matter,county/municipal employees should face the real world of economics,no sacred cows allowed.
Fire,police,sanitation first,everything else should be on the chopping block,and supported by methods other than property tax revenues,user fees,donations, private ownership,etc.
The wards/districts,in counties and municipalities,should not be exist period,and surely not be instituted and based on race either!!!
By the way,term limits are in order,and should be implemented for ALL elected officials.

Panacea

March 29, 2009 - 11:42 am EDT

I agree, the district system for the Commissioners needs to go. All should be elected at large.

These guys have elected themselves kings of the county.

DBHaynes

March 31, 2009 - 11:12 am EDT

Mr. Johnson, let me just start by saying that I enjoy reading your editorials each week. This is the first time I have responded to any of the editorials. I don't always agree with your position on items but I really feel that you try to be balanced. With that said, I must say that I get so tired of hearing about our dysfunctional county commissioners! You did a great job outlining why nothing is ever done about them. Why is it that we don't have "balance of power", much like our federal government?

These commissoners should term limits! I don't ever hear about other counties fighting and carrying on like this one. I am from TN and we had issues in the county where I come from, but nothing compared to Guilford county. At least the commissioners were civil and got things done. Also, they didn't have the power that is given to our commissioners.

I just wonder how we get out of this mess? How do we make the county government better? I also think this would go along way in making our schools better.

eMail Updates

Advertisement | Advertise with Us

Featured Ads

Search

Advertisement | Advertise with Us
Advertisement | Advertise with Us
Advertisement | Advertise with Us

News & Record Network Sites

User Tools

  • Social Networking
  • RSS
  • Share
  • Sign in to MyNR

Search