news-record.com

OPINION

A son's crime becomes his mother's punishment

Sunday, March 15, 2009
(Updated 7:04 am)

GREENSBORO — Monica Purvis thinks about her oldest son every day.

Stop by her small apartment at Smith Homes, and she’ll pull a heavy box from her closet and read the stacks of letters she has written her firstborn, encouraging him to stay strong and keep his head up. She calls him “Pa Pa,’’ a nickname he’s had since birth.

In the margins, in big letters, are words Deandre can’t miss: “Watch the Lord move for you,’’ “A son for life’’ and “Pa Pa coming home.’’

“People think I’m crazy,’’ she says. “But God tells me he is coming home, and that’s what I have to rely on.’’

Deandre Purvis will be in jail for a long time.

He got caught in the vicious cycle we all hear about.

No father. A single mother. An impressionable teenager drawn to the glamorous life of a gangster. He committed a string of armed robberies, got popped by the cops and had his mug shot flashed on the 6 o’clock news.

He got locked up, carted away from his hometown and erased from our collective memory.

But not from his mother’s memory.

She wants to start a support group to help mothers like her cope. She wants to get his sentence reduced. But mostly, she wants to give her son some kind of hope.

So, she writes him. Almost every day.

“That is my child,’’ she says.

 

* * *

 

Some would call Deandre Purvis a punk. He was hardened by the streets, lured by an easy buck — no matter the consequences.

Around Thanksgiving 2004, he and a seven-member crew went on a crime spree and toted handguns wherever they went. Deandre, cops say, was the ringleader. Monica refutes that.

They stole a Saturn and robbed three restaurants and four convenience stores. In one case, according to court records, Deandre shot a clerk in the neck. In another, the crew kicked restaurant employees and beat them with brass knuckles, pistols and their fists.

All for $400.

When he was arrested, Deandre had his nickname written on one side of his tennis shoes. On the other side were two words that cops say underscore everything about Deandre’s motivation for breaking bad: GET MONEY.

At the time, Deandre had just turned 17 and had a 10th-grade education. He pleaded guilty to multiple felony counts of armed robbery, kidnapping and assault, and he’ll be in jail until he’s at least 64.

During his plea hearing in June 2005, Monica apologized for her son. Meanwhile, Deandre has apologized for his actions — and to his mother.

“I aprriate how u raised me and all the extra love that u gave me,’’ he wrote in an undated letter. “I wish I can take the pain away. … I said I’m sorry mama. I never ment to hurt you. I never meant to make you cry.’’

Monica keeps that letter in her box, along with the other letters she has written — so many that her son can’t keep them all in prison.

Deandre never knew his dad. Monica Purvis was a single mother with a checkered past who raised three children and worked as a certified nursing assistant.

She often wonders if Deandre’s life would have been different if he had been raised with a father, a strong male role model. She wishes someone had come to her about Deandre’s crimes so she could yank him hard and say, “It’s not OK to do this ungodly stuff!’’

She didn’t know until he was arrested two days before Christmas 2004. Two hours before daybreak, she was awakened by a phone call from her son.

“Pa Pa, where are you? You need to come home.’’

“Mom, I’m in jail, and they’re trying to pin all these robberies on me.’’

“Huh? How much is your bond?’’

“Mom, it’s $1 million. I’m never coming home.’’

 

* * *

 

Monica had Deandre when she was young. She was 20, unmarried, just a few years out of prison herself. A high school dropout raised by her mother and grandmother — Monica didn’t know her father, either — she had served time for stealing.

But once she got pregnant, she felt she had to get right.

She had two more children. The fathers were never involved in their lives. As her kids grew older, she held down a job and kept telling herself, “Monica, you don’t want your kids to go down that same path you did.”

Ask her about it, and she’ll retrieve a folder full of certificates from Deandre’s days at Jones Elementary and Jackson Middle in Greensboro. There, Deandre was an honor-roll student who earned certificates for good attendance and physical fitness.

He played baseball. He fished. He protected his younger siblings, Ashley and Nathan, even telling his sister, “Don’t be getting into no trouble, and don’t be talking to no boys.’’

And he minded his mom. Until age 15.

He started cutting school, hung close to a drug-dealing crowd and got caught driving 100 mph without a license, trying to outrun a state trooper. He ended up in training school for nearly 10 months.

When he came back home in the summer of 2004, he was out the door constantly, drawn to the street, hanging with his old crew. Monica told him to stay away from that crowd. Deandre didn’t listen.

“Pa Pa, please don’t get into trouble,’’ she once pleaded. “I went through all this, and you’re doing the same thing I did.’’

“Mama, you don’t know what you’re talking about,’’ he said.

“Oh, yes I do, honey,’’ Monica told her son. “Your past will haunt you.’’

“Well, Mama, I can get the hell out of this house,’’ he yelled.

“Well, Pa Pa, you know more than me, you go on ahead,’’ Monica yelled back. “Seems I can’t talk any sense into you.’’

Deandre left for two months. He lived in a hotel room with his friends, and during that time, they went on a monthlong crime spree that landed them prison time and prime time on the 6 o’clock news.

“I wished I would’ve beaten the hell out of him,’’ Monica says now. “But I was focusing on my job. I loved working with elderly people, and he wasn’t listening to me.

“But, Lord, sometimes I think it was my fault him getting locked up,’’ she says. “I carry that burden, and I think if he could’ve stayed with me and not stayed with his friends....But that was his other family.

“That stays in the back of my mind,’’ she says. “When he’s doing time, we mothers are doing time.’’

On this particular morning, Monica has a visitor: Carolyn Stover. Stover’s son, Larry Allred, one of Monica’s best friends, is doing time for armed robbery.

Allred calls, gives Monica advice and writes letters to Deandre. Stover simply visits, sits on her couch and says often, “Monica, don’t give up. Prayer changes things.”

A few months after her son’s arrest, Monica lost her low-income apartment on Swann Street because she didn’t pay her light bill. She says she was too preoccupied with going back and forth to court for her son’s case.

She bounced from family to friend and even to Pathways, Greensboro’s shelter for homeless families, before she got an apartment two years ago at Smith Homes, a low-income housing community on the city’s south side.

She says she can’t hold down a job because of her emotional state. She’s going through counseling, and she’s taking pills every day to help her sleep, fight depression and keep an ulcer in check.

Meanwhile, she has had two operations on each foot, paid for by Medicaid. And she lives on $326 a month in food stamps and $61 a week from Ashley’s child support.

Ashley, her 18-year-old daughter, a senior at Smith High, gave birth three weeks ago to Monica’s first grandchild, a girl named Amieria Pierson.

Ashley isn’t married. She plans to graduate from Smith in June and go to GTCC to study nursing. Her 19-year-old brother, Nathan, is expected to graduate from Smith next year.

So at 41, Monica Faye Purvis is a grandmother.

 

* * *

 

Generation after generation.

Monica grew up around crime, got involved in crime and later tried to keep her kids away from crime. She couldn’t save her oldest son.

Now, she depends on government handouts, can’t hold down a job, sees her only daughter getting pregnant and is helping raise her granddaughter in a community that knows crime and violence and prison firsthand.

Monica can’t escape — maybe she refuses to escape — the life around her.

She says she wants to get a job after she finishes counseling. She says she wants to stop getting government assistance. She says she wants to buy a house and live in a safe community.

But she wonders if she ever can. Life has been a constant struggle for her and her children.

“I raised my kids by myself, taught them right from wrong, and I have been a good mother,’’ she says. “But you have to realize when they reach a certain age, it’s up to them to listen and make choices of their own.

“I’ve stuck with my kids through good and hard times, and I’m still sticking with them. But it’s hard. It’s really, really hard.’’

Around Smith Homes, she’s known as “Mama Faye.’’ She spends her days watching her nieces, nephews and now her granddaughter when Ashley goes to school.

And when she does, she’s surrounded by pictures, certificates and dreams of her oldest son.

She sees him on the table in her den, wearing a vest, dress slacks and black shoes for an Easter service. Deandre was no more than 7.

She sees him on a shelf near the TV, wearing his blue graduation gown, taken at Foothills Correctional Institute south of Morganton, after he earned his high school diploma.

And she sees him in her dream, knocking on her front door, walking in and telling her, “I’m here. I’m home.’’

All that helps, especially when she thinks that Deandre may never come home. At least not in her lifetime.

When that hits her, she thinks about the next time she can get to Morganton to see him. Or she simply goes into her bedroom, turns on the local AM gospel station and begins writing another letter to her son.

 

Contact Jeri Rowe at 373-7374 or jeri.rowe@news-record.com

 

Accompanying Photos

Joseph Rodriguez (News & Record)

Photo Caption: Monica Purvis at home with her daughter Ashley.

Additional Photos

Help for parents

Carolyn Stover and Monica Purvis are interested in starting a support group for parents of imprisoned children. Issues to be discussed include ways to cope and ways to push for judicial reform. For information, call 686-5985.

Life without: A letter from prison

Larry Allred, 34, mailed this letter to staff columnist Jeri Rowe from Caswell Correctional Center on Feb. 13. Growing up I was motivated, influenced and fascinated by drug dealers and hustlers. They was the ones who had all the females, cars, money and jewelry. Yes, I was a petty hustler. I started selling drugs and hanging around the wrong crowd at 12 years old. I started stealing bicycles, jacking bakery trucks, neighborhood street gang fighting and other juvenile delinquent activity. ... I didn’t know any better! I had no father around. I had no positive male role models in my life. Young African American males are up against odds. (We) are (in) fatherless households. We have single mothers trying to raise us. Guys like me and Li’l Pa Pa (Deandre) lose because our neighborhoods are full of violence. Our surroundings are not positive. The system (life) is set up to fail guys like me and Deandre. Without positive role models we grow up idolizing gangsters and drug dealers. Watching older guys in the neighborhood, I thought that it was cool to carry guns and sell dope. The other role models we have are rappers. And we all know rap music is not positive. A lot of us want street cred. Getting into trouble is some of our meaning of fun. A lot of our trouble comes from peer pressure. It’s the cool thing to do getting in trouble. Some of us are followers. We be mad at the world because we (are) living in a crowded apartment. We see our mothers, struggling. We see our mothers in domestic violence relationships. Our dreams of being rappers and ballplayers are shattered.

Comments

This article has been closed to new comments. Comments are generally closed after 14 days. However, comments may be closed earlier at the discretion of the News & Record.

Inappropriate content? Please report abuse.

Paul J

March 15, 2009 - 6:16 am EDT

He is where he wanted to BE.

justified

March 15, 2009 - 9:38 am EDT

He is where he should be..............

Lakeshia

March 15, 2009 - 9:33 am EDT

Let's blame all this on racism and let us understand the very necessary concept of racism: for racism allows the blame to be shifted away from those actualy responsible for their own plight. Racism makes it possible for the finger to be pointed elsewhere. If not for racism how else could the so very many problems which exist in the black community be explained away?

johnq2

March 15, 2009 - 10:05 am EDT

Step back and look at the big picture. What patterns and trends do you see? Single parents having multiple children early in life before they can care for themselves they're responsible for another life. It's hard to get an education, build a career and establish yourself when you are alone with young children. No positive male role models, whether it's a grandfather, uncle or pastor. Please!!! Young people build your own life before having children. If you don't know where you're going in life, don't have a plan or just don't care don't drag a child into it. There is plenty of effective birth control. Many of the problems in America, among black and white is lack of morals, values and family. From the CEO's who stole pensions, to the person stealing identities to the thug robbing the local store it's all wrong. It's not ok to steal. It's not ok to sell drugs to make ends meet; that just causes more misery. My heart goes out to Ms. Purvis. If she knows she did all she could to raise him right there's not much she can do. He consciously decided to continue to commit crimes thinking that somehow it would never catch up with him. She's a mother, that's her child and she loves him no matter what. But I would not want him back out on the street anytime soon.

GSXWRIGHT

March 15, 2009 - 10:26 am EDT

I DON'T THINK THAT JUST BECAUSE HE WAS BEING RAISED BY A SINGLE PARENT MAKES ANY DIFFERENCE AS TO WHAT HE IS ACTUALLY RESPONSIBLE FOR. I'M FROM A SINGLE PARENT HOME AND WHAT WAS INSTILLED IN ME WAS TO WORK HARD FOR WHAT I WANTED AND THAT'S WHAT I DID. SO NOW THAT HE'S IN JAIL FOR THE MULTIPLE CRIMES THAT HE'S COMMITTED NOW SHOULD WE BE EXPECTED TO FEEL SORRY FOR HIM??? HOPEFULLY THIS EXPERIENCE MAY CHANGE HIM BUT IF HE HAS COMMITTED THESE HEINUS CRIMES HE SHOULD ACCEPT HIS PUNISHMENT IN FULL. BECAUSE MOM SHOULD REMEMBER THAT THERE WERE VICTUMS TOO.

jafro45

March 15, 2009 - 11:15 am EDT

You have got to be kidding me. Of course he is sorry, he got caught, he ends up right where he belongs PRISON, with his homies. What I do find funny is that you Jeri Rowe write like you really believe that this fool is a victim. Enjoy the rain today I am.

kikablue

March 15, 2009 - 6:16 pm EDT

i REALLY LIKE YOUR COMMENT.

reader276

March 15, 2009 - 11:18 am EDT

Let's go ahead and blame racism, moral standards, and lack of a male authority figure until we're blue in the face...then we'll all be the same color, and that's one down. All we'll need then, apparently, are a bunch of older men standing around us thumping bibles. It's really funny to hear someone blame it on Nodaddy Syndrome here, in the 21st century. It implies that, where raising kids is concerned, a strong-willed woman just can't perform the job. I do not believe this to be true. Here is what most cases are lacking: COMMON SENSE. Forget morals and no male authority figure...and race should just be thrown out all together, let's get over that...poor judgement is the main factor here. As for victims, there are more than you can count. To all of the people who worked alongside of this woman over the years, and came in on YOUR days off when she was too depressed or feeling sorry for herself to work, and still raised your kids not to rob and steal and keep their legs closed, my hat goes off to YOU. Everyone who disagrees with that can hold a telethon, and then go brunch togetherin the Arts District of Winston-Salem next week, contemplating your next PC movement. COMMON SENSE, folks. So easy, even a HIPPIE can do it. Now THAT'S easy!!

b218342@bsnow.net

March 15, 2009 - 12:28 pm EDT

“I aprriate how u raised me and all the extra love that u gave me,’’ he wrote in an undated letter. “I wish I can take the pain away. … I said I’m sorry mama. I never ment to hurt you. I never meant to make you cry..."

but tonight I'm cleanin' out my closet. Anyone else notice but me that he was reciting a song my Eminem?

MyTwoCents

March 16, 2009 - 10:11 am EDT

GOOD CALL.

What a worthless punk.

gsolady29

March 15, 2009 - 12:44 pm EDT

Honestly the only reason why he is sorry is because he got caught...He went on a month long spree and didn't even think about how this would affect his family, his victims families and his community...He belongs in jail and that is where he should stay...the only reason why he finally got is high school diploma is because he is in jail and what else he is going to do...i have no sympathy for him...because there are thousands and millions of children that are raised by single parents and grandparents in the projects, slums and ghettos and they still manage to make a better life for themselves and family and later to return to give back to their communities....as for his sister so what who cares that she give birth at 18...that is so old because teenager's in the hood been having babies for a long time..and she couldn't be carefull and use protection while having sex then why should anyone else care she just another chic in the hood...and now it is up to her make a better life for herself and newborn daughter and make it out of the hood and don't get caught again by having a another baby before she can take care of this one without being on WIC or receiving food stamps....and for the record Deandre sentence should NOT be reduced...let him spend everyday every hour thinking about what he done...

fishgutz

March 15, 2009 - 1:02 pm EDT

What does it have to do with being from a single mom household? Everything. It is the one factor that accounts for the difference between black and white incarceration rates.
It is not "the man." It is not "the system." It is not "racism." That not all children of single mom's end up in jail does not negate of the fact that children, particularly boys, of single mothers are many times more likely to drop out of school, commit crimes and end up in prison, regardless of race or economic status.
Yes the mother in this case bares some responsibility for her son being in prison. She could have been a parent. Should have not had multiple children out of wedlock. She made a lot of bad decisions that no one forced her to make. And the rest of us who are responsible, and put off having children until we were married and could support a family have been paying for her bad decisions. And it sounds like she is still making bad choices and not taking responsibility for her life and her choices.
She can either wallow in self pity and blame everyone else, as she is now doing, a lesson she taught her son well, or she can do something to change her cards.
We live in a land of opportunity. It does not guarantee equal outcome. But anyone with the desire and determination to make a better can do it. Legally.
Stop making excuses. Own one's mistakes. And then stop making the same mistakes and expecting a different outcome.
Bill Cosby was excoriated by the so-called black leadership for calling on men to men and step up and be fathers to their children.
The other side of the coin is the feminist have to stop selling the lie that women do not need men and the children to not need fathers. Men are not just sperm donors to be tossed aside when it becomes inconvenient to have them around.

barbiesmurfette

March 15, 2009 - 6:58 pm EDT

you know, you made the comment about single parents being women and their sons dropping out if school...I am a single parent of 3 beautiful children..I had all 3 of my children in serious relationships with their fathers until they decided that they wanted to be "sperm donors" instead of fathers...I am raising all 3 of my children with the morals of right and wrong and they are happy, know right from wrong and want their education to suceed in life. So please do not judge ALL single mothers as failures...there are some of us who are raising their kids without the support of others

mdoby

March 15, 2009 - 1:41 pm EDT

Well i am a single mother of two boys now 23 and 15 i might not have lived like i should have all the time,but i worked two jobs went to college at the same time and still provided needs and quality time. my 23 year old had good influences as he grew up with in the family,but he now sits in prison with my heart also broke none the less. My youngest son is a good boy with the same influences he will be 16 next month and continues to go to school and be good yes he is still a teenager but a good boy. I feel we all have choices in life we chose either to do good or take the easy way out . It is not my fault or faults that made him chose the life he chose it is his. I hope also to see him on the outside doing good soon,but still again if he has not done something to change before he hits the exit doors he will be right back in. I have went out on a limb more than once now his chances are up he must find a program for transition or he will be back on the street he is grown and there are ways to start over you must want to first, his days at my house is over it is time for me now to be happy and only i can make myself that way quit greiving he did this to himself. The lord might have put him there for a reason at least you can see him wright him talk to him at the rate these kids go they could be dead but now we know where they are my heart is at ease now for awhile. Marcia Doby

Maddie

March 15, 2009 - 4:00 pm EDT

I'm glad there is someone on here who has gone through what this mother is going through.No, you can't blame everything on your environment, home life or race, but it can definitely be a factor.
Look at Bristol Palin and Levi Johnston. I'm sure she was raised correctly, heck that's all her mother campaign about. But she became an unwed teenage mother whose ex-fiance's mother is on trial for selling drugs.
Moral of the story is that this can happen to anyone. Before you start preaching about how other parents are raising their children check and see what you own are doing.

cac2008

March 15, 2009 - 2:37 pm EDT

I read this article and the "Life Without: A Letter From Prison." I cannot believe that these young men (Deandre Purvis and Larry Allred) blame all their troubles on not having a positive male role model in their life. I will give you examples of men raised by single mothers and went on to great things in their lives.

1) Pres. Obama
2) Warrick Dunn (Tampa Bay Buc)
3) Pres. Clinton
4) Lawrence Fishburne (Actor)

And I 'm sure there are many more great men brought up by single mothers; White, Indian, African American, etc. it doens't matter. My brother and myself were raised by a single mother; we aren't "Criminals" or "Products of our Environment." He is a Fireman and I chose to join the U.S. Army. You make your own choices, whether right or wrong. You have to blame yourself, not society nor your community. And how is being a "Rapper" a positive dream to set for yourself or anyone? Most (not all) are the one of the problems in the youth today. Rapping about drugs, domestic violence, murder; making our youth think that it is "cool" to live that kind of lifestyle. I have 2(two) names for ya; Tupac and Biggie Smalls. May they RIP (get the point).

nanamamaedge

March 15, 2009 - 4:16 pm EDT

BULL... I raised two Sons on my own, and they both have lived very productive lives, and have great careers. They
did not go to crime, because I spent my off time with them, instead of letting them run with the "Hood"..

You have to be their Mama, and not their Friend.. This kid made his choices, and now he needs to live with it.
What if the ones he shot had died??? He would probably be getting the needle.. He is where he should be, and
his Mama needs to get some education on how to help other single moms, properly care for their kids, and keep them out of crime. She is serving this time, cause she knows she did something wrong.. But the Son made his own choice.

ANYONE can come out of the Hood, and join the Army. They build men, and women, and not thugs.. This is one
way that anyone can better their lives. You need to keep him where he is..

MyTwoCents

March 16, 2009 - 10:15 am EDT

AMEN! Excellent post.

ladyhairartist

March 15, 2009 - 4:31 pm EDT

His "undated letter" just quotes song lyrics from Tupac and Eminem.

kikablue

March 15, 2009 - 6:12 pm EDT

I'm sorry for the heart break she feels, but he brought this on himself. I am so sick and tired of the old song I didn't know any better. I didn't have a father as a role model, give me a break a lot of others have grown up in crowded homes, with no father. But they didn't turn to crime. Also a lot of them were Black, White, Hispanic a lot of other races so that card doesn't work any more. It's time he faces what he done, no sense crying about it now, he made his choice. Live with it. My tears and sympathy is for the victims. Not for the ones that make the choice to ruin their own lives then try to blame it on everyone else. Get his sentence reduced, NO. YOU DO THE CRIME YOU DO THE TIME.

biggin44

March 16, 2009 - 3:46 am EDT

You have got to be kidding me... why do all of these "thugs" get attention in the news? If she did her job, he would of never disrespected her by leaving the house at all hours. I don't feel bad for him, or her for that matter. This article is a waste of space for more important news.

ncb

March 16, 2009 - 8:39 am EDT

This is perhaps the biggest puff piece the News and Fish Wrap has published in quite sometime. This isnt journalism, its social activism

Merrimit

March 16, 2009 - 9:28 am EDT

There is nothing about this that says racism. By the way I am a 33 year old black man with two degrees. One being sociology and the other an MBA. I grew up in this same area and don't agree with this being racism. This is a sociological issue that get little attention due to the ignorant crying racism. This is a cycle seen in many other races as well. It is for some reason more noticeable in the black community.
Unfortunately the mother didn't realize that her actions carried far greater consequences that just herself. Her past behaviors landed her in a situation where I am sure she didn't have the best job, nor education and therefore even if she found a man because of her history he wouldn't have been a good one. This is a cycle that I have seen working as a social worker in Miami, Fl. The son didn't learn to be a man because of his environment. His environment taught him basic survival. This environment is the result of his mothers past. The mother was product of her mother and her mother's poor skills.
Unfortunately he was probably lost long before this instance. He had signs all along and the mother didnt effectively know what to do and those around her really didnt know either. We learn how to parent from our parents, and notice how the mother was an offender, now her son is one to. Unfortunately the grandchildren will likely be too. She lack the proper skills to teach her children success. She needs to figure out where she can go to get help and save the rest of her family.

MyTwoCents

March 16, 2009 - 10:07 am EDT

I have ZERO sympathy for this guy. He made his bunk, now sleep in it (for the rest of your natural life). I also feel very little empathy for the woman who gave birth to him Being a single parent doesn't excuse horrific behavior - but more often than not, that's the cop out.

The apple doesn't fall far from the tree.

eMail Updates

Advertisement | Advertise with Us

Featured Ads

Search

Advertisement | Advertise with Us
Advertisement | Advertise with Us
Advertisement | Advertise with Us

News & Record Network Sites

User Tools

  • Social Networking
  • RSS
  • Share
  • Sign in to MyNR

Search