news-record.com

OPINION

Advertisement | Advertise with Us

Off the Record

A forum for an exchange of opinions managed by editorial writer Doug Clark.

November 2, 2009

Same 10

No changes in this week's Tarheel Top Ten, thanks to unexpected victories in the Old Dominion:

1. Duke, 5-3 (No. 1 last week)

2. Carolina, 5-3 (2)

3. Wake Forest, 4-5 (3)

4. Elon, 7-1 (4)

5. Appalachian State, 6-2 (5)

6. East Carolina, 5-3 (6)

7. N.C. State, 3-5 (7)

8. Gardner-Webb, 5-3 (8)

9. N.C. A&T, 5-4 (9)

10, UNC-Pembroke, 8-1 (10)

Big Four

Duke, 1-0

Wake, 1-0

Carolina, 0-0

State, 0-2

Foxx: Not so much to fear from terrorists

Maybe another way to look at Rep. Virginia Foxx's "health-care reform is scarier than terrorists" statement today (see Mark's post) is that terrorists aren't so scary.

Is that a vote of confidence for the Obama administration's handle on national security?

Look, you've got to stretch when trying to make sense of anything Virginia Foxx says.

The Democrats are stretching, too, when they respond in a news release: " 'If you haven't met Virginia Foxx, an extreme right wing Republican House Member from North Carolina you should because she, Glenn Beck, Sarah Plain (sic) and Michele Bachmann are the new and most powerful faces of the GOP,' said DNC Communications Director Brad Woodhouse."

Virginia Foxx, one of the top four "new and most powerful faces" of the GOP?

Hardly. She's a low-ranking, minority-party representative who wouldn't get much attention if not for her habit of making dumb statements.

 

Free speech at Carolina

Jay Schalin, writing at Carolina Journal, reviews recent speaking events at UNC-Chapel Hill and reports that the free exchange of ideas once again is respected and protected.

That's good news. Chancellor Holden Thorp surely is due much of the credit for letting it be known back in April that shouting down a speaker on campus was not acceptable. A weaker response from the chancellor would have invited more of the same.

 

 

October 29, 2009

Cheap tickets

I don't know if Phillies fan Susan Finkelstein really was trying to swap sex for World Series tickets, as police charge, or "just flirtin', as she claims.

What I'd question is whether anyone would give up Fall Classic seats so cheap.

Not any real baseball fan, that's for sure.

AP does it again

The Associated Press does it again:

"An early progress report on President Barack Obama's economic recovery plan overstates by thousands the number of jobs created or saved through the stimulus program, a mistake that White House officials promise will be corrected in future reports," AP reports today.

We ran the story in our print edition.

Will White House officials launch an offensive charging that AP "isn't a real news organization" and urge other media to "stop following its lead"?

Seriously, it's good to see AP fact-checking pronouncements by the administration, as it did last week about insurance industry profits. This raises AP's credibility.

The Obama White House seems to expect favorable news coverage, but some skeptical reporting will serve the public better.

October 28, 2009

Easley or Campbell: Who's telling the truth?

"There's a lot about that that I wouldn't know."

A typical statement by Mike Easley during his testimony this morning before the State Board of Elections.

The question was about campaign donations routed through the party, allowing supporters to give more than spending limits would permit.

Like several of yesterday's witnesses, Easley experienced some memory problems.

So many flights around North Carolina during his 16 years in statewide office. He can't recall all the occasions when McQueen Campbell ferried him here and there.

But he remembers very clearly Campbell telling him he was reimbursed for every one of them -- in contrast to Campbell's testimony Monday that he wasn't paid for any of them.

The legal issue is whether they amounted to unreported campaign contributions.

Campbell's not an "imbecile," Easley said. He knew he was supposed to send bills for any services he provided for the candidate.

No, he didn't appear to be an imbecile.

The question is, did he appear to be lying?

Because both he and Easley can't be right.

Samet, Troutman and O'Hale

The Guilford County Bar yesterday nominated Jan H. Samet, Michael K. Troutman and Susan Yu O'Hale for the District Court judge seat being vacated by Patrice Hinnant.

Gov. Bev Perdue must appoint one of the three.

Last month, Perdue appointed Hinnant to the Superior Court bench, replacing retired Judge Henry Frye Jr.

Approximately 500 lawyers registered for Tuesday's meeting, President Richard Manger said -- more than a third of the Guilford County Bar. The vote totals were as follows:

Jan Samet, 275

Michael Troutman, 92

Susan O'Hale, 85

Lonnie Albright, 74

William Davis, 65

Angela Liverman, 60

Joyce Terres, 46

Linda Falls, 30

Lisa Johnson-Tonkins, 27

Cyrus Brown, 22

Moshera Mills, 21

Margaret Dudley, 20

Mary Katherine Nicholson, 18

Jeffrey Berman, 5

The really strong vote for Samet, a High Point attorney with more than 30 years in private practice, should get the governor's attention. But, obviously, Troutman and O'Hale also are respected by their peers.

All in all, I found this to be a very good process for selecting a judge. Members of the Bar know, better than the general public, who would and would not make the best judges.

 

Governor puts everything on the line

A few weeks from now:

The governor calls a meeting of her top advisers — in the Wake County jail.
“I brought you a cake,” one of them says, holding a bakery box.

“Does it have a file under the icing?”

“Governor, breaking out of here is the last thing you want to do.”

“Why is that?”

“Because your poll numbers are shooting up. Getting that contempt-of-court citation is the most popular thing you’ve done all year.”

“I’m not doing this to score political points. I’m doing it to protect the public from murderers and rapists. I said I won’t let those criminals out of prison, and I mean it.”

“The people love it, Governor. There’s going to be a Bust Bev Out rally in front of the jail this afternoon. Tomorrow there’s going to be a protest outside the Supreme Court building. There’s a movement to impeach the justices unless they release you. Of course, we hope they won’t — at least for a while.”

“That’s easy for you to say. I’d rather be sleeping in the Executive Mansion. And Bob misses me.”

“All the better. The people appreciate that you’re suffering on their behalf. They don’t see that from elected leaders very often. Usually it’s the other way around.”

 “I’m happy the public is supporting me, but I’m worried about this getting out of hand. If this is going to turn into a showdown between me and the Supreme Court, everybody could lose.”

“How’s that, Governor?”

“It’s not good for the state if people turn against the judiciary — and if the justices think I’m stirring that up, well, I could be here for a long time.”

“What do you want to do?”

“Call the chief justice and ask her if she’d be kind enough to pay me a visit.”

The next day ...

“Thanks for coming, Madame Chief Justice. Would you like a piece of cake, or pie, or some cookies? I’ve got more baked goods here than the State Fair.”

“No, thanks, Governor. I lost my appetite when I had to walk through a mob outside the courthouse screaming for my impeachment.”

“Well, people can get carried away. Surely, there’s no impeachment movement in the legislature.”

“It was a mob of legislators!”

“Oh. Well, you know they just follow the political winds. This will blow over soon.”

“When?”

“When the courts rule those criminals should stay behind bars and I should get out.”

“Governor, I am not going to negotiate legal matters. The courts have ruled according to the law without any consideration for politics or public opinion.”

“Obviously. But judges are still elected by the people. And they’re subject to removal for misconduct in office or failure to perform their duties, as determined by the legislature. I don’t know about you, but I’d consider myself derelict in my duties if I agreed to let killers and rapists out of prison. And I think a lot of legislators feel the same way.”

“Do they? You know this is all a result of laws passed by the legislature and policies set by the Department of Correction? Don’t blame the courts.”

“I’m not blaming anyone. I’m just carrying out my responsibilities the best I can.”

“You’re required by your oath of office and the constitution to carry out the law.”

“Right. I’m just seeking clarification of the law. And until I get it, I’m not letting any killers and rapists loose.”

“The law has seemed very clear to the courts so far.”

“So, I guess we’re just at an impasse then, aren’t we?”

“Not necessarily.”

“What do you mean?”

“I mean there’s a constitutional requirement that 'the governor shall reside at the seat of government of this state.’ ”

“So? I reside at the Executive Mansion in Raleigh.”

“It appears to me that you presently reside, and will continue to reside as long as the court finds you in contempt, here in the Wake County Detention Center — which is clearly not located within the Raleigh city limits. One also could make a case that your incarceration here amounts to physical incapacitation. These are grounds for your removal from office. I should be having this conversation with the lieutenant governor, who could be your successor very soon.”

“You wouldn’t dare.”

“I can’t allow a political assault on our courts, for any reason.”

“Now wait a minute. I can see your point.”

“Good. Let’s talk. I think I’d like some cake after all.”

Thanks for reading. You can call me at 373-7039, email me at dgclark@news-record.com, or post a comment here.

October 27, 2009

Who wants to be a judge?

Quite a mob of folks.

Well, 14, to be exact.

Fourteen Guilford County attorneys are vying to replace Patrice Hinnant as a District Court judge.

Hinnant was appointed last month to fill the Superior Court vacancy created by the retirement of Henry Frye Jr.

The governor in turn will name someone to replace Hinnant. But she'll have to choose from among three candidates submitted by the Guilford County Bar.

The Bar meets at 4 this afternoon in the Old County Courthouse to select those three.

The 14 contenders are:

Lonnie G. Albright III, a Greensboro atttorney in private practice. Law degree: N.C. Central 1986. 

Jeffrey S. Berman, Greensboro, private practice, Toledo College of Law 1987.

Cyrus J. Brown, Greensboro, assistant district attorney, Thomas M. Cooley Law School 2001.

William B. Davis, Greensboro, assistant public defender, Duke 1998.

Margaret A. Dudley, Greensboro, private practice, Howard 1974.

Linda L. Falls, Greensboro, assistant district attorney, N.C. Central 1987.

Lisa Johnson-Tonkins, Greensboro, assistant district attorney, N.C. Central 2003.

Angela F. Liverman, Greensboro, deputy county attorney, Wake Forest 1991.

Moshera Mills, Greensboro, private practice, N.C. Central 2001.

Mary Katherine Nicholson, Greensboro, private practice, Wake Forest 1976.

Susan Yu O'Hale, Greensboro, assistant district attorney, Campbell 1991.

Jan H. Samet, High Point, private practice, North Carolina 1973.

Joyce L. Terres, High Point, private practice, Wake Forest 1990.

Michael K. Troutman, Greensboro, assistant public defender, N.C. Central 1993.

This should be an interesting Bar meeting. The field is varied in age and experience. I like the fact that there are several veteran attorneys interested in serving as a District Court judge.

  

Easley's being wrung out

Lots of Mike Easley's dirty laundry is being wrung out at the State Board of Elections hearings this week.

It looks bad, so far, for the N.C. Democratic Party, too. Testimony yesterday indicates the Easley campaign and the party worked together to funnel contributions through the party to the campaign and, in some instances, might have seen to it that donors were rewarded.

The Easley defense strategy might be to cast blame at others: Good 'ol Mike never asked or ordered anyone to break rules on his behalf.

We'll see how that holds up.

Interested in watching when the hearings resume at 9:30 this morning? The N&O has livestream.

The Locker Room is live blogging.

And, of course, Mark is there with coverage.

The State Board of Elections is doing a good job of unraveling this tangled trail of apparent malfeasance. Easley stained the state's reputation, and a good scrubbing is due.

About the Author

eMail Updates

Advertisement | Advertise with Us

Featured Ads

Search

Advertisement | Advertise with Us
Advertisement | Advertise with Us
Advertisement | Advertise with Us

News & Record Network Sites

Triad Weather

  • Current Condition: CLOUDY
  • Current Temperature: 49°
  • UV Idx: 0
  • Forecast High/Low: H: 0° L: 46°

User Tools

  • Social Networking
  • RSS
  • Share
  • Sign in to MyNR

Search